Chapter 65

Chapter Title: Gray

Kathy

The silence clotted around us. A seagull’s cry pierced the air outside. The fryer hissed, sharp and relentless. Behind the counter, Gus shuffled—slow, too careful, like he was holding his breath to eavesdrop.

The bagman let out a long, ragged exhale, his eyes narrowing. “You’ve got guts, Hastings. Still, guts alone will land you in a shallow grave in Crisfield."

“Will you arrange it or not?” I snapped, catching the flicker of calculation in his gaze.

He didn’t answer. His hand snaked toward a chicken wing, and he bit into it—slow, mechanical, like he was buying time. The blinds sliced bars of light across his face. His eyes darted to the window, scanning for ghosts.

I grabbed my sweet tea, the ice clinking loudly, and took a sip. The sugar burned my throat, too sweet, like a lie you choke on in a place like this.

When he spoke, his voice was a low hiss, barely audible. “I can slip a word to the right ear. But hear me, Hastings—Benny doesn’t do meetings. He sets traps. Step into one, and no badge, no Bureau, no goddamn cavalry will drag you out.”

I leaned in, my voice cold, cutting. “Then I’ll roll the dice. Because walking away without Kimberly? That’s not an option.”

His head tilted, eyes locking on mine—sharp, icy, unreadable. “You’re not listening. To Benny, your sister’s not a person. She’s a pawn. And pawns? They get crushed without a second thought.”

“A pawn?” My pulse slammed in my throat. “What do you know about Kimberly? Did Benny take her? Is Divine pulling the strings?”

“I don’t know shit about your sister,” he growled, leaning closer. “Didn’t even know Kimberly was your sister until you opened your mouth. And Benny? He’s got nothing to do with her disappearance. He’s scared of Divine. Allison’s gone, and he’s sure it’s her handiwork—but he’s too damn weak to touch her.”

“I thought Benny owned this state—mayors, cops, judges,” I shot back.

He snorted, bitter. “He does. But Divine’s got more cash and sharper claws. Her husband? He’s not just a senator. He’s the Senator.”

My heart pounded, a single heavy thud. “What’s that supposed to mean?”

His laugh was a jagged edge. “Divine’s hands are bloody, but you think she moves without Henry Williamson’s say-so? Not a chance.”

“You got proof he’s dirty?” I demanded, my voice low but razor-sharp.

He shook his head, eyes never leaving mine. “Proof? Not a shred. But those missing girls?” His voice dropped to a whisper, venomous. “They were his playthings. You catching my drift?”

The air froze. The fryer’s hiss faded beneath the sharp ringing in my ears.

Senator Henry Williamson—Hank’s father—paid for sex? Maybe even went as far as killing them?

It slammed into me like a fist. Did Kimberly know too much?

“Shit,” I breathed, barely audible. Jesus Christ, Kimmie, what the hell did you stumble into?

“Damn right,” he muttered, his voice tight.

His face softened for a split second—something like respect flickering through the exhaustion. “Name’s Gray,” he said, voice low, final. “That’s what OC called me when I went under. Nothing’s black or white here. It’s all gray.” He tossed a few bills on the table, his movements sharp. “I’ll see about your meeting. But don’t kid yourself—Benny agreeing to see you? That’s not respect. It’s him deciding how to deal with you. And if it goes south, Hastings, don’t expect me to be your lifeline.”

I caught the strain in his eyes and felt a flicker of pity. Three long years spent infiltrating a syndicate—now hanging by a thread because I wanted a sit-down. I thought of Archer and decided fast: Gray didn’t need to be dragged into this.

I grabbed his arm as he moved to stand, shoving my card into his hand. “Forget it. I won’t risk your cover. I’ll get the Ryder brothers to set it up—they’ve been useful so far.”

He pocketed the card, his eyes narrowing. “Archer’s tight with Benny, but watch your back, Agent Hastings. Trust nobody.” His voice was a blade, slicing through the greasy air.

He stood, looming over me for a moment, and gave a curt nod. His footsteps echoed, deliberate, heavy, as he crossed the diner. At the door, he pushed it open, sunlight slashing across the greasy floor. The glass swung shut, the chime swallowed by silence, leaving only the hum of the lights.

I sat, fists clenched in my lap, the mirror reflecting a warped world beyond the door—cars, light, motion. None of it felt real.

Kimberly—a pawn. Divine. The Senator. Papa Benny.

Threads of the same twisted knot.

The fryer hissed again, a long, weary sigh, like the room itself was gasping for air. I didn’t move. I stared at the door through the convex mirror , my reflection glaring back, distorted. If Papa Benny thought I was a threat—good. Let him try me. He hadn’t met a Hastings.

I stayed in the booth, the tea glass sweating, the air thick with grease and silence. Waiting. Scheming.

Then, movement caught my eye. Gus locked the door, flipped the open sign to closed, and approached, a white box in his hands, his pale face unreadable.

“Agent Hastings,” he said, his voice low, clipped. “I’m Agent Augustus Moore. Fletcher’s waiting for you upstairs.” He set the box on the table, his eyes flicking to the mirror above. “Parcel came in last night from Agent Chen, New York office. He said it was urgent.” He twisted the blinds shut, the slats snapping closed. “When you're ready, I’ll take you upstairs.”

“Thanks, Agent Moore,” I said, forcing a tight smile. He nodded and stepped back, leaving me alone.

I tore into the box, revealing a thick manila folder with the name Kelly Lawrence printed on the front. My breath caught, guilt clawing at me for not doing this sooner.

Kelly’s file was stuffed with statements and photos. I rifled through, hunting for notes from Martha’s Cheesecake Spot staff.

After several minutes of sifting through the documents, I finally found something. A cashier named Ana Ferguson said Kelly had always come alone—until a few months before she vanished. That’s when a man started showing up with her: young, blond, around six feet tall, athletic build, preppy. Quiet type. Always wore a cap or hat pulled low. Unsociable. Never ordered, never spoke, never lingered. He’d arrive with Kelly and leave before she did. Ana guessed he might’ve been an NYU student, though she never saw him wearing any school gear. What she did notice was how he always slipped into a chauffeured black Mercedes-Benz waiting outside after each visit.

Ana said Kelly dodged questions about him. When she asked if he was her boyfriend, Kelly just smirked and said, “I think we're past that.”

Of course. Because she was pregnant.

Blond, six-foot, rich... Sounded like Hank. Except Hank went to Salisbury University, not NYU.

I sighed. It could be anyone. Too many men fit that vague sketch. I yanked out my phone and dialed Chen.

“Calling to grovel, Hastings?” Chen’s voice was sharp, wary.

“Thanks for the file,” I said, keeping it curt. “But I need more.”

“Christ, what now?” he groaned, tension crackling through the line.

“Martha’s Cheesecake Spot in the Village. Find Ana Ferguson and see if she still works there. Ask if the blond guy who she mentioned seeing with Kelly ever came back. Take her photo with you to jog Ana’s memory.”

"Martha's Cheesecake Spot? Hell, your sister had taste. Fine, I’ll swing by after work. You think this blond ghost’s tied to her disappearance?”

“Maybe,” I said, my voice tight. “If he showed up again, hack their system. Look for a credit card, anything. It’s a long shot, but dig.”

“Challenge accepted,” Chen said, his tone clipped. “I’ll call if I get something.”

“Send me the bill for cheesecake,” I added.

“Damn right I will,” he shot back, a faint edge of humor.

“One more thing... Have you pulled Hank’s school records?”

“Not yet,” he snapped. “I’m neck-deep in a dark web case. Radical group snatched a kid from a park, auctioning her off to the highest bidder.”

My stomach twisted at the news. “Found her yet?”

“Close,” he said, voice grim. “We’re closing in.”

“Save her first. Hank can wait. Call if you need me.”

“Will do,” Chen said. “Don’t stiff me on the cheesecake. Out.”

I shoved the file back into the box and stood.

“Gus,” I called, my voice sharp. “Let’s move.”