Chapter 64
Chapter Title: The Bagman
Kathy
The FBI front, Chick-N’Go, hit me like a memory—hot oil, old grease, and the sweet, chemical tang of air freshener trying too hard to fake clean. It wasn’t just a smell; it was a stain, the kind that settled deep into the grout and vinyl and never quite left. The kitchen hissed and popped behind a curtain of steam, as if time itself had been left to sizzle. I paused in the doorway, bag slung over my shoulders, fingers hovering over my Glock, listening to the diner breathe.
The fluorescent light overhead buzzed with a lazy, offbeat hum. A few flies circled near the menu board, drawn to the faint sweetness of old cola syrup. Somewhere, a fryer belched. Perfect place for a setup, I thought. Somewhere public enough for cover stories, quiet enough for blood to dry unnoticed.
My eyes moved to the counter. Behind it stood a young man—pale skin, thick glasses, a red rooster stitched onto his cap, the name Gus on his nameplate. The rooster’s head bobbed as he nodded, acknowledging me. One look and I knew he wasn’t just another fry cook. Too alert. Too precise with his movements. His eyes didn’t wander; they assessed. Bureau. Desk type. Someone who probably thought fieldwork smelled better on paper.
As for the man I found lounging in the diner—the one I called The Bagman—he didn’t flinch.
He sat in the booth next to an empty corner booth, half-swallowed by shadow, one arm stretched across the backrest, the other resting on the table beside an untouched plate. The sunlight slanted through the blinds, striping his jaw, carving his face into pieces of light and shade. He looked like a man who’d seen too much and learned to make peace with the rot.
His black hair was shiny, combed back smooth. He wore simple clothes—black jeans, worn boots, and a tight white t-shirt. The short sleeves showed tattoos on his arms: dark swirls, skulls mixed with red roses, and old, faded words that held secrets no one asked about.
I let my hand fall from my weapon but I didn’t relax. My stance stayed ready, weight balanced, pulse measured. Every instinct whispered don’t blink first.
“I said hands where I can see them,” I said, voice clipped and cold.
He turned his head slightly, a faint smirk tugging at one corner of his mouth. Slowly, he lifted his one arm and placed it flat on the table, sitting upright.
His voice came out smooth, deliberate. “As you can see, I'm unarmed. If I were here to pull a trigger, Agent Hastings, you wouldn’t have made it past the threshold. Now—sit down." He gestured to the empty booth behind him. "You and I have a lot to discuss, and I don’t have a lot of time.”
I quickly scanned the room—the corners, the vents, the chrome reflection from the soda machine. Empty. Just the two of us and the hum of grease-soaked machinery.
“Comforting,” I muttered as I walked toward him.
Following his instructions, I quickly placed my bag on the table and slid into the booth behind him—back against back. Close enough that I could feel the faint warmth of him through the cracked vinyl. From here, I had a full view of the front door through the large convex mirror perched high on the wall. The warped reflection bent the room into a fish-eye view—cars flashing by, shadows bleeding across the floor, every shape elongated and strange. If someone were to come through that door, I’d see them before they'd see me.
Gus appeared again, wordless, carrying a plate of chicken wings drowning in sauce, mashed potatoes slick with gravy, and a sweating glass of sweet tea. He set them down in front of me, his gaze darting to me once before he retreated to the counter, disappearing into the hiss of the fryers.
The silence stretched. Only the hum of the refrigerator and the ticking of the wall clock filled it. Then, finally, the bagman spoke. “You don’t remember me.”
I frowned. “Should I?”
“No,” he said. “But I’ve read your name enough times that I feel like I know you. I’m from the Baltimore division. Organized Crime Task Force. You’ve stepped on the wrong nest this time.”
The words cut like a wire pulled taunt. Baltimore Division. Internal connection. If he’s lying, he’s good. Too good. My hand drifted near the Glock again, not touching, but close enough. “You’re saying you’re one of ours?”
“I’m saying I’m embedded,” he corrected. His voice was calm—the kind of calm that came from years of pretending to be someone else. “On paper, I’m the bagman. I carry envelopes, pick up cash, drop off instructions. Nobody in Benny’s crew questions the bagman. That’s the beauty of it. That’s my cover. That’s my life now.” I studied his reflection in the mirror. His body language was still, controlled. Stillness like that doesn’t come cheap. He’s either telling the truth—or he’s memorized it.
“Convenient,” I said.
“Not convenient,” he answered, his tone flattening. “Necessary. You think I like watching Benny’s crew chew through this state? You think I enjoy taking orders from him? I can’t act from the inside, Hastings. I can’t make noise without blowing three years of work. But you—” He leaned back, just enough for me to feel the ghost of his breath brush my shoulder. “You’re the variable Benny didn’t see coming. And that makes you dangerous.”
“Dangerous to him, maybe,” I shot back.
“To him, definitely.” His voice lowered, the words landing like gravel. “Benny’s not afraid of the law. Not of cops, mayors, or half the judges from here to the Shore. He owns them. But you? You’re an outsider with a badge he can’t buy. You don’t play his game. You don’t belong. And that makes you unpredictable. Benny hates unpredictable.”
Unpredictable keeps me alive, I thought. Predictable gets you a bullet in the back.
“So he put a hit on me,” I said.
“You’re catching up.”
The vinyl beneath me groaned as I shifted, turning just enough to catch the edge of his face. “I didn’t come here to stir things up. I came here for my sister. Kimberly Hastings. She’s missing. That’s my focus.”
He raised an eyebrow, unimpressed. “And you think Benny’s going to care about that distinction? You flashing your badge, asking questions? He doesn’t care why. He only cares that you’re crossing a line. He built this town on control, and right now—you’re standing outside his circle.”
“Then draw me in,” I said.
He blinked once. “What?”
“Arrange a meeting. Benny and I have something in common. His daughter’s missing, from what I’ve heard.” My gaze stayed fixed on his face, voice steady. “You’re his trusted errand boy. Use that. Put me in front of him.”
He gave a short, humorless laugh. “That’s suicide. You think Benny’s going to sit down with you like some neighborhood priest? He’ll slit your throat before you finish your sentence.”
“Then make him listen,” I said, leaning in just enough that my voice cut through the hum of the fryer. “Tell him I’m offering help to find his daughter. I’m not here to topple his empire or his Order. I want my sister. That’s all.”
He didn’t speak right away. For the first time, his composure cracked—barely, but enough to see it. The faint tremor of conflict. “You don’t ask Benny for favors. You don’t walk into his office unless he’s already decided your fate. A meeting with him isn’t a conversation—it’s a sentence.”
“Maybe,” I said quietly. “Or maybe it’s leverage. He sees me as a threat? Fine. I’ll show him I’m not. I’m after one person. If he understands that, maybe I get what I came for."