Chapter 59

Chapter Title: The Butterfly Tattoo

Kathy

I dashed through the four blocks to Cars R Us, my lungs hurting with every quick breath, my heart pounding in my chest, desperate to put as much space as possible between me and the Ryder brothers. I had to escape the memory of their hands touching me, their heat, and the deep, nagging want that stirred inside me—a feeling I hated to admit even to myself in the quiet corners of my mind.

My body still hadn’t calmed down from the wild rush that had taken hold of me. The long night, stretching into the early morning hours, had worn me out completely, leaving me tired in a way that sank deep into my bones. Yet, even with all that exhaustion, I couldn’t shake this restless feeling, like something inside me was still awake, still hungry, still wanting more. It was as if that need, that aching want, was running through my blood, pushing me to keep chasing something I couldn’t quite name. I could feel it stirring in my chest, tugging at my thoughts, making my skin tingle. But I pushed those thoughts aside because none of that mattered now. This hunger or whatever this was—it would have to wait. I had a job to do, a purpose.

Kimberly’s smile—vivid in memory, absent in reality—broke through my confusion. I couldn’t waste another second lost in lust while she was out there, God knows where, with time running out.

I needed to find her.

And the CCTV footage was my best lead. I could already feel the momentum rising.

My loafers struck the pavement with a relentless, almost punishing rhythm, each step a sharp slap that echoed the frantic hammering of my pulse in my ears. The late morning air clung to me, heavy and warm, saturated with the briny tang of the nearby sea, its salty breath mingling with the acrid sting of exhaust fumes that curled through the streets. Around me, the city pulsed with life—people hurrying along the sidewalks, their faces buried in phones or lost in idle chatter, utterly unaware of the urgency that etched itself into every taut line of my face, every clenched muscle in my jaw. They moved like a tide, flowing past me, their indifference a stark contrast to the turmoil roiling inside my chest.

My destination loomed ahead, unassuming yet critical: the rental agency, a squat, unremarkable little building crouched at the corner of the street, its faded neon sign flickering weakly in the daylight, as if it had long since given up on grabbing anyone’s attention. I gripped the door’s handle, yanking it open with more force than necessary, and the bell above let out a jangling chime, its bright, cheerful notes jarring against the tension coiled tight in my body, almost as if it were mocking the dread that had taken root in my gut.

My eyes scanned the room briefly. It was small, square, the walls plastered with posters advertising happy families crammed into minivans and SUVs. Adventure starts here, one promised in bold blue letters. Adventure. Right. What they didn’t advertise was abduction, fear, blood trails going cold.

A woman behind the counter looked up, her name tag reading Susan. Mid-forties, mousy brown hair pulled tight in a bun that didn’t suit her round face. No uniform like the one Carter wore yesterday—just a gray pantsuit that looked one wash away from giving up.

Her smile was professional, but her eyes watched me warily, like she’d already been warned to expect me.

I approached, flipping open my credentials with a practiced flick. “Special Agent Katherine Hastings, FBI. I spoke with Carter yesterday regarding a black SUV tied to an abduction. I’m here to follow up."

Susan gave a sharp nod, her response immediate and without a trace of hesitation. She was already in motion, her movements brisk, purposeful, and efficient, her hands navigating the cluttered desk with the practiced ease of someone who thrived under pressure. “Carter briefed me,” she said, her voice clipped but steady, carrying a no-nonsense tone. “Said you’d want CCTV and GPS, pronto.” Without waiting for my confirmation, she bent down, her frame folding briefly as she reached for a lower drawer, her fingers deftly retrieving a slim USB drive that glinted faintly under the harsh fluorescent light. The click of it sliding into the terminal was sharp, resonating in the small room with an odd weight, louder than it should have. With a quick tilt of her wrist, she angled the monitor toward me, its screen casting a pale glow across her focused expression. Her fingers then glided over the keyboard in a near-hypnotic rhythm, each keystroke crisp and deliberate.

“The vehicle was rented eight days ago,” she said, her eyes flicking briefly to meet mine before returning to the screen, “and it was due back two days ago. Paid in full, cash transaction, no questions asked.” Her nails, neatly trimmed but unpainted, tapped rhythmically against the mouse, summoning a grainy feed of CCTV footage on the monitor. She paused for a moment as she scanned the data, then leaned forward slightly, her voice dropping to a quieter, more deliberate tone. “Let’s run the footage,” she said, her finger pressing the play button.

The grainy footage stuttered to life, timestamped eight days ago: 02:17:43 AM. Two figures slipped into frame—hoodies cinched tight, baseball caps tugged low, sunglasses shielding their eyes despite the pre-dawn gloom. Their heads dipped in unison, a calculated tilt to dodge the lens. Deliberate. Rehearsed. It was obvious they knew where the CCTV camera was.

Rage tore through me, hot and sudden, a flash fire in my chest. They weren’t amateurs; they’d studied the angles, walked the frame like it was mapped out. Which meant Kimberly wasn’t random. She was chosen.

My nails bit into my palms, hands curling into fists against the counter. For one reckless second, all I saw was red—I wanted their faces, their names, their blood in my hands.

Then I forced air through my lungs, slow and steady, forcing the fury down where it belonged. I wasn’t a grieving sister here—I was an agent. And agents didn’t lash out. Agents documented, observed, dismantled.

I squared my shoulders, fixed my eyes on the screen, and studied the two subjects.

Based on their builds and heights, I logged the first as male—approximately six feet, broad shoulders, movements precise and deliberate. Everything about him suggested authority, control. The leader. The second, female, stood shorter, maybe 5'7" in height, slighter. Her behavior was restless: hands tugging at her sleeves, head snapping in quick, irregular motions. Indicators pointed to stimulant use. Subordinate role, most likely. My gut tightened, but I kept the reaction contained.

I watched as the rental clerk slid paperwork across the counter. Odd dynamic—the man filled out most of the forms, but the woman produced the license. When it came time to sign, she scrawled her name, and that’s when it happened.

“Freeze it at 02:24:06,” I said. Susan paused the frame. The woman's sleeve rode up, just a fraction. "Zoom in."

The image pixelated, but there it was: a tattoo winking into view on her pale forearm. Small, indistinguishable in the video, but nevertheless, a distinct marking.

I leaned closer, eyes narrowing at the image. “Who was the teller on duty that day?”

“That’d be Leslie,” Susan replied. She reached for the intercom on the wall and pressed the button. “Leslie, front desk, please.”

Moments later, a brunette emerged. Mid-thirties, heavyset, her uniform straining at the seams, but her eyes sharp, alive. She wore a crooked name tag—Leslie. Her smile was polite, but her stance wary.

I didn’t bother with a handshake, just a simple nod in her direction, and kept my tone clean and professional. “Special Agent Katherine Hastings, FBI. I need to ask you about the couple who rented the SUV. You remember them?”

“Oh, I remember.” Leslie’s mouth twisted with distaste, her eyes sparkling with recognition. “Long sleeves pulled down tight even though the night was warm, ball caps tugged low over their brows, and both were wearing sunglasses even though it was still dark outside. The woman—she was jittery, strung out on something, maybe meth. Couldn’t stop fidgeting.”

“Was there any interaction between them? Did the woman address the man by name?” I pressed, keeping my questions tight, probing for behavioral tells.

Leslie shook her head, folding her arms tight across her chest. “Hardly a word,” she muttered. She paused, frowning as if she was replaying it in her mind, then reached for the mouse and dragged the video back a few frames. “But look—watch this.”

On the screen, the shapes moved in the harsh, flickering light, their outlines blurred but clear enough to read. Leslie leaned closer, her finger tapping the monitor. “See here? She keeps trying to touch him. An arm around his waist, leaning into his side, reaching for him like she doesn’t want to stand alone. Over and over again.”

She let out a short breath, almost a laugh but without any humor. “And him—he pushes her off. Every time. Not gentle either. He shoves her like he can’t stand the feel of her near him."

I turned back to the screen, studied the man’s flinches. His whole body was stiff, radiating tension, like every touch burned. Interesting.

Maybe he was angry with her. Embarrassed, even. Or maybe he just wanted distance. But it felt heavier than that. Tense. Guarded. Like he didn’t trust her, didn’t like her, wanted it spelled out in every shove that whatever they had—it wasn’t closeness. It was business. Purely transactional.

“Height on the male?” I asked.

“Six feet, maybe an inch over,” Leslie said, her voice firm.

I pointed to the frozen frame, the woman’s tattoo glaring back. “And that marking. Can you tell me what it is?” I pulled my phone out from my pocket and took a quick photo.

“Butterfly tattoo,” Leslie answered without hesitation, nodding firmly. “Small, black and blue, about half an inch across, right here.” She tapped her own forearm, mirroring the spot. "Stood out ‘cause her skin was ghost-pale.”

My lips curved into a small, satisfied smile.

A lead.