Chapter 83

The torn page fluttered like a wounded bird in the shadow-man’s hand. Rain dripped from his sleeve, streaking across the paper and smearing the red ink until it bled like a cut.

He held it out to me.

I didn’t move at first. My stomach felt like it had dropped into the pit of the earth. My pulse roared in my ears louder than the storm outside.

Finally, my fingers reached out, trembling, and took it from him.

One name.

Hardin.

Scrawled in red like a wound.

I recoiled as if the letters themselves were fire. The page crumpled in my shaking hands. “No.”

The shadow-man’s eyes didn’t blink. “You think Sebastian chose him by chance?” His voice was quiet but sharp, like glass. “He placed him near you—to watch, to guide, to earn your trust.”

My mind screamed against it. The storm thundered. It was all wrong.

Hardin had been the one who pulled me out of the water when I thought I’d drown. Hardin had stood between me and gunfire, had pressed a bandage to my bleeding arm, had refused to leave Lucien’s side.

Hardin had loved me.

He couldn’t. He wouldn’t.

But the torn page trembled in my hand like a living thing, whispering another story.

I stared at the name again, waiting for it to vanish, for the ink to rearrange itself into some stranger’s name. It didn’t.

“No,” I whispered again. My throat burned. “You’re lying.”

The shadow-man tilted his head. “Am I?”

I looked up at him, desperate. “You’re trying to turn me against him. Just like Sebastian did to Lucien. That’s what this is.”

His scarred face softened—not much, but enough to make it worse. “Ask yourself, Natalie. When Lucien whispered ‘betrayal,’ whose face did he see?”

Lightning slashed across the sky, filling the conservatory with white light. For a heartbeat, the shadow-man’s expression looked almost like pity.

Then darkness again.

I could hardly breathe. I thought of Lucien’s eyes in the hospital—wild, hurt, accusing. You betrayed me.

No. He couldn’t have meant Hardin. He couldn’t.

And yet—

Hardin had known things he shouldn’t. The right doors to open. The right hatches to find. The right shots to fire. Always arriving just in time, always pulling me out.

Always close enough to know everything.

My hands tightened on the page until it crumpled, the red ink smearing against my skin.

The shadow-man stepped closer. “Sebastian is clever. He doesn’t send knives. He sends hands to hold you. Shoulders to lean on. Someone you would never suspect until it’s too late.”

My heart hammered so hard it hurt. “Stop,” I said. “Just stop.”

“Open your eyes, Natalie.”

I wanted to scream at him, but my voice caught in my throat. The storm outside roared louder, drowning everything.

Then, cutting through it, footsteps.

Fast. Heavy.

Coming closer.

My head snapped toward the sound. The broken door of the conservatory rattled against the wind.

And then—

“Natalie?”

Hardin’s voice.

Sharp. Panicked.

It echoed through the conservatory like a gunshot.

I froze.

The shadow-man’s eyes flicked toward the door. “He’s here.”

My breath caught. My fingers closed tighter around the page, hiding it inside my fist.

Hardin’s voice came again, closer this time. “Natalie! Answer me!”

I spun back to the shadow-man, whispering fast. “If this is true—if any of this is true—why tell me now?”

His jaw tightened. “Because you need to choose before he does.”

A beam of light swept across the broken glass floor as the door burst open. Rain and wind surged in, scattering shards.

Hardin stood in the entrance, soaked through, flashlight in one hand, his pistol in the other. His eyes locked on me first—then slid to the shadow-man.

He raised the gun instantly.

“What the hell are you doing with him?” Hardin’s voice was a growl.

The shadow-man stepped back, hands half-raised but steady. “You’re late.”

“Shut up!” Hardin snapped. His gaze flicked between me and the figure in the shadows. “Natalie, get away from him. Now.”

I couldn’t move.

Hardin’s eyes landed on mine. “What’s going on?”

My lips parted, but no words came. The crumpled page burned in my palm like a secret too hot to hold.

The shadow-man’s voice was low, almost amused. “Tell him what you’re holding, Natalie.”

“Don’t listen to him,” Hardin said sharply. “He’s playing you. Just like he played your brother.”

I looked between them. Hardin’s face was tight with fury, his gun steady, but there was something else there too. A flicker. A shadow.

Rain pounded the roof. Water dripped down my collar. The smell of wet earth and rust filled my nose.

“Tell her, soldier,” the shadow-man said softly. “Tell her who sent you.”

Hardin’s eyes flicked to the man, then back to me. “Natalie—”

My voice cracked. “Did Sebastian send you?”

Silence.

The question hung there like lightning waiting to strike.

Hardin’s jaw clenched. “I saved you,” he said quietly. “Every time. I saved you.”

“That’s not an answer,” I whispered.

His grip on the gun tightened.

The shadow-man took a step forward. “Too late.”

“Stay back!” Hardin barked, swinging the pistol toward him.

I stumbled backward, the torn page clutched to my chest. My heart pounded so loud it drowned the storm.

Hardin’s face twisted—anger, pain, something else I couldn’t read. “Whatever he told you, it’s a lie.”

My voice shook. “Is it?”

His eyes met mine. For the briefest heartbeat, they softened. “I never wanted this for you.”

The shadow-man lunged.

Hardin fired.

The conservatory exploded with sound—gunfire, shattering glass, thunder and rain all at once.