Chapter 15: The Other Option

The weird thing about almost-moments is that they do not disappear just because school continues.

They follow you. Into class. Into lunch.

Into whatever aggressively normal outdoor seating area Fletcher Academy had apparently built to make rich students look casual in expensive lighting.

I sat on the low stone wall near the courtyard lawn with my iced coffee beside me, pretending I was enjoying the breeze and not replaying the exact look on Ryker’s face when he opened that study room door yesterday.

Not shocked. Not confused. Just… aware.

Because confusion I could work with. Confusion was fixable. Awareness meant there had been something there to notice.

I stared out at the grass where students sat in neat, effortless groups, laughing like nobody at this school had ever had a private breakdown while keeping a straight face.

Krizzy was somewhere behind me with Jake and Franco, arguing about whether one bad quiz grade counted as academic decline or just a personality flaw.

Jacob was nearby too, quiet as usual, which somehow made him seem even more observant.

Normal afternoon. Casual. Harmless.

Which would have been comforting if my nervous system had not chosen betrayal as its current personality.

I picked up my drink, took one sip, and realized it had gone watery.

Of course it had. Even my coffee had given up on me.

“You look like you’re thinking too much.”

I glanced up.

Ryker stood in front of me with the kind of easy posture that should have been illegal in stressful environments.

One hand in his pocket. Sunlight catching the edge of his grin.

Entirely too calm for someone who had recently witnessed the emotional collapse of my self-control.

“I am thinking about the appropriate amount,” I said.

He sat beside me without asking, which somehow felt normal coming from him.

“That’s not true.”

“It is absolutely true.”

Ryker leaned back, bracing one arm behind him.

“No. The appropriate amount is medium concern. You look like you’re mentally writing a legal defense.”

I laughed. “That is a very dramatic accusation.”

“You seem dramatic today.”

“I’m always dramatic. I just usually hide it better.”

“Fair.”

That was the thing with Ryker. Talking to him never felt like stepping into a trap.

There was no weird power shift. No sense that one wrong sentence would change the air around us.

With him, conversation just… happened.

Easy. Natural. Human. Dangerously human, actually.

He glanced at me. “Bad day?”

“Define bad.”

“You’re deflecting.”

“I prefer the term redirecting.”

“That’s just deflecting with better branding.”

I smiled despite myself and looked down at my cup. “I’m fine.”

Ryker made a quiet sound that said he did not believe me.

“You know that answer has never convinced anyone, right?”

“It has convinced several people.”

“Name one.”

I opened my mouth, then closed it again.

He nodded once. “Exactly.”

Annoying. Warm. Slightly smug.

Safe. And maybe that was the problem.

Because I could feel myself relaxing anyway. My shoulders loosened. My breathing evened out.

The noise in my head dropped to something almost manageable.

This is easy, I thought.

This is safe.

From behind us, Franco called,

“If you two get any more serious over there, I’m reporting it as suspicious behavior.”

Ryker didn’t turn. “Mind your business.”

“I am,” Franco said. “This is my business now.”

Jake’s voice followed. “Everything becomes Franco’s business when he’s bored.”

Krizzy snorted. “That’s because his real hobby is surveillance.”

Their voices folded into the afternoon around us—familiar, chaotic, weirdly comforting.

I turned slightly toward them. And that was when I saw him.

Across the courtyard, near the main path, Isaac stood completely still.

People moved around him, past him, beside him. But none of that changed the fact that he felt separate from everything else, like the space around him had different rules.

My stomach dropped so fast it was honestly insulting.

Ryker was saying something beside me, but I only caught half of it because suddenly all I could hear was my pulse.

Isaac’s gaze was already on us.

On me. On Ryker sitting too close.

On the fact that I had been laughing a second ago like my life had not become a deeply inconvenient emotional problem.

Nothing around me changed. No one gasped. No dramatic music played, which felt like a missed opportunity.

But something in me shifted instantly.

Ryker felt it too, I think, because his voice paused before he followed my line of sight.

He didn’t say Isaac’s name.

That is the opposite of safe.

For one stupid second, I hated that he was far away.

That was the truly offensive part.

Not that Isaac was watching. Not that Ryker was beside me. Not even that my life had somehow developed a completely unnecessary triangle-shaped complication.

It was that distance should have made this easier.

It did not. Ryker made sense.

That was the plain, obvious, deeply inconvenient truth.

He was kind without making it a performance. Easy without being shallow.

The kind of person who noticed when you were spiraling and pulled you back without making you feel pathetic about it.

Being around him did not feel like standing too close to a fire and pretending I was not warm.

Being around him felt possible.

Reasonable.

Safe.

And across the courtyard, Isaac was still looking at me like none of those things mattered.

Like easy was not the point.

Like safe had never been the point.

My grip tightened around the plastic cup.

“This is ridiculous,” I muttered.

Ryker glanced at me. “You say that like it narrows things down.”

Normally, I would have laughed.

Normally, that would have helped.

But Isaac was still there, quiet and still and impossible to ignore, and suddenly the space between what I should feel and what I actually felt seemed bigger than the whole courtyard.

One makes sense.

One doesn’t.

So why is the wrong one harder to ignore?

The thought hit hard enough that I looked away first.

Cowardly. Efficient. Necessary.

I stood before I could think too much about it, slinging my bag over my shoulder.

Ryker straightened beside me immediately, his expression changing just enough to tell me he noticed.

“Are you leaving?”

“Probably,” I said.

He looked at me for a second, then nodded once. No pressure. No challenge. Just space.

And that should have answered something.

It should have made the choice clearer.

Instead, as I stepped away, I could still feel Isaac’s gaze across the courtyard like the beginning of a bad decision I had not made yet.

And suddenly, I didn’t know who I was supposed to walk away from.