Chapter 84

The page crumpled tighter in my fist, edges cutting into my palm. My heart felt like it was splitting clean in two—one half clinging to the man who had stood at my side through fire and water, the other half choking on the proof bleeding in my hands.

Hardin burst through the broken door, rain slashing in behind him. His eyes were wild, scanning the conservatory until they landed on me. Relief flickered across his face, softening the hard lines for a single heartbeat. “Thank God,” he said, voice breaking. “I thought—”

Then he saw the shadow-man.

Everything changed.

In an instant Hardin’s body went rigid, his hand flying to his weapon. The sound of steel clicking echoed in the glasshouse.

“You!” Hardin spat.

The scarred man didn’t flinch. His hood slipped back just enough for the storm light to cut across his ruined face. “You can kill me,” he said calmly, “but the truth is already in her hands.”

Hardin’s gaze snapped to me, sharp as a blade. “Natalie… what did he tell you?”

I opened my mouth, but nothing came out. My throat was tight, my tongue heavy. All I could do was stare back at him, the torn page hidden in my fist like a live grenade. My silence was its own betrayal.

Rain pattered through the broken roof, dripping down my neck. My pulse hammered so loudly I couldn’t hear the storm anymore.

Hardin’s jaw tightened. Hurt flashed across his eyes—a kind of hurt that looked worse than any wound. “Don’t let him twist you,” he said, voice low but urgent. “Not now.”

The shadow-man shifted slightly, stepping back toward the shattered doorway. “She’s already twisted,” he murmured. “You’ve both been living in lies.”

“Shut up,” Hardin snarled, his gun steady. “You don’t get to talk to her.”

The scarred man tilted his head, rain dripping from his chin. “Funny. That’s what Sebastian said about you.”

I squeezed my eyes shut for a second, trying to breathe, trying to sort through the noise in my head. The ledger. The torn page. Lucien’s voice in the hospital—you betrayed me.

The shadow-man’s words. Ask yourself, Natalie. When he said betrayal, whose face did he see?

My hands shook.

I forced my eyes open. Hardin stood between me and the scarred man, his body a shield like always, but now the shield felt like a wall.

“Tell her,” the scarred man said softly. “Tell her who sent you.”

“Don’t you dare—” Hardin snapped.

“Then I’ll do it for you.” The shadow-man’s voice rose just enough to slice through the rain. “Sebastian placed him at your side from the start.”

“No,” I whispered, barely audible.

Hardin’s head jerked toward me. “Natalie—”

“Tell me it isn’t true.” My voice cracked. “Tell me you’re not one of them.”

His face shifted—anger, pain, guilt, something I couldn’t name flickering behind his eyes. “I saved you,” he said quietly. “Every time. I saved you.”

“That’s not an answer!”

Thunder rolled overhead. The conservatory shuddered as wind shoved at the cracked walls. Shards of glass trembled underfoot.

The scarred man took another step back, into the rain. “Truth breaks louder than glass,” he said, voice almost like a prayer.

Before either of us could react, he melted into the storm—one moment there, the next a shadow swallowed by rain and darkness.

His words lingered behind him like smoke.

Trust breaks louder than glass.

I stood frozen, still clutching the page.

Hardin lowered his gun slowly, like someone setting down a weight too heavy to hold. He took a step toward me. “Natalie, listen to me—”

I stepped back.

His eyes widened a fraction. “Don’t do that,” he said softly. “Don’t look at me like I’m the enemy.”

“What am I supposed to look at you like?” My voice came out sharper than I meant. “I’m holding proof, Hardin. Proof with your name on it.”

He ran a hand through his soaked hair, water dripping from his fingers. “That page… that’s only part of the story. Sebastian twists everything. He—he placed me near you, yes. But it wasn’t to hurt you.”

My chest rose and fell, fast. “Then what?”

“I was supposed to report on you.” His words came out low and raw. “That’s true. But I didn’t. I stayed because…” He swallowed hard. “Because you’re not like them. Because you’re…”

He stopped.

I took another step back, glass crunching under my boots. The rain roared louder on the roof, filling the silence between us.

“Because I what?” I whispered.

His jaw worked. “Because you’re the only thing I’ve ever wanted to protect.”

My throat closed.

For a heartbeat, everything went quiet inside me—the storm, the fear, even the ache in my chest. I stared at him, searching his face for the lie.

But all I saw was a man standing in the wreckage, soaked to the bone, weapon hanging loose at his side, eyes full of something like desperation.

Lightning flared.

The torn page fluttered from my fingers and landed in a puddle on the cracked tile. The red ink bled outward like a spreading wound.

Hardin’s gaze dropped to it. Then back to me. “Please,” he said. “Don’t believe him over me.”

I wanted to. God, I wanted to.

But the scarred man’s voice echoed in my head. Ask yourself, Natalie. When Lucien whispered betrayal, whose face did he see?

I stepped back again. “I can’t do this right now,” I whispered.

Hardin’s face tightened, but he didn’t move closer. He just stood there, breathing hard. “Then let me prove it,” he said finally. “Give me that chance. Please.”

Rain poured through a crack in the roof, splashing between us like a curtain.

I didn’t answer.

He took one small step toward me, hand half-lifted. “Natalie—”

The storm outside shifted. A distant crack—gunfire? Or just thunder? My body flinched anyway.

Hardin’s head turned toward the sound, eyes narrowing. “They’re coming,” he muttered. “We need to move.”

I stayed rooted. My heart felt heavier than the storm.

He looked back at me. “Natalie. Whatever you think you know—don’t decide here. Not now. Please.”

And for the first time since I’d met him, his voice broke.