Chapter 133: Remorsefully Sad

Lucian’s POV

One Month had crawled by, and Garland had yet to make a move. Tension hung in the air, a storm cloud that never broke, and each day without action seemed to grind us further down.

Keith, true to his word, had sent help in quiet, discrete ways that no one noticed. We hadn’t shared this with anyone else—not even our Betas. Trust felt fragile, like glass too thin to bear any weight. If one of them was compromised, it could all shatter.

The days since Scarlett returned had been a kind of hell. The air between us felt like ice. Every look she gave was distant, a reminder that forgiveness wasn’t anywhere close.

I’d secretly hoped that Elsa would return from her mission to the South; maybe she could be a voice of reason, maybe she’d help mend the widening gaps. But there was no sign of her return, and with each passing day, it became painfully clear: we had done too much damage, made mistakes that couldn’t be taken back or easily forgiven. Every decision, every action I’d taken weighed heavily on me. Worst of all, I knew the biggest mistakes were mine.

Scarlett smelled of Keith now, and none of us could pretend otherwise. I couldn’t blame her. I had failed her. I’d tied her to that pole, stripped her of her dignity, left her there as though she were nothing more than a criminal, as though her life held no more value than the frost I’d hoped would take her.

The memory sickened me, each second of it replaying in my mind as if to punish me. I could see my own face, cold and unyielding, even cruel, as I’d told her that I wished the cold would finish what I’d started. Why had I been so heartless? So… convincing in my cruelty?

I looked around me now, at the pack I’d sacrificed my soul to protect. They went about their lives as though nothing had happened, as though my sins hadn’t ripped apart everything that should have held us together.

None of them felt the pain I did now, the bitter consequences of choices made to please and protect them, choices that only drove a knife deeper into Scarlett’s heart.

I was alone with that burden, left to carry it while the rest of the pack lived in peace. Only a fool would let his responsibility to his pack turn him against his mate, and I had been exactly that fool. In my blind duty to them, I’d sacrificed the one thing that should have mattered more—her.

And it wasn’t just me. Clay and Maxwell were caught in this tangled web of guilt too. I could see it in their faces, shadows under their eyes that no one else noticed, a haunted look that seemed to pull all the colour from them. None of us even had the energy to plan for Garland’s eventual attack.

It was as if there was no fight left in us, no will to defend what we’d already torn apart. We’d thought that finding Scarlett again would heal us, that she would return to us and bring back what we had lost. But that hope was as empty as we were now.

The woman who returned wasn’t our Scarlett, she was changed—hardened, forged by everything we’d put her through, made bitter and distant by the cruelty we’d inflicted. She was our creation, a reflection of the mistakes and injustices we could never undo.

Clay had been right all along, and that was why he bore the heaviest weight of guilt. If it had been up to him, we never would have handed Scarlett over for the Trial. We would have defied the elders and dismissed the outdated laws of our parents. T

hey were gone now; their authority should have died with them. We were supposed to be in charge. But when it came down to it, our weakness shone through. The elders wielded more influence than we could, despite our titles, and that reality had stripped us of control.

Was that our parents’ fault, the way they had raised us to bow to tradition, or was it simply our own lack of strength?

I reached into the cabinet, pulling out a bottle of whiskey. The drink had become my constant companion lately, numbing the ache that clawed at me day after day. Tiger, my inner beast, was as lost as I was, both of us caught in this limbo of regret and helplessness. Drinking away the hours seemed like the only way to pass the time now.

But after a few sips, I felt a surge of resolve. I couldn’t just sit here, drowning myself while Scarlett continued to suffer alone. I’d been locked out from her for weeks now—she kept our interactions brief and maintained a wall around herself. It was painfully clear she was only biding her time until Garland arrived, fulfilling the promise she’d made to herself.

She’d leave as soon as it was done, and nothing we could say would change her mind. The realization burned, knowing that her departure was inevitable, that she was so close yet felt further away than ever.

The worst part was the distance, even now. She was physically here, back within our walls, but emotionally, she was a thousand miles away. I could see the storm of emotions in her—confusion, anger, hurt, and raw, unfiltered pain.

Her magic radiated around her, fierce and untamed, a shield of fire I could never break through. I felt hollow, aching to hold her, to offer her the comfort I’d failed to give before, to show her the depth of my remorse. But I was denied even that.

Finally, I made up my mind. I left our apartment without a word. Maxwell was out hunting, and Clay was shut away in his room. I knew if they saw me, they’d try to stop me, remind me of the fragile truce we’d maintained, the caution we had agreed upon. But I couldn’t go on like this, watching her from a distance, feeling my heart twist every time I caught a glimpse of her.

This might be a foolish decision, and perhaps she wouldn’t even hear me out. But I knew, deep down, that it was necessary. I had to see Scarlett. I had to try, even if it was only one more time.