Chapter 37

Chapter Title: Crossing Lines

Kathy

Dorsey shuffled into the diner like a relic from a forgotten time, his gray hair wild and thinning, curling at the edges like wisps of smoke. His face was a roadmap of deep creases, etched by years under the relentless Crisfield sun, and his dark coveralls hung loosely on his wiry frame, streaked with grease that hinted at long days in the scrapyard. There was something unsettling about him—a quiet menace in the way his dark eyes darted, sharp and calculating, always one step ahead. He wasn’t the kind of man you’d want to meet in a dark alley, let alone share a diner booth with at dawn.

The hum of conversation in the diner faltered as Dorsey crossed the threshold. At a nearby table, Cole and his friends fell silent, their easy laughter snuffed out like a candle in a storm. Cole’s usual smirk vanished, replaced by a wary glance at the man who entered, his fingers tightening around his coffee mug. The air thickened, the clink of silverware and the faint buzz of the diner’s ancient jukebox fading into a tense hush. Dorsey’s presence cast a shadow over the room, and I felt like I’d stumbled into a scene from a true-crime documentary, where the quiet old man knows more than he’ll ever say.

Dorsey made his way to our booth, his steps slow but deliberate, like a predator sizing up its prey. Alice, the diner’s lone waitress at this hour, appeared with a plate piled high with scrambled eggs, crispy bacon, and butter-drenched toast. She set it down with practiced ease, along with a fresh mug of black coffee, its steam curling into the air like morning fog.

I kept my face composed despite Archer’s thigh brushing mine. That first touch was like a spark catching on dry tinder—subtle, almost deniable, but it spread fast. When his leg pressed again, firmer, a sharp pulse shot between my legs, nearly making me shift in my seat.

“Dorsey, this is Katherine Hastings,” Archer said, his voice steady but laced with a formality that felt out of place among the diner’s chipped mugs and worn vinyl seats. “Katherine, meet Dorsey. He’s an old friend of our father’s.”

Then Archer’s hand slid onto my thigh. Heavy. Possessive. Fingers curling into muscle like they belonged there. My breath caught, and I prayed no one noticed the way my chest rose too quickly. His thumb moved, drawing slow circles that sent my pulse skittering and my temperature rising.

I was burning up in a cheap vinyl booth at six in the morning, sweat beading under my collar, heat pooling low. My FBI training screamed to stay sharp, but all I could focus on was the press of his hand, the dangerous promise in that lazy rhythm.

Dorsey’s eyes flicked to me, dark and unreadable. I forced a cool nod, but under the table, my thighs tightened around Archer’s touch. He knew it. I knew he knew.

“You find the car?” Dorsey asked, his voice like gravel dragging over stone.

It took me a beat too long to process. Ace answered for me, his jacket creaking as he leaned back, and I clung to his voice like a lifeline.

“Car was junk. Someone got it into the crusher before we could get a good look.”

Archer’s thumb pressed harder, stroking upward, grazing the seam of my jeans. My heartbeat thudded in my ears. I should’ve been dissecting Ace’s words, filing them, cross-referencing timelines. Instead, I bit the inside of my cheek to keep from shifting against Archer’s hand.

Dorsey chewed his bacon, slow and deliberate. “Earl,” he muttered, disdain dripping. “Can’t blame him, though. Scrapyard and mechanic work barely keep the lights on. You boys take pictures of the car, at least?” Ace nodded. “That oughta be enough. But I didn’t tell anyone about the car. Don’t even know if Earl knew what he had. Maybe someone paid him to crush it, but that don’t sit right. Earl’s too lazy to run the crusher himself.”

I barely registered Dorsey’s words, catching fragments like radio static. My focus tunneled to the heat spreading through me, my body coiled and restless.

“So, who does know how to run it?” Archer asked, his other hand drumming on the table while the one on my thigh tightened.

Archer’s thumb brushed higher, so close to my center that my thighs clamped shut instinctively, trapping his hand. I should’ve pushed him away. I should’ve done anything. Instead, I sat frozen, pulse hammering, every ounce of discipline torn between the conversation and the molten ache consuming me.

My breath hitched as I felt his fingers move again. Heat unfurled in my belly, pooling between my thighs. I shifted, but that only pressed his hand tighter, my body betraying me with a clench that burned hotter.

Dorsey’s voice was faint, muffled by the blood rushing in my ears. “Marty’s boy, Junior. Works for me in the summers. Clocks in at eight, leaves when I do. Except yesterday—he stayed late.”

Important detail. Vital. But I barely processed it. Archer’s fingertips grazed higher, brushing the heat of me through denim, and it was all I could do not to let a sound escape. My nails dug crescents into the ceramic mug I clutched. I forced my breath steady, forced myself to meet Dorsey’s eyes, when every nerve screamed to close them and give in.

Ace leaned forward, his voice dropping to a conspiratorial whisper. “You think Earl and Junior are working together?”

“Could be.” Dorsey scraped the last of his eggs, his fork clinking against the plate like a warning bell. “Scrapyard’s a two-man job at least. Takes muscle and know-how to run that crusher.”

Another inch, and Archer would be touching the kind of warmth I was desperate to hide.

I swallowed hard, fingers gripping my coffee mug. The ceramic burned my palms, but it was nothing compared to the heat between my legs. I shifted, trying to angle away, but that only pressed me harder against Archer’s hand. He didn’t pull back. He never pulled back.

But when Dorsey turned his gaze to me, Archer withdrew his hand, leaving a chill like a draft through a cracked window. “Ms. Hastings, I’m real sorry about your sister. I want nothing more than to help find her. These folks—they’re good people. They didn’t know the car was evidence. I’ll ask around. People trust me in this town. If I hear anything, I’ll call Archer.” He drained his coffee in one long gulp, the mug clunking heavily on the table as he stood. He tugged his coveralls straight, the fabric snapping softly, and gave a nod that felt more like a dismissal than a goodbye.

That was my cue.

“I’m heading out too,” I said, keeping my voice steady as my trembling hands fished a hundred-dollar bill from my pocket to cover our meal, Dorsey’s, Cole’s, and a tip for Alice. The crumpled bill felt like a small act of defiance against the weight of Archer’s touch.

Archer slid the money back toward me, a mischievous smirk on his lips. “On the house, Katherine.”

I shook my head, pushing the bill back. “Archer, that money’s Divine’s. She’s footing the bill for all of this.” I paused, forcing lightness into my voice. “And please—call me Kathy. The only person who called me Katherine was…” I faltered, a nervous laugh escaping. “My dad.”

The lie tasted bitter. Kimberly had been cagey about our family, guarding our secrets like a dragon hoarding gold. Mentioning our father was safe enough—a half-truth that wouldn’t raise eyebrows in Crisfield. The rest of our story, the tangled mess of our past, was better left buried. For now.

Archer’s eyes glinted briefly as he pocketed the cash with a nod. “In that case, thank you, Divine.” His voice carried a sharp edge when he said her name. He obviously didn’t like her.

Something to ask about on our way to Ocean City.

“Oh, and a tip for Alice,” I added, nudging him out of the booth with a shove harder than I intended. “Where do we meet up, Ace?”

Ace didn’t respond. His eyes were glued to his phone, his brow furrowed so deeply it looked like it might crack. His thumb hovered over the screen, frozen, as if whatever he’d just read had stolen the air from his lungs.

“Ace?” I waved a hand in front of his face, my voice sharper now. “Problem?”

He blinked, startled, and cleared his throat, shoving his phone into his pocket with a quickness that screamed guilt. “No, nothing. Just… I need to make a quick stop at the Williamson estate. Let’s meet there.”

I studied him, noting the way his jaw tightened, the way his eyes wouldn’t quite meet mine. Something was off, but pushing him now would only make him clam up tighter. “Fine,” I said, keeping my tone light, though Archer’s touch still had me burning.

I waved a quick goodbye and stepped into the crisp morning air, grateful for the chill.

I should’ve pushed Archer away. I should’ve leaned forward, broken contact, anything. But despite the warning in my head, every nerve screamed with awareness as his hand had crept upward...

I let out a jagged sigh. I needed a cold shower.

I was halfway to my car when I heard Cole’s voice, low and tense, drifting from the diner’s open window. Instinctively, I ducked behind a scraggly bush, pretending to fumble with my keys.

“Ems, we talked about this,” Cole said, his voice tight with frustration, barely audible over the diner’s hum. “We agreed to never bring it up again.” A pause, heavy with unspoken weight. “Yeah, I saw her too. No, I didn’t tell her anything. I don’t care what those messages told me to do. Besides, the only ones who know are you, me, Allison, and Divine. It’s probably some clown thinking it’s a funny prank.” Another pause, longer this time, as if he were weighing his next words carefully. “And risk Hank hating her forever? Not a chance. The only reason he does everything she asks is because he believes she was right about her. If he finds out the truth, it’s over—for all of us. So no, she won’t double-cross us.”

My heart thudded in my chest, loud enough I was sure they’d hear it. I stayed low, the bush’s sharp edges scratching at my jacket. Cole’s words spun in my head, each one a puzzle piece that didn’t quite fit. Hank. Divine. A secret so ugly it could shatter loyalties. An ex-girlfriend, maybe? Someone they’d all conspired to erase?

“Hastings?” Ace’s voice cut through the haze, sharp and close.

I shot to my feet, jingling my keys like a bad actor in a community theater production. “Dropped my keys,” I said, my voice too bright, my back still turned to him. “I’ll catch you later.”

I slid into my car, my hands shaking as I gripped the steering wheel. I didn’t look back at Ace, didn’t dare meet his eyes. My mind raced, connecting dots that weren’t fully formed. Hank didn’t follow Divine blindly—he followed her because of something in the past, something she’d been “right” about. Something that tied Cole, Emma, Allison, and her together in a web of lies.

And now, Kimberly was gone. Just like someone else had disappeared.

The engine roared to life, and as I pulled out of the lot, the sinking feeling in my gut hardened into certainty. Divine and her so-called friends were hiding something—something big.

Things were getting very interesting.