Chapter 20

Chapter Title: Sun-kissed and Aviators

Kathy

"I respect you, Kathy. I just don't know if I can trust you."

“Good,” I shot back without hesitation. “Because I don’t trust you either.”

The silence that followed wasn’t hostile, but it wasn’t comfortable either. It was charged, like the air before a storm, humming with the weight of two people sizing each other up. Two chess players who’d just realized they were evenly matched, each waiting for the other to make a move—or a mistake.

He studied me for a moment, his head tilted slightly, the faintest crease between his brows. Then he asked, “Why are you really here, Hastings?”

I blinked, thrown by the question being turned back on me. “I told you. I’m looking for my sister.”

“No, I mean here,” he said, gesturing vaguely at the boutique, the street, the whole damn town. “You could’ve called Emma. You could’ve asked around by phone. But you’re here, in person, stirring things up. Why?”

I opened my mouth, then closed it. He wasn’t wrong, and that irritated me more than I wanted to admit. I could’ve done this from a distance, but something about Kimberly’s disappearance had pulled me to Crisfield, to this sleepy coastal town where secrets seemed to cling to the air like humidity. I didn’t have an answer that didn’t sound like a gut feeling, and I wasn’t about to bare that to him.

“Maybe I like the scenery,” I said, deflecting with a half-smile.

He didn’t buy it. His eyes narrowed slightly, like he was trying to read the fine print of my soul.

“Scenery’s nice,” he said, “but it doesn’t explain why you’re poking around Emma’s shop like you’re looking for a smoking gun.”

“Maybe I’m just shopping,” I said, holding up the paper bag as evidence.

He snorted. “You’re not the boutique type, Hastings. You’re more… dive bar and determination.”

I raised an eyebrow. “You think you’ve got me figured out?”

“Not even close,” he said, his grin returning, softer this time. “But I’m working on it.”

I shook my head, fighting the urge to smile back. “You didn’t answer my question. Why are you here?”

He shrugged, the motion too casual to be entirely believable. “I need to pick up something.”

“That’s vague." I gave him a look. “Our deal was for me to follow my leads alone, then dinner tonight. You showing up here makes it look like you don’t want dinner after all. That’s fine. I was planning to grab something from Lace and Timber anyway. And... I can use this dress I bought some other time."

He looked mildly offended. “What? No. I’m here to pick up a shawl for my neighbor. She’s turning eighty-six tomorrow and likes soft things. Emma carries this ridiculous handmade alpaca stuff. I swear, Kathy, we’re just orbiting the same town today.”

Then, like it was nothing, he slipped his aviators onto his face. The effect was rude. And unfair. And unfairly hot. The sunglasses only amplified the whole golden-boy vibe, like he’d been designed to make hearts stutter and good sense falter. He leaned against the driver’s side of my car, his hip brushing the handle, close enough that if I wanted to open the door, I’d have to step into his space.

He knew it too—his grin said so, all lazy confidence and calculated charm. “I’ll pick you up at five-thirty, okay?” he said, like it was a done deal. “It’s almost two. Shouldn’t you be headed back to get ready? I know I've been single for so long, but I still know girls need hours to prepare."

I scoffed, rolling my eyes. “I’m not your usual girl, Ace. I can be ready in fifteen.”

He smirked. “Dangerous.”

“I try,” I said, opening the car door, forcing him to step back. “Can I at least know what I’m supposed to dress for?”

“And ruin the surprise?” His grin widened as he pulled the door the rest of the way open for me, the gesture so smooth it felt like a trap. “Five-thirty, Hastings. Be ready. No blazer. You’ll hate me if you wear a blazer.”

I slid into the driver’s seat, but he didn’t move. For a second, it was just him and me in the narrow frame of the open door. He braced one hand lightly against the roof of my car, leaning down just enough that his cologne wrapped around me—dizzying, intimate, like a summer night you couldn’t shake. His other hand hovered by the doorframe, close enough that if I shifted my fingers an inch, we would’ve touched. The heat of him pressed into the air between us, charged and unspoken, like a wire pulled taut.

“Careful, Hastings,” he murmured, his voice low enough to catch against my skin, rough and warm. “Keep looking at me like that, and I’ll think you actually want dinner with me.”

My breath caught, traitorous and unbidden. I tightened my grip on the steering wheel, pretending not to notice the goosebumps prickling along my arms. I glanced up at him once, and instantly regretted it. His sunglasses reflected the sun, but not before I caught the ghost of something sincere beneath them—something that wasn’t just charm or games. For a split second, I wanted to lean that fraction closer, to see if his mouth was as warm as his words, to see if he’d flinch or lean in too.

Instead, I started the car, the engine’s rumble snapping the moment in half. He stepped back with a knowing smirk, giving me a two-finger salute as I pulled away.

And damn it, I waved back.

I didn’t even mean to. My hand just… did it. Reflex. Muscle memory. Or maybe it was the way he’d said my name, like it was something familiar, something worth holding onto. Like it wasn’t just a name but a promise.

I cursed under my breath and gripped the wheel tighter. This wasn’t what I came to Crisfield for.

Ace Ryder was a distraction I couldn’t afford—a complication wrapped in charm and secrets, with eyes that saw too much and a smile that promised trouble. But something told me—deep in my gut, where instincts lived and logic didn’t always win—that this town wasn’t done throwing him in my path.

And next time, I might not wave.

I might not even walk away.

Because as much as I hated to admit it, there was something about Ace Ryder that felt like a lead I couldn’t ignore. Not because I trusted him, but because I didn’t. And in a town like Crisfield, where secrets clung to the salt air and truths hid in plain sight, that made him dangerous.

But it also made him useful.

I glanced in the rearview mirror as I drove away, half-expecting to see him still standing there, watching me go. He wasn’t. The street was empty, the boutique fading into the haze of the afternoon sun.

But I could still feel the weight of his gaze, like a promise—or a warning.

Five-thirty couldn’t come soon enough.

I shoved thoughts of Ace aside and pulled up to the curb, grabbing my phone from the passenger seat.

Before heading back to Kimberly’s place, I needed to track down Janet Rivera.