Chapter 134: Letting Go
Lucian’s POV
I made my way to Scarlett’s room, feeling the weight of every step. I knocked on the door, my heart pounding as I waited for her response.
“What do you want, Lucian?” Her voice came through, cold and indifferent, piercing me even from the other side of the door.
“Please,” I replied, struggling to keep my tone steady. “I just want to speak with you, that’s all.”
“With alcohol in your system?” she replied flatly. She must have smelled it on me, the faint sting of whiskey I’d tried to bury with resolve.
“Please, Scarlett,” I pleaded, my voice soft. “I promise I won’t do anything stupid.”
Silence followed, long enough for me to wonder if she would refuse. But then, her voice came, low and resigned. “Come in.”
I opened the door and entered, forcing myself to stay calm as Tiger rose within me, wanting to reach out to her. She stood there, eyes like green fire, the hint of her wolf just beneath the surface.
She was wrapped in a silk robe—one I recognized as a gift from Keith. The sight of it stung. I wanted to tear it off her, replace it with something that bore my mark, our mark, but I knew I had no right. That claim had been lost, shattered by my own doing. I doubted she’d even touched anything we’d given her since she returned.
“What do you want?” she asked again, her voice sharper, impatient.
I took a deep breath, meeting her gaze.
“Scarlett, I know you hate us,” I began, my words slow and deliberate. “Me most of all. And I know you’re only here for Garland to help us with that. I just want you to know how much that means to me, that despite everything, you’re still willing to do that.”
She folded her arms, her expression unreadable, but I could feel her wolf and her magic simmering just beneath the surface, waiting.
“You may not believe this,” I continued, my voice unsteady, “and I don’t expect you to. But every promise I made to you was true. I was weak and foolish. I took what we had for granted. I thought… I thought I’d always have time to fix it, to make things right. I didn’t see how much I was breaking you until it was too late.” My throat tightened as I spoke, but I pushed on. “I was wrong, Scarlett, and that’s a scar I’ll carry for the rest of my life.”
I saw her lips part, and I knew she was about to say something, but I wasn’t finished. I had to say it all before I lost the courage, before her words sliced through the thin layer of resolve I had left.
“Please, just hear me out,” I said quickly, holding up a hand to stop her. “I know I don’t deserve your forgiveness. I know it’s not even fair to ask for it. But I need you to know that I see it now, every mistake, every selfish act. And if there’s even a small part of you that can remember what we had, then maybe… maybe there’s hope that I can earn some fraction of your trust back.”
Her expression didn’t soften, her eyes still hard and unyielding, and I felt the heavy weight of reality. I might have already lost her completely, and yet, here I was, hoping for a miracle.
“You were right,” I admitted, each word carrying the weight of everything I’d realized too late. “We should have checked on you, made sure our orders were being carried out. Above all, we shouldn’t have—I shouldn’t have—let you stand trial. That was our mistake, my mistake, and I will live with it.” I felt tears beginning to blur my vision, but I didn’t look away. She deserved to hear it all, no matter how much it hurt to admit.
“I thought I was protecting you by trying to clear your name, by focusing on tracking down Olsen. We were so caught up in our mission that we failed to see what was happening to you, right here in front of us. There’s no excuse for that, Scarlett.”
I took a shaky breath, forcing myself to continue, even though her gaze was unwavering, piercing me with every word I spoke.
“And as for the incident by the pole… as cruel as it may sound, I don’t regret it. You were brought in unconscious, and they were prepared to lynch you without a second thought. I had no choice.” My voice dropped, struggling to find the right words to explain the impossible.
“You may not understand it now, but if the time comes when you rule the South, you will. I did what I could to make them believe you were punished so they would return home and leave you alone. The deaths… they demanded retribution, a show of justice. They wanted you beheaded, but I couldn’t—I couldn’t kill my mate. So I tried to convince them you’d been punished, that it was over, while Maxwell would take you to safety in Brome in the South.”
I sighed, the weight of the failed plan sinking heavily. “It wasn’t a smart plan, and I am sorry for everything. Clay didn’t want a part of it, and neither did Maxwell. I hope… I hope you can find it in your heart to forgive them.” I paused, searching her face for any sign of softness, of understanding. But she stood still, her expression a mask of control, unreadable.
Looking at her, I felt the distance between us more acutely than ever, and the truth settled painfully in my chest. “I think I’ve already lost you,” I said quietly, my voice barely above a whisper. “You reek of Keith so strongly that I don’t even need to be told what happened. And I can’t be angry with you for that. If there’s anyone to blame, it’s me. I pushed you right into his arms.”
I took another deep breath, the finality of it sinking in. “And I’ll regret that until the end of my days, Scarlett.”
“The emptiness I feel… it’s deeper now, more painful with you so close,” I said, feeling the words claw their way out of me. “I’m not saying this to make you feel sorry for me, Scarlett. Pity isn’t what I want. I don’t want anything from you except love, and I know I can’t demand that.”
I sighed, a heaviness settling over me. “I’ve decided I don’t want you fighting Garland on our behalf. Whatever happens, so be it. There’s no point in surviving if it means staying incomplete. I don’t want to force you to stay, to tie you to us when you don’t want to be here. That’s why I’ve made a decision: I’m letting you go.”
Her expression remained unreadable, her silence like a wall between us, but I pushed on, knowing this was the only gift I had left to give.
“The South is your home. If you want to go there, you’re free to leave. If Keith makes you happy and you want to be with him, then I release you to him. Just knowing you’re alive and safe… that will be enough for me.” My voice wavered, the words barely holding themselves together. “I promise I won’t trouble you or come looking for you again.”
My gaze drifted to the mark on her neck, the one that had once been a symbol of our bond. “If I could remove my mark to give you the freedom you deserve, I would. And when Elsa returns, I’ll ask her to block the bond on your end. This way, you’ll be free of me, of us. I hope this will bring you peace, Scarlett.”
Her silence continued, and part of me ached to reach out, to hold her just once more. But I knew that right was gone, that I no longer had permission to bridge the distance I’d created. I had caused her pain, and no words, no promises, could erase that.
Setting her free was the only way to give her even a fraction of the happiness I’d taken from her. If she chose to stay, it wouldn’t be because of obligation or the pull of our bond; it would be because she truly wanted us. And if she chose to leave, I would have to live with it.
As the silence grew between us, I waited, holding onto the last fragments of my heart, hoping this decision would at least bring her some kind of healing. Even if it left me empty, knowing she could finally breathe free might be the one small balm for this wound.