Chapter 21
Chapter Title: Paper Walls
Kathy
The air in Crisfield clung like a damp shroud, heavier than a summer afternoon should allow. Humidity pressed against my temples, but it was the weight of unanswered questions that made breathing a chore.
I slid on my blazer as I climbed the creaking steps of the converted rowhouse on Fairmont Street, each groan of the warped wood echoing the unease in my gut. The building was old, its faded brick softened by ivy crawling like veins up the walls. A green-trimmed door stood at the top, its brass placard glinting in the hazy sunlight:
Rivera Legal Associates—Client-First. Justice Always.
The words felt like a promise, but in this town, promises crumbled like oyster shells ground into the sidewalks.
A chime jingled as I pushed through the door. The waiting room greeted me with calculated warmth: terracotta floors polished to a soft glow, bookshelves stuffed with leather-bound legal tomes and creased issues of Modern Justice. A bowl of butterscotch candies sat on the receptionist’s desk, cellophane wrappers catching the light like tiny beacons. The air carried crisp paper and a faint trace of bergamot, likely from a diffuser humming in the corner. It was comforting in a no-nonsense way, a place that promised order in a world that rarely delivered.
The receptionist, a young woman with a sleek bob and a nameplate reading Heather, looked up from her computer. Her polite smile was practiced, but her eyes cataloged me: the slight crease in my blazer, the subtle bulge of the badge at my waist. “You must be Special Agent Hastings,” she said, her voice smooth and courteous. “Ms. Rivera is expecting you.”
“Thank you,” I said, my tone clipped. My agent instincts were awake, tugging at details—the faint scuff on the floor near the door, the stack of unopened mail tucked behind the candy bowl, Heather’s fingers hovering on her phone. Details mattered. Always.
Janet Rivera’s office was at the end of a narrow hallway lined with framed certificates and faded photos of Crisfield’s waterfront in better days. Her door was open, an unspoken invitation. She stood as I entered, her presence filling the small space.
Janet was tall, dark hair swept into a low bun that spoke of efficiency over vanity. Early forties, with sharp hazel eyes that dissected the world in a glance. Her navy blazer and crisp white blouse were impeccable, unadorned save for a slim silver ring on her thumb and a steel watch that ticked with relentless precision. A lawyer’s calm radiated from her, the kind most mistook for coldness but I recognized as control.
“Agent Hastings. I wasn’t aware Kimberly Hastings had a sister—and an FBI agent, at that.” Her voice was low and measured, precise as if she were reading from a case file. “Please, have a seat.”
I settled into the leather chair across her mahogany desk, its creak breaking the silence. The office was orderly: a single potted fern in the corner, a window with salt-streaked glass overlooking the street, the late afternoon sun filtering through. A faint hum of traffic mixed with distant gull cries from the harbor.
Janet didn’t waste time. “I assume you’re here about the Williamsons,” she said, folding her hands neatly on the desk, her silver ring catching the light. “Specifically, the prenuptial agreement.”
“I’m here for the truth,” I said, meeting her gaze. “But the prenup’s a good place to start.”
She nodded, a flicker of approval in her eyes. “The agreement was pushed hard by Divine Williamson. Not by Hank."
“Really?” I raised an eyebrow, surprised. Hank Williamson—tall, blond, polished like he’d stepped out of a yacht club catalog—seemed the type to guard his family’s fortune with an iron grip. “That doesn’t add up.”
“It shouldn’t,” Janet said, her voice steady as steel. “But Divine controls the family’s finances. The Williamson name carries political weight, sure—but it’s the Wincroft name, Crisfield’s last gilded dynasty, that holds the real power. Naturally, Divine Williamson is the one with the claws. Hank is…” She hesitated, searching for the right word. “Agreeable. Polished. But deferential. A shadow the moment his mother enters the room.”
I pictured Hank shrinking under Divine’s shadow. It wasn’t hard to imagine. Divine Williamson was a force, her name whispered in Crisfield like a warning, the kind of woman who could silence a room with an arched brow.
“And Kimberly?” I asked, keeping my voice neutral despite the ache her name stirred.
Janet hesitated, the first crack in her composure. Her fingers twitched, as if resisting the urge to reach for something—a pen, a file, anything to anchor her. “Kimberly didn’t want to sign it at first. She was offended by the insinuation, the idea she was after their money. But she wasn’t naive—she knew what marrying into a family like that required.”
“What changed her mind?” I pressed, leaning forward slightly.
Janet’s jaw tightened, a muscle flickering beneath her skin. “Our closed-door meeting. During negotiations, Kimberly admitted she had doubts about the role they expected: wife, baby-maker, support system for Hank’s ambitions. Divine didn’t flinch—just stared at us, cold as the bay in January, and said Kimberly should ‘reconsider marrying her son’ if she had a problem. Kimberly looked… dimmed after that, like someone had snuffed out her fire.”
I frowned, the image of Kimberly—vibrant, stubborn, her laugh bright enough to fill a room—fading under Divine’s gaze twisting something in my chest. I kept my face steady, professional. “It wasn’t about the money, was it?”
“No,” Janet said sharply. “Kimberly didn’t care about trust funds or inheritances. She’d built her bakery from the ground up—storefront, local awards, all from scratch. She wanted respect. She didn’t get it.”
“Was there anything in the prenup that could’ve threatened her?” I asked, my hands clasped to keep them still.
“No,” Janet replied, her voice firm but her eyes narrowing, as if turning over a memory. “I made sure of it. If anything, the language was unusually clean. Too clean.”
“Too clean?” I echoed, my instincts prickling. Janet reached into a drawer and slid a manila folder across the desk. I opened it, revealing the prenup—pages of black-and-white clauses, notarized signatures, cold ink on colder terms.
“It’s straightforward,” she said. “If they divorced, Kimberly would walk away with only what she brought in. No claims to Williamson assets. No alimony. No exceptions.”
“She didn’t bring much,” I said quietly, skimming the document, my mind flashing to Kimberly’s bakery, her recipes, her grit.
“She brought herself,” Janet snapped, her voice cutting like a blade. “Her intelligence, her name, her bakery. The idea that she was disposable—replaceable—it infuriated me.”
I looked up, catching the fire in her eyes. “Did you ever confront Divine?” Janet’s lips curved into a humorless smile.
“There’s no confronting Divine Williamson. You speak, and she lets you know when she’s done listening. It’s like arguing with a tidal wave.”
“And Hank?” I asked, picturing his easy smile, the one that never reached his eyes.
“Cordial. Distracted. He’d parrot whatever Divine said in meetings, like a well-trained dog. Kimberly called him a ‘well-dressed ventriloquist dummy’ once.” Janet’s voice softened, a flicker of amusement breaking through. “She had a way with words.”
I brows arched, surprised. “She said that to you?”
“She said a lot,” Janet replied, her tone gentler. “In our last meeting, she mentioned canceling the wedding.”
My pulse quickened, but I kept my expression steady. “When was that?”
“A week before she disappeared,” Janet said, her voice heavy.
“Was she serious?” I pressed.
“She was scared,” Janet admitted, her eyes locking onto mine. “Not just about the prenup. She said she didn’t feel safe, that people were ‘watching her more closely.’ She didn’t elaborate—brushed it off like it was nothing—but I could see it in her face. Something was eating at her.”
A pulse of dread bloomed beneath my ribs, cold and sharp. “Did she say what?”
Janet shook her head, her lips pressing into a thin line. “Only that she felt trapped. She’d started carrying pepper spray again, the kind she used when she worked late nights at the bakery. That caught my attention. She wasn’t the paranoid type.”
I took that in, the dread coiling tighter. Kimberly hadn’t told me anything, but I couldn’t let that show. Not here. “Anything else? Anything that seemed off at the time?”
Janet’s brow furrowed, her gaze drifting to the window, searching the fading light. “She asked a strange question,” she said slowly. “She asked… what would happen if someone was forced to sign something under duress. Would it still hold?"
The room went silent, the word duress hanging like a storm cloud. My mind raced—Kimberly’s fear, the pepper spray, the prenup’s sterile clauses—pieces of a puzzle I couldn’t yet see.
Janet leaned forward, her eyes burning with intensity. “Agent Hastings, I know you’re not here just to collect facts. You want answers. So do I. If something happened to Kimberly—if she was coerced, threatened, manipulated—I want those responsible held accountable. No matter their name.”
I nodded, rising from my seat, my hands clenched at my sides. “I appreciate your candor, Ms. Rivera. We’re on the same page.”
She stood, her voice dropping to a whisper that carried a warning. “Be careful, Agent Hastings. That family—especially Divine—doesn’t play fair. And if Kimberly was silenced…” She paused, her gaze unyielding. “They didn’t do it alone.”
I held her stare, the air thick with unspoken stakes. Then I turned for the door, the prenup folder tucked under my arm, its weight heavier than paper should be. Outside, the sun dipped lower, casting long shadows across Fairmont Street. Somewhere in those shadows, the truth was hiding.
And I’d tear this town apart to find it.