Chapter 63: 43| Home

┏━━━✦❘༻༺❘✦━━━┓ Home ┗━━━✦❘༻༺❘✦━━━┛ I was still puzzled and processing everything Dad had just said when he picked up his suit and walked toward the door. Pausing a few feet short of it, he turned around and called me. "Amara," he said, beckoning me over. Glancing at Tristan, I walked forward and stopped at his side while Tristan stayed in his spot, waiting. "I know this is all being thrown at you," he said, handing me his suit as he smoothly rolled his sleeves down and snapped his cufflinks back on. "But I need you to move quickly and covertly. I know you trust Tristan but-" "You don't," I said knowingly. "No," he admitted, "I don't. Were you ever planning to tell me he had been trying to kill you?" Releasing a small huff, he stared at me expectantly. He was furious. It was hard to know if he was angry or not but I'd learned how to read him over the years. Even though he never openly expressed his anger or lashed out at anyone, his silence and the storm in his eyes told me enough. "How do you know that?" I asked hesitantly. "I keep my eyes on you, Amara. And I know you hate it but you have to understand that it is a matter of your safety. I can't trust anyone other than myself. He's been trying to kill you and you love him?" "I do, Dad." "You love him?" he asked again in disbelief. "I do," I affirmed. "I trust him. I know that you have no reason to but he's earned my trust. Can you at least give him a chance?" "That is precisely what I'm doing. For you." I held his gaze. "I appreciate it, Dad." "Don't, not just yet. If I find out he tried something or that he betrayed you, I will kill him with my bare hands, Amara. Nobody is going to hurt you, I promised you that the night I saved you and promised myself the same thing the day you became my daughter. Then again, you've always been my daughter. I may not trust him but I trust you and that's why I'm giving him this chance. I'm doing it for you, cara mia." He took in a slightly shaky breath. "Promise me you'll be safe. You'll come back home with or without him, Amara." I nodded slowly. "I promise." But I didn't know if I had it in my heart to come home without Tristan. I had no idea what I would do or how much it would ruin me if I found out that Tristan had turned on me, if this was just a game to him all along. I trusted him enough that I didn't want to doubt him. My instincts allowed me to put my faith in him and so I did, even if Dad disagreed. "Dad, there's something else I need to ask you," I said. He nodded, "Go ahead." I glanced at Tristan and found him gathering all our things. "Michael told Tristan that you… that you killed his parents," I whispered softly. "Is it true? Did you kill them?" He held my gaze blankly for a minute. "Do you believe him?" "I don't want to," I answered truthfully. "Does Tristan believe him?" "I don't know. But what I do know is that he refuses to let that come between us. Even if you did, he doesn't blame me." "I didn't kill them, Amara," he said. "I hardly knew them. This is Michael's last, desperate attempt to cover his tracks. He lied to Tristan so that he would kill you and he would never be caught for what he did to your parents." "But what about Tristan's parents? Who killed them?" "I suppose that's a question you should ask Michael before you kill him." I let out a soft sigh and my gaze dropped to the ground as I shifted my weight. "Amara, trust no one," Dad said, "be safe. Instead of losing out on more time, pack your things and leave. Before Michael finds out." "And you?" "What about me?" "What if he tries to hurt you? What am I supposed to do then?" I scoffed. "You're all I have left." He chuckled softly before glancing at Tristan pointedly. "No, I'm not." "Dad, please." "I'm staying back to keep him away from you, Amara. I'm staying back so Michael can't find you. When you go there, you will not call me. Don't reach out to anyone in New York and tell Tristan to do the same. Promise me." "I promise," I mumbled before he patted my head lightly and then left. I walked back to Tristan feeling all the more puzzled and completely torn. Suddenly, I didn't know who I could trust anymore. I didn't know if Tristan was being completely truthful or even if my Dad was being honest about what happened to Tristan's parents. Tristan turned to me as I stopped beside him. "Everything okay?" he asked. I eyed him for a minute before nodding half-heartedly. He grabbed my hands and pulled me against him before tilting my chin up. "And are you okay?" he questioned. I shook my head lightly, "I don't even know anymore." "Are we leaving?" he asked after a beat. I nodded. "Where are we going?" I paused, a flicker of doubt in my mind if I could trust him. I have to be safe. It's not that I didn't trust Tristan, just that this wasn't something I could gamble on. "You'll see," I chose to say, "I'm taking you home." "Home?" he mused. "Mm-hmm," I hummed, "my home. Where I spent every summer and every Christmas growing up. We should go home and pack. We'll leave tonight." He seemed to sense that something wasn't right with me but nodded nonetheless. "Okay." Tristan first dropped me home and we agreed he would pick me up later tonight. Rushing upstairs, I took a shower and then began packing. I knew the apartment and Donna would be taken care of, so I grabbed everything I could possibly need and tossed it into a suitcase. I finished with a few minutes to spare so I took time to sit down and just think. Groaning, I dropped my head forward before running my fingers through it. What should I do? What if Tristan betrays me? What if my Dad is not the man I believe him to be? What if Tristan's still working with Michael? What if Dad really did kill his parents? What if… what if I don't make it back home? What if, somehow, Michael finds me in Catania? Or worse… What if Tristan kills me? The shrill ring of my doorbell snapped me out of it and I took my suitcase, pushing Donna off my lap before heading to the door. "Hi," I exhaled, my eyes meeting Tristan's. How can I not trust him? After everything… He won't turn on me, right? Leaning past me, he took my suitcase out of my hand and kissed me while he was at it. My reaction was impulsive but I found myself planting a hand on his chest, ever so slightly pushing him away. I regretted it immediately. His eyes fell down to my hand on his chest, a flash of hurt taking over his face as he pulled my suitcase to his side. "Sorry," I rushed out. "I just…" "That's okay, you don't have to apologize. Are you okay, Amara? Really?" "Can I trust you?" I blurted out without even comprehending. "Are you… doubting me? Because your Dad did?" "I'm sorry, Tristan, I really am. But I'm terrified. I don't know who to trust, I don't know who's lying to me and who isn't, I don't know what's real anymore," I rambled a little breathlessly. He nodded slowly before stepping closer to me. "This is real," he said calmly, "we're real, Amara. And I'm not going anywhere. I'm not going to betray you. If I've ever known anything so real, it's us. I know you still have reasons not to but I'm asking you to trust me." "I really…" I paused to take a deep breath. I really hope he isn't lying to me. How can he look me in the eye, tell me he loves me, and lie about it all? But I knew how badly I'd be hurting him if I wrongfully accused him. So I decided to trust him. Because I loved him enough to. Because I loved him more than that. He loved me enough, so why couldn't I? I couldn't doubt him. Even if I didn't, perhaps he loved me enough for the both of us. So why the fuck couldn't I? "I really do love you," I said, "please don't break my heart." He shook his head, "I won't. I promise you that." I practically collapsed against him, my arms going around his waist as I hugged him. Tristan kept an arm around me while resting his other hand on the back of my head. "Amara, I love you," he whispered into my hair. I drew back a minute later and met his gaze. All I could read in his eyes was concern for me. "I'll be okay," I whispered, nodding frantically. "We should go. We have to go." Taking my hand in his, he led the way out. Tristan's hand never left mine until he seated me in the passenger seat and even then, he picked it right back up the moment he began driving. I wasn't sure of anything, couldn't trust anyone, couldn't believe anyone either. But my heart simply wasn't listening to my mind. I couldn't bring myself to distrust Tristan. I loved him with all my heart and I wanted to believe he did too, that he meant what he said and loved me more than that. So, I decided to trust him. No matter what my head was telling me. Tristan had every chance to kill me and didn't take it because he loved me. And I trusted him because I loved him too. . . . . . Chapter 43