Chapter 98: Danny
We head down the street to a low-lit bar that’s just quiet enough for us to have this conversation in private. The place has an old-school charm, with leather booths and wood-paneled walls, and the soft jazz playing overhead almost makes me feel calm—almost. As soon as we settle into a booth, Riley flags down a waitress and orders a round for the table, glancing at Cole with a look that means business.
The drinks arrive, and Riley raises his glass, eyes locked on Cole. “To unexpected allies,” he says, a slight grin hinting at something deeper.
“To allies,” Cole echoes, clinking his glass with ours. He’s trying to look relaxed, but I can tell he’s curious. He’s no fool; he knows there’s more to this meetup than drinks and small talk.
After a beat, Riley starts filling him in, going over what we learned about the girls’ parents and the blackmail situation with Moretti’s men. Cole listens without interrupting, nodding every now and then, though his gaze sharpens when Riley mentions Sofia’s name.
“So, yeah,” I add, leaning back in my seat, “we’ll need to discuss next steps. But you know how it is. It’s gonna get messy.” I study him for a second. “We’d understand if you wanted out.”
Cole shifts, his jaw clenching slightly. He glances at his drink, then back at us. “Nah,” he says, keeping his voice even. “I’m here. I want to help, whatever it takes.” He shrugs, trying to make it sound casual, but I can see he’s all in.
Nate leans forward, his gaze fixed on Cole, eyes narrowed. “Alright, straight up,” he says, tone as serious as I’ve ever heard it. “Do you love her?”
Cole freezes, his glass halfway to his mouth, and it’s like he’s been slapped. His face turns a shade paler as he chokes on his drink, coughing and grabbing a napkin. “Uh, what?” he stammers, clearly taken aback.
Riley lets out a quiet chuckle, but his expression is anything but playful. “You heard him. Do you love Sofia?”
Cole swallows, shifting uncomfortably as he looks between us, like he’s half-expecting us to laugh and tell him it’s a joke. But we’re all dead serious, and he realizes it. “I mean, you guys are my bosses,” he finally manages, still rattled. “It’s not like that—I just wanted to help her out. She’s been through hell and…”
“Answer the question, Cole,” I cut in, my tone sharper than intended. But he needs to be straight with us. No more dodging.
He sighs, looking down into his glass as if it holds the answer. Finally, he speaks, his voice quieter than before. “Look… I didn’t plan on it. But yeah, I’ve gotten attached to her. It’s like she’s got me under some damn spell.”
Riley leans back, exchanging a look with Nate and me. We don’t need to say it; we all know that feeling, and we’re all caught in it, just like he is.
“Trust me, we get it,” Nate says, his tone surprisingly calm. “She has that effect. She’s the kind of person you want to be around, someone you want to protect.”
Cole lets out a short laugh, the tension breaking just a little. “I feel like an idiot,” he mutters. “If you need me to back off, tell me now. I get it, she’s your girl. I’ll keep my distance or… whatever you want.”
I glance at Riley, Leo and Nate, and Riley gives me a nod, a silent agreement passing between us. “Actually,” I say, looking back at Cole, “we think it’d be better if you came to stay with us. That is, if you’re really serious about helping her.”
Cole’s eyes widen, and he goes completely still, staring at us like he’s waiting for the punchline. “Wait… you’re serious?”
“Dead serious,” Nate says, not a hint of humor in his voice. “If you’re this invested in her, if she’s that important to you, it’s best if you’re close. Keep an eye on things from up close.”
Cole’s surprise shifts to something else—acceptance, maybe. He’s seeing that we mean it, that we’re all in this together. His hand tightens around his glass, and he nods, his voice steady. “Alright, then. Count me in.”
We linger at the bar a little longer, the atmosphere lightening with each round. It feels like a weight has lifted between us now that Cole’s part of the plan, part of us. We talk about everything and nothing, old stories from the past, ridiculous moments on missions, inside jokes that make us all laugh until we’re tearing up. For the first time, it feels like we’re all on the same side—not just because of the job or the crew, but because we care about Sofia, and we’d do anything to keep her safe. Cole’s part of that now, and it feels right, like he’s one of us.
When we finally head back to his place, it’s late, and we’re all feeling it. Cole unlocks the door, and we step inside, our laughter softening when we see Sofia asleep on the couch. She’s curled up, a blanket draped over her, and there’s something so peaceful about the way she looks that it makes us all pause.
“She’s out like a light,” Cole whispers with a grin.
Nate chuckles quietly, “Looks like she wore herself out with that Jenga of hers.”
We watch her for a second, and I feel the kind of calm I haven’t felt in a while. Knowing she’s safe, right here, puts us all at ease.
“She should stay here for the night,” I say finally, keeping my voice low. “No point waking her up just to drag her across the city.”
Cole nods. “Yeah, you’re right. I’ll bring her over in the morning, with my stuff.”
Riley pats him on the shoulder. “She’s in good hands with you tonight. See you both tomorrow.”
Before we leave, we pause, watching as Cole carefully bends down to pick Sofia up, her head resting naturally against his shoulder. There’s a gentleness in the way he holds her, like he’s already been doing it for years, like it’s the most natural thing in the world. He carries her to his room, moving quietly, his hand steady on her back. He closes the door softly behind him, a silent promise of care that none of us questions.
I exchange a look with Nate and Riley, a silent acknowledgment. Never in a million years did I think I’d be here, standing in the hallway of another man’s place, willing to share someone as important as Sofia. But looking at her now, asleep in Cole’s arms, it just feels right. For us, it works. There’s a balance in it, something I never thought I’d feel about sharing, but with Cole, it’s different. It feels like we’re stronger together, like it isn’t about losing any part of her but about giving her more.
We turn to leave, the unspoken bond between us settling comfortably as we step out into the cool night. There’s an unbreakable sense of trust, one I’m finally learning to lean on. We’ve got each other’s backs.