Chapter 60
Chapter Title: Paperweight
Kathy
The butterfly tattoo on the woman was a small win, but it wasn’t enough. I needed something on the man—anything—that could help me identify him.
"Any other markings? Anything distinctive you can remember—scars, piercings, anything on the man?” I pressed, my voice calm but insistent, my mind already racing ahead, building a profile from scraps.
Leslie drew her brows together, the look of someone digging hard through memory’s clutter. She stood there, arms folded, lips twitching slightly, and for a moment I thought she’d come up blank. Then she shook her head. “Nothing I could see,” she admitted, the words heavy with regret. “Both of them kept covered up—long sleeves, glasses, hood up over their caps, hair tucked away. Like they didn’t want to be recognized by anyone, not even in passing. But…” She trailed off, her eyes narrowing as she held onto something. “I did notice the man was much older than the woman. Maybe late thirties, early forties.”
The words hit me like a cold draft, crawling under my skin. Older man, younger woman. Power imbalance. Dynamic already screaming something off. I pivoted back toward the footage, eyes narrowing, until the pixels blurred. “The license,” I said, my voice thinner, sharper. “Did the photo match?”
Leslie gave a quick nod, but I caught the flicker of frustration that tightened her mouth, the kind that came from knowing you were about to repeat yourself but couldn’t cut corners. “Yes. She pulled her sunglasses down for just a moment when she handed me the license. The eye color matched. I ran it in the system: Kelly Lawrence. Everything checked out. Clean. No flags, no notes, no history that tripped the wires.”
And that was its own kind of wrong—when everything lined up too neatly, when the trail looked scrubbed clean, you knew someone had put work into it.
Or maybe not...
My eyes landed on Leslie, her lip caught nervously between her teeth. The couple had arrived around two in the morning. The footage showed her yawning repeatedly, barely keeping her eyes open. She looked exhausted—but it wasn’t unexpected. At that hour, anyone would struggle to stay awake, and the couple had clearly taken advantage of it.
I turned toward Susan, heat edging my voice sharper than I meant, but I didn’t care. “The form he filled out—where’s the hard copy? And the SUV’s GPS—I want it up. Now.”
“The hard copy’s in the back. Leslie, grab it.” Susan didn’t even look up, just waved a hand toward her colleague before hunching closer to the screen. Her fingers flew across the keyboard, quick, decisive, like she was eager to keep pace with me. A map flared to life, bright blue lines etching across the screen, each point another ghost of their path. “The SUV stayed in Ocean City for two days,” she narrated, her voice flat, businesslike. “Then it moved through Pocomoke, Crisfield, Annapolis. Four days ago, it circled back to Crisfield. That was the last ping.”
“Any stops stand out? Gas stations, motels, anywhere they lingered longer than a few minutes?” I asked.
Susan scrolled, her eyes narrowing, face tightening as she fought the sluggishness of data. Then she froze. “Looks like they idled near an estate in Crisfield. More than once.” She clicked, and a name appeared in stark letters on the screen. “Williamson Estate. Formerly Wincroft Mansion.”
The name hit me like a hammer between the eyes. My chest tightened, my lungs locked. Divine.
“You said they stayed here in Ocean City for two days. Can you tell me where?”
Susan’s lips pulled taut as she zoomed in, clicked a red dot that pulsed like a warning. “Cabana Motel. Near the boardwalk.” The faint smile she’d worn earlier evaporated, leaving her face hollow, tense.
I tapped the counter with my fingernail, each click a metronome marking time I didn’t have. Motel. Estate. The pieces shifted in my head, already building a path forward whether I wanted it to or not. “The cash payment,” I said, sharper than I intended. “How’d they handle it?”
Leslie reappeared then, a folder in her hand, speaking as though she’d been waiting for this moment. “Big stack of hundreds. Maybe five grand in total. The guy pulled it straight out of his pocket, counted it out fast, like he’d done it a thousand times before. He didn't even blink.”
I checked the time—0922 hours—then angled my phone and snapped a clean shot of the rental form. Sliding on a pair of nitrile gloves, I pulled an evidence bag from my kit. With careful hands, I slipped the document inside, pressed the seal until it locked, and scrawled my initials across the closure tab. Chain of custody: Hastings, K. Primary handler. Standard protocol, the kind of thing drilled into me a thousand times.
But this wasn’t just chain of custody. This was Kimberly. Every edge of tape, every scribbled note, every bagged document—each one tethered me to her, to the hope of her still breathing somewhere. I slipped the bag into my pack, the weight digging into my shoulder like lead. Paper shouldn’t feel that heavy. But it did.
Another breadcrumb. Another faint trace for the lab—latent prints, handwriting, DNA if the gods of forensics smiled on me. The trail might still be warm. If I pushed hard enough, fast enough, maybe it wouldn’t end with a body bag.
“Any accents? Speech patterns? Anything distinct in how they talked?” I asked, leaning in, relentless, scraping the bottom of the barrel because sometimes that’s where the gold dust hid.
Leslie hesitated, then shook her head. “The woman barely spoke. Maybe a few words—‘here’s the license.’ Steady voice. No accent.”
“And the man?”
She tilted her head back, eyes flicking up as if she could pull the sound from the air. “He’s the one who asked to rent the car. His voice was low. Faint. Gruff. Almost forced. No accent, though.”
Voice described as low, faint, and gruff—suggestive of intentional disguise.
“I’m seizing that USB for forensic analysis,” I said, my tone flat as stone. “We’ll run facial recognition, cross-reference the tattoo, pull GPS metadata. We’re already running behind.”
Susan ejected the drive, slid it across the counter. Her fingers trembled, almost imperceptible, but I caught it. “Understood. Anything else we can do?”
“Police station—where is it?” I demanded, pocketing the USB, its weight a lifeline in my blazer.
“Two blocks west, left turn,” she replied quickly, her words tripping over each other. “Brick building, flag out front. You can’t miss it.”
“Thank you both.” I was already halfway to the door, brain buzzing hot, focusing on my to-do list: get the rental form to prints, enhance the footage, push the tattoo through every system.
I sighed. Time, time, time. Always bleeding away.
I exited the rental agency, the USB weighing down my pocket, the butterfly tattoo and GPS trail fresh leads itching to be chased. Time was bleeding out, every second cinching the noose tighter. If I didn’t move faster, I’d lose them—and they were my only chance at answers.
My phone buzzed in my pocket—Fletcher, maybe—but before I could check, I walked straight into a wall of muscle.
I jolted back, gaze snapping upward. Caramel-brown eyes glinted down at me, amused, like they’d been waiting.
Ace.
He was dressed casually—dark blue V-neck, new jeans, the faint bite of cologne trailing off him. Sunglasses hung in the V of his shirt, perched there like they belonged, like it was a privilege to rest on his chest.
Images surged, unbidden—him inside me, pushing, relentless, filling every space. My throat went dry. I swallowed hard, tamping the hunger down, forcing my face into something colder.
I scowled before my mind caught up, hoping the expression would hide the heat crawling up my skin. Over his shoulder, Archer lingered several yards away, arms crossed over a green polo, jeans stiff, his face a mask of pensive thought, something heavy pressing behind his eyes.
“Didn’t I tell you to check if the car was ready?” I snapped at Ace, my voice sharp as broken glass.
He only tilted his head, his grin unbothered, sly. “Hastings, after yesterday’s shooting, you think we’d let you walk alone?” He winked, then nodded toward the Lincoln parked at the curb. "But as you can see, mission accomplished. So—what’d you find out?”
I moved forward, letting him fall into step beside me. “Couple rented the SUV. Male, female. Both covered—hoodies, caps, sunglasses. Heads down, avoiding cameras. The woman jittery, maybe high. Teller said she matched the license photo.”
I didn’t mention the tattoo. That stayed mine. No way I was feeding Divine’s lapdogs more than necessary.
“So it’s a dead end?” Archer’s voice came from behind, edged with relief that made me want to snap at him.
I glanced back, my brow arched. “Not quite. GPS puts them at the Cabana Motel for two days. And at the Williamson Estate four days ago.”
"Hastings," Ace said, a warning in his tone. "I know where you're going with this."
“No—you don’t know,” I hissed. “They may have been casing the Williamsons. Maybe they saw Kimberly. Easy mark. You’re head of security. So if Cabana Motel doesn’t give me anything, you’re pulling every second of footage from the estate—five days back. Every camera.” I jerked my chin toward the street. “We stop at the motel first, before heading back to Crisfield. Come on. OCPD’s this way.”
We followed Susan’s directions, the three of us moving through streets that smelled faintly of salt and oil. The building loomed soon enough: two stories of red brick, flag snapping sharp above it, patrol cars lined in uneven rows out front. Uniformed officers clustered near the door, the buzz of their talk cutting off when we approached.
Inside, the air was cooler, thicker, tinged with disinfectant and coffee that had been burned an hour too long. Before we reached the front desk, I turned to the Ryder brothers, my voice brooking no room for argument.
“Wait here,” I said. “They’ll only want to talk to me.”