Chapter 14: The Interrupted Moment
Isaac Fletcher was becoming a pattern, and I hated patterns I couldn’t control.
Especially this one.
Especially when it involved him saying something infuriating in a hallway and me still ending up outside the study room like I had not, in fact, spent the last hour mentally arguing with his existence.
“You’re the one who keeps coming back.”
He was wrong.
This was tutoring. A scheduled academic obligation. A normal school thing tied to grades, deadlines, and my ongoing commitment to not destroying my scholarship for a boy with weaponized eye contact.
That was the official version, anyway.
The less official version was that my hand tightened around the study room handle for half a second before I pushed the door open.
Isaac sat by the window with his notes open, looking so composed it felt offensive.
Like the hallway hadn’t happened. Like he hadn’t said one sentence and left it stuck in my head all afternoon.
His eyes lifted to mine as I walked in.
I shut the door behind me. “You’re early.”
His gaze stayed on mine. “You came.”
I hated how much that landed.
“I usually do,” I said, dropping my bag onto the chair beside me. “That’s how schedules work.”
Something in his expression almost shifted.
Which was somehow more irritating than a real reaction.
I sat across from him and opened my notebook like I was here for academics and not because he had been standing too close to me in a hallway not long ago.
“The project,” I said.
“The project,” he repeated.
Silence settled between us, the kind that made the room feel smaller.
I reached for my pen just as he reached for the paper between us. My fingers stopped short before they could brush his.
I pulled back first.
His gaze dropped to my hand, then returned to my face.
I hated that too.
“You could at least pretend to care about the assignment,” I said.
“I’m here.”
“That’s not the same thing.”
His voice stayed even. “No?”
That one word had no business sounding like that.
I looked back at my notes, because looking at him felt like cooperating with my own downfall.
We were repeating a pattern.
This was a bad pattern.
I should have stayed angry. Angry was useful. It kept me from noticing stupid things, like the way his sleeves were pushed up or how he made sitting still feel threatening.
Instead, I said, “Can you stop looking at me like that?”
“Like what?”
Like you know exactly why I came. Like the hallway is still here. Like you’re waiting for me to prove you right.
“You’re being annoying on purpose,” I muttered.
That almost made him smile.
“You seem tense,” he said.
I looked up. “You think?”
“I think you’re still thinking about earlier.”
Heat rushed to my face. Humiliating.
I shut my notebook. “You don’t get to say something like that and then act normal.”
His expression didn’t change. “How should I act?”
Worse. Sorry. Less calm. Human, maybe. Instead, he stood.
The room instantly felt smaller.
“Isaac,” I said.
It should have sounded like a warning. It didn’t.
He stopped in front of me, close enough that I had to tip my chin up. Not touching. Still too close.
My chair suddenly felt like a bad decision.
“You came back,” he said quietly.
“This is tutoring.”
His eyes stayed on mine. “Is that what this feels like?”
No. It felt like making the same mistake twice and being smart enough to know it.
“Yes,” I said. A lie. A weak one.
His hand settled on the back of my chair.
Not trapping me. Not helping either.
My heartbeat was officially embarrassing.
The door opened. I jerked back.
Ryker stood in the doorway, one hand still on the handle, his gaze moving from me to Isaac and back again. He took in the distance between us—or the lack of it.
His brows lifted. “Am I interrupting something?”
For one terrible second, nobody spoke.
Isaac stepped back first. The shift was small, but I felt it anyway.
Ryker pushed the door wider and looked at me.
“You okay?”
And that was the problem with Ryker.
He asked questions like a normal person.
I cleared my throat and grabbed my notebook like it could restore the last thirty seconds of my life.
“Obviously.”
Ryker’s mouth tilted. “That sounded fake.”
“Everything sounds fake when I’m academically stressed,” I said.
Ryker stepped inside. “That did not look academic.”
I opened my mouth, found nothing safe to say, and gave up.
Across from us, Isaac said,
“Why are you here?”
His voice was calm, but colder now. Ryker glanced at him, unfazed.
“Mrs. Alvarez wanted the project outlines before last period. Mrs. Vale reminded us, but apparently we’re not trusted with basic instructions.”
That made the whole thing feel annoyingly school-real while my heart was still in an active crisis.
Ryker lifted the folder in his hand.
“You looked like you were about to forget yours. Or pass out. Could’ve gone either way.”
I blinked. “That is a weirdly specific read.”
“I’m observant,” he said. It was such a small thing. Helpful. Easy.
“Thanks,” I said.
He gave me a quick half-smile. “You’re welcome.”
Talking to Ryker felt easy. Standing near him felt easy. Nothing in me was bracing for impact.
So why did that make the other side of the room feel sharper?
Why did I still know exactly where Isaac was without looking?
Why was that worse?
Isaac picked up his pen, then set it down again. Quiet. Controlled. Colder than silence.
“We’re done here anyway,” he said.
My eyes snapped to his face.
Done?
The word landed harder than it should have.
Ryker looked between us again, and this time I was pretty sure he understood there was something under the surface here. Something messy.
He stepped closer to my chair, casual enough to mean nothing. Protective enough to mean exactly that.
“You coming?” he asked.
A normal question. That was the terrifying part.
Because one answer made sense. One answer felt safe.
And still—
“Yeah,” I said, tightening my grip on my notebook.
Isaac’s expression didn’t change.
Ryker picked up my project outline and handed it to me before I could humiliate myself by dropping it.
“Come on,” he said lightly. “I’ll walk with you.”
Normal words. Harmless words.
Not words that should have made the room feel like a choice.
I stood and tried not to look at Isaac.
Failed, obviously.
His gaze met mine for one brief second—cool, unreadable, and somehow still the loudest thing in the room.
Then he looked away first. That should have felt like relief. It didn’t.
I followed Ryker to the door, painfully aware of how easy it was to move beside him.
And how none of that stopped Isaac from staying under my skin like a problem I hadn’t solved.
As Ryker opened the door, he glanced down at me.
“You know you don’t always have to stay in rooms that make you uncomfortable, right?”
My chest tightened.
Because I wasn’t sure if he meant the study room—or Isaac.