Chapter 38

Chapter Title: Cheesecake

Kathy

I eased my car to a stop in front of Kimberly’s house, staring through the windshield longer than I should have. This place gave me relief, something close to sanctuary. But at the moment, it unsettled me.

I hated to admit it, but the Ryder brothers were getting under my skin. Though my mind was on Kimberly, my body ached for something else entirely, a fleeting heat only a man’s touch could offer. The betrayal felt like shame and hunger all at once, leaving only an emptiness that no badge, no case file, no training could soothe.

I shut off the engine. Silence fell, pressing into my ears. The street was still—too still for an early morning. It was a stillness that carried weight, like someone was watching me from a distance.

I got out of the car, my bag heavy on my shoulder. The air smelled of salt from the nearby ocean and a sweet hint of flowers from a neighbor's garden. I looked around, my eyes quickly scanning for movement, but nobody was on the street.

Just as I started toward the porch, my phone buzzed, sharp and loud.

Ace.

A file. Photos and the unknown fingerprints.

I opened it, my thumb moving fast, though it felt strange, like it wasn’t mine. My eyes skimmed the contents but then froze on one detail—Kimberly's palm print on the SUV's window. The weight of what I saw followed me all the way to the door—and that’s when I noticed it.

Sitting like a curse.

A black paper bag, glossy and deliberate, perched neatly in front of the door. A small gift tag dangled from the handle, fluttering slightly in the ocean breeze.

I crouched without thinking, already reaching for the latex gloves I kept in my jacket. The snap of rubber around my wrists was a small ritual, a comfort, a sharpening of focus. Gloves always made me feel more like an agent—clinical, detached, steel-edged.

Carefully, I lifted the bag. The paper crinkled like it was holding its breath.

Inside were two perfect slices of cheesecake, each sealed in a dainty white box, tied with pale blue ribbons. Not random. Not grocery store. Curated.

My heart raced. A cold feeling ran up my back.

I knew exactly where they were from.

Martha’s Cheesecake Spot.

And that was impossible.

The ribbons blurred as my throat tightened. There was only one person who loved that cheesecake more than my father’s, more than anyone—

Kelly.

Kimberly’s twin.

Our sister.

Identical in every way except for the tiny birthmark on her wrist, the one she hated, the one I loved because it was how I told them apart.

Kelly, the reason I put on this badge in the first place. Kelly, the ghost who had fueled every choice I ever made until the trail went so cold I thought I’d freeze with it.

I slid Kimberly’s key into the lock with stiff fingers. My gaze darted to the folded slip of paper I’d wedged in the doorframe earlier. Still there. Still frayed from the salt air. Untouched. At least that meant no one had entered the house.

But someone had been here.

With cheesecake.

I brought the bag and my pack inside, setting both on the counter. My hands shook as I turned the gift tag over, reading the delicate, cursive logo stamped on it.

Martha’s Cheesecake Spot.

No mistake.

The past came rushing back, heavy and dark.

I peeled off my boots and shrugged out of my jacket, but the chill inside me stayed. Curling up on the sofa, knees to my chest, I let the flood of memory drown me.

During the divorce, Dad had taken Kimberly and me, while Kelly stayed with Mom. Two halves of the same whole torn in opposite directions. People used to frown, confused, when they realized her last name didn’t match ours. We’d shrug and say, “Divorce,” like it explained everything. It never did.

She’d been a junior at NYU when she vanished. Walked out of her dorm one morning, never came back.

If I shut my eyes, I could still see her—her quick smile, her dark hair shining in the sun, the way she hummed songs I didn’t know.

I still remember the flyers Mom plastered everywhere—her shaking hands pinning them up even though she could barely stand from chemo. She offered what little she had as a reward, begging strangers for scraps of information. The problem was, with Kimberly looking exactly like her twin, the calls that trickled in always pointed to the wrong girl. Each wrong call hurt more.

I haunted the police station daily, a college kid with no badge, asking for answers, hoping for a miracle. Every time, the answer was the same:

“Nothing. Come back tomorrow.”

Until tomorrow became a punchline, and then they shifted their theory.

“She probably ran away. Couldn’t handle the pressure of caring for your mom.”

I wanted to rip their smug faces off. Kelly wasn’t like that. She was strong, loyal, the one who’d stay up all night reading poems to Mom to ease her pain. She wouldn’t run.

I pushed harder. Questioned her friends, her professors, anyone who might’ve seen something. Walls. Always walls. One professor, a smug bastard with tenure, even threatened to sue me for harassment. A friend of Kelly’s slipped once, mentioned a boyfriend—someone new, someone she hadn’t told me about. That was my lead.

I built theories—an affair gone wrong, a jealous partner, Kelly silenced to keep a secret. But every thread unraveled. Paper trails vanished. Alibis held like iron. No one cracked.

But I overlooked one detail.

The bakery.

Kelly had been obsessed with Martha’s Cheesecake Spot, a tiny shop tucked in a corner of the Village. She’d bring boxes back to Mom’s apartment, swearing their cheesecake had “the fluffiest whipped topping in the state.” She’d sit by the window, savoring each bite, watching the world pass by with that dreamy look she got when she was lost in thought.

I never followed up. Never asked the owner, never pressed the staff. Fear held me back—the fear of hearing we don’t remember her, or worse, yes, we do.

That changed in my rookie year with the FBI, six months after Kelly vanished. A call came in about a body that had washed up on the East River, matching her description. The coroner’s preliminary forensic data pointed to Kelly Lawrence. They needed someone to identify her, but Kimberly couldn’t face it, Mom was too sick, and Dad didn’t have the stomach for a morgue. So I flew in from the FBI training facility in Virginia, my heart a lead weight in my chest.

When the coroner pulled back the white sheet, I wasn’t prepared. The body wasn’t the Kelly I remembered—not the vibrant, laughing sister who’d tease me about my terrible taste in music. She was ghostly white, frail, with dark circles carved under her eyes and her head shaved bald. She looked like a stranger wearing my sister’s face.

"Cause of death, overdose," a detective from the NYPD Special Victims Unit read the coroner's findings aloud. "Heroin."

I shook my head, my voice sharp. “That’s impossible. Kelly didn’t do drugs.”

The detective, a woman with kind eyes but a tired face, placed her hand on my shoulder, perhaps to comfort me. “We believe you, Ms. Hastings. We’re treating this as a homicide. The coroner found ligature marks around her wrists and neck. We think she was abducted, drugged, and sold into the sex trade.” She slid a stack of photos across the table, and I reached for one, my fingers brushing the glossy surface. It was Kelly’s bracelet—the matching half of Kimberly’s, a delicate gold chain with her initials.

“And all this time, you said my sister ran away,” I hissed, my voice trembling with rage. “Any suspects?”

The detective’s jaw tightened. “The body was cleaned before it was dumped. No nails, no hair, no stomach contents. But we have a lead—a group of smuggled women were found at a sex den last week.”

“No,” I said, shaking my head, sliding the photo of Kelly’s bracelet back toward her. “That sex den isn’t tied to her case. If it was, this bracelet wouldn’t be on her wrist. Someone wanted her family to find her. Someone who knew her, maybe even cared about her at one point. Anything else?”

The detective hesitated, then said, “She’d been dead for three months. Stored in a freezer, thawed out before being dumped in the river. Also… she was pregnant. Three months. The coroner’s running paternal DNA. If the father’s in the system, we’ll find him.”

But they didn’t find him. They didn’t find anything. The case went cold, and the leads dried up like rain on pavement.

Mom died a month after we buried Kelly. She stopped eating, stopped sleeping, stopped taking her meds. She’d sit by the window, staring at nothing, whispering, “Maybe today is the day we get to be together, Kelly.” Her hope broke her before the cancer could.

Kimberly... she moved forward by force alone—school, graduation, work—life like an endless treadmill. And so did my dad, until death finally took him.

Three years ago, I called Kimberly, and she told me she was at Martha’s.

“What are you doing at Martha’s?” I asked, surprised.

“It’s her death anniversary, Kathy,” Kimberly said, her voice thick with hurt and disappointment. “She loved this cheesecake. Remember? Strawberry and blueberry. Always both."

Oh yes, I remembered. I remembered everything.

And now, years later, cheesecake had appeared on Kimberly's doorstep like a taunt.

A memory.

A clue.

A threat.

Or all three.

I buried my face in my arms, the weight of everything—Kelly gone, Kimberly missing, the world closing in—crashing over me like a tidal wave. For the first time in years, tears came hard and fast, wracking sobs that tore through me, leaving my chest raw and my throat burning. The pain was a living thing, clawing at my ribs, demanding to be felt.

What if this wasn’t a gift? What if it was a message?

What if someone was telling me I wouldn’t find Kimberly?

And worse—what if they were right?

My tears slowed, my breathing steadied—training doesn’t let you collapse for long. The agent in me clawed its way back, demanding control, demanding action.

I lifted my head, swiping my sleeve roughly across my face. The black paper bag still sat on the counter, the gift tag curling at the corner like it was mocking me.

I forced myself to my feet, my legs unsteady at first, and crossed to the counter. My gloves were still on, slick with sweat inside, clinging to my skin. I picked up the gift tag and held it closer to the light, studying it with a clarity that felt almost unnatural.

It had one word, written in ink: Remember.

The handwriting wasn’t the bakery’s usual elegant cursive, the kind they used for custom orders. This was blockier, sharper, like someone trying too hard to be precise, to hide their natural hand.

Then I saw it.

On the underside of one ribbon, a faint smudge, barely visible unless you tilted it just right under the light. White, grainy, not ink.

Powder.

My chest locked, my breath catching in my throat.

I grabbed a small evidence pouch from my bag and, with a pair of tweezers, carefully snipped the ribbon free. I slipped it into the pouch, sealed it, and labeled it with a steady hand, the rhythm of procedure grounding me—catalog, preserve, test. But it wasn’t just the powder that stopped me cold. It was the shape of the smudge.

A fingerprint.

Whoever left this wanted me to find it.

The back of my neck prickled, a primal warning. I turned slowly toward the living room window, the curtains half-open, revealing the street beyond.

Someone had been here. Maybe still was.

The cheesecakes sat on the counter, glowing under the light like an offering—or bait.

The air tightened around me.

This wasn’t just about Kimberly anymore.

Kelly's ghost was here.