Chapter 64: 44| Witness-1

┏━━━✦❘༻༺❘✦━━━┓ Witness ┗━━━✦❘༻༺❘✦━━━┛ Chapter 44: Witness (Tristan's POV) Something had been off with Amara the entire flight there. In fact, I noticed it almost immediately after we met her Dad. He didn't exactly love me and I didn't exactly make the ideal first impression either. But then again, I never got the chance to make that first impression because Mr. Milano had known me long before Amara and I got together. It took me a moment to figure it out: He doesn't trust me. Certainly, he voiced his concerns to Amara, as he should have. But now… Amara doesn't trust me. Again. She wouldn't tell me what was wrong at first but when she pushed me away at her apartment, I felt myself crumble a little. It felt like everything I was working toward, everything I achieved so far was crushed. Like all the efforts I made to gain her trust were in vain because one comment from someone changed her mind again. It was breaking my heart to see her like this and it killed me that she wouldn't trust me. She was fucking breaking my heart. But I had to remind myself it wasn't just one little comment and it wasn't from a stranger. Her Dad was the most important person in her life and I was okay with being second to that. But I couldn't stand anybody's words, even his, shaking Amara's trust in me. So, Mr. Milano would just have to wait until we returned to start liking me because I would make sure he did. The flight was long and exhausting, almost eleven hours, and with a six-hour time difference, I braced myself for jet lag. We had just over an hour left to land when Amara woke up, a few minutes after me. Lifting her head off my shoulder and unwrapping her arm from mine, she grabbed it and pulled it around her shoulder, snuggling up against me. "How much longer?" she mumbled sleepily. "An hour," I whispered, my lips brushing against her temple, resting there. "We should reach there by three in the afternoon, Sicily time." She let out a soft, sleepy chuckle. "Finally figured out where we're going, hmm?" "Hmm," I glanced down at her. I realized she wasn't telling me because she was afraid at that moment. Perhaps afraid that I would tell Michael. A few minutes went by before she lifted her head and turned to look at me. "Tristan, I'm sorry," she said. "For what, Malyshka?" Her gaze dropped to my lips briefly. "For not trusting you," she whispered. "I doubted you." "It was valid." "No," she shook her head, "no, it wasn't. You've done nothing to make me doubt you. You've done everything you could have to gain my trust." "I owe it to you." Her gaze softened as she met mine. "I didn't say it back," she mumbled in realization. "Before we left my apartment, you said you loved me and I didn't say it back." I noticed it but didn't have it in me to question her. "I love you," she said urgently, "I love you so much, it hurts." "No, Amara. I don't want it to hurt." She leaned forward, leaving a soft kiss against my lips before drawing back and dropping her head against my arm. "I love you," I told her, lifting my hand to curl her hair behind her ear, brushing it over her shoulder and away from her neck. "I love you too," she whispered, leaving a gentle kiss on my neck. "How do you feel about going home?" I asked, absentmindedly running my fingers along the side of her neck and collarbone. "Strange," she admitted, "it's been… twenty years since I stayed in that house. When I went to Italy three years ago, I couldn't stay there all alone. Dad had it rebuilt right after the fire. You know, he really tried to take me back there, to make sure I didn't grow to hate a place I called home. Every summer, every Christmas, he'd take me there. And I just…" She gave me a small shrug. "I couldn't even go inside. I'd thrash in his arms if he tried to carry me. Once, just once, he took me in there, held me tight, and for the first and last time, snapped at me. He shouted my name and I went… so still in his arms. Then he explained calmly, like he always does, and told me that this was my home and I couldn't let someone else ruin that." She turned to me. "He never forced me there after he knew I understood." "He's the best father anyone could ask for." "He really is," she said quietly, "I'm worried about him, Tristan." I paused for a beat. "Trust me, he can take care of himself. From what I saw yesterday, he'll be just fine, Amara." She let out a soft laugh and squeezed my waist lightly where her arm stayed loosely draped over it. "Did he scare you?" "Shitless," I admitted blatantly. "I was…" I trailed off, tilting my head slightly as I let out a breathy chuckle, "I was fucking terrified." She laughed a little louder with me before reaching up to trace my jaw. "He will love you. He just needs time, you know." I nodded with a soft hum. "Considering he's aware I was planning to kill you." "I really don't know how he figured it out." "Your father's a genius. It's the only explanation." She smiled sheepishly and left a quick kiss on my cheek. We landed shortly after and got off the plane while our luggage was unloaded and steered toward the bright cherry red convertible Cadillac with a security guard waiting in front of it, keys in hand. "Did you choose it?" I asked as we made our way to the car. She let out a soft laugh and glanced at me. "Dad chose it. We're in Sicily, Tristan. I can't bring you to Italy and let you miss out." She grinned, taking the keys from the guard and rounding off to the driver's side, shooting me a quick wink. Once our bags were lodged in the trunk, she thanked the staff and security for their help and then drove off. I watched her as she steered the wheel steadily with one hand while opening the glove compartment in front of me. "Can you hand me the sunglasses?" she asked, keeping her gaze on the road.