Chapter 97: Riley
We’re all huddled at Cole’s door, hearing Sofia’s laughter seep through. It’s a sound I didn’t realize I’d missed until now, soft and bright, filling the silence of the hallway outside his place. When Cole swings the door open, he gives us a casual nod, stepping aside so we can come in.
Inside, they’ve got this elaborate, wobbly tower of stacked fruits teetering on the coffee table, and Sofia’s holding her breath, hands clasped as she stares at the tower. “Cole, look, you’ll never beat that—” Her eyes flick up, and the smile on her face fades the second she sees us.
And man, it stings. Seeing her go from carefree and laughing to guarded in an instant, all because of us. I glance over at Nate, half-expecting him to hang back like the rest of us, but he doesn’t hesitate. He crosses the room and wraps his arms around her, whispering, “Hi, baby.”
She doesn’t resist him. Just stands there in his hold, letting him bury his face in her hair, her own arms hanging loosely by her sides. Cole takes a step back, his eyes flicking between us before he clears his throat. “I can step out if you guys need some time.”
Sofia shakes her head, her hand reaching out for him, almost instinctively. “No, please stay.”
Cole gives her a reassuring smile and stays put. I shift uncomfortably but try to keep my voice steady as I step forward, locking eyes with Sofia. “We talked to the girls’ parents,” I say, my tone a bit sharper than I intend. “We figured everything out and settled it.”
She nods slightly, but her expression stays blank, and that quiet, empty look... it grates on me. I feel the frustration bubbling up, and I take a step closer, unable to hold it in any longer. “Sofia, we would never touch anyone else or do anything to break your trust. You’ve gotta know that. We’re in this with you, all of us. We can’t have you staying mad at us forever.”
Cole cuts in, his voice calm but firm. “Hey, Riley, ease up a bit. She knows that, alright? But it doesn’t change how it looked from here.” He glances down at her, his eyes softening. “It’s a lot to process.”
Her face crumples a bit, and she wipes her cheeks, whispering, “I know you wouldn’t. I was just... hurt.” She glances at each of us, her eyes lingering on me. “It was hard to feel like I could be forgotten. I know it’s stupid, but—” her voice breaks off.
I step closer, my voice softening. “It’s not stupid. It’s not. Just trust me when I say there’s no one who could ever replace you, Sof.”
Danny comes up behind her, his hand on her shoulder, his eyes gentle. “You’re not easy to forget, alright? There’s no one like you, and we’ll prove it every day if that’s what it takes.”
A faint smile touches her lips, though her eyes are still glassy. She nods, finally, and leans back against Cole, who’s stayed quiet, keeping a steady hand on her shoulder.
Out of nowhere, Leo pushes past the rest of us, his face determined. Before any of us can react, he cups Sofia’s face, tilting it up and pressing his lips to hers in a kiss that’s full of apology, longing, and everything he hasn’t been able to say. She’s wide-eyed at first, her hands caught between them, but soon she melts into it, a small smile breaking through as she kisses him back.
When he finally pulls back, his hand lingers on her cheek, his words tumbling out in a rush. “I was an idiot, Sof. I shouldn’t have let them come to the house, shouldn’t have even thought of it. You mean... God, you mean everything to me, to all of us. I love you, alright? And I’m sorry. So damn sorry.”
A warmth lights up her eyes, and she places her hand over his, a full smile spreading across her face now. “It’s okay, Leo. I forgive you.” She glances around at the rest of us, letting her gaze settle on each of us for a beat. “I forgive all of you.”
We all let out a collective sigh, the tension finally breaking, and her smile widens as she reaches out, pulling us all into a hug.
Danny leans back, pointing at the stack of precariously balanced fruit pieces. “Alright, what’s up with this… tower thing?” he asks, raising an eyebrow, unable to hide his amusement.
Cole and Sofia exchange a quick look and laugh, clearly in on the joke together. “Sofia didn’t know what Jenga was,” Cole says, a playful grin spreading across his face. “And, well, I didn’t have the game on hand, so we had to make do.”
Sofia chimes in, giggling. “And when the fruit falls, we get to eat it,” she explains proudly, picking up a little apple slice that toppled over.
The room feels lighter, relaxed, just watching her laugh, like the tension between us guys fades away for a minute. It’s nice seeing her like this—at ease, enjoying the simplest things.
“We thought you’d be missing your books,” I say, lifting the bag we brought for her. She gasps, genuine happiness lighting up her face, and starts flipping through the notebooks we packed for her.
“Thank you! I missed having something to study,” she says, clutching the books to her chest.
I look at her, hoping she’ll be okay with our next request. “Hey, Sofia,” I start, keeping my tone light, “Would you be alright if we took Cole out for a quick drink? Just to thank him for taking care of you. Won’t be more than an hour.”
Cole raises an eyebrow, his face showing he’s not stupid—he can read right through us. He knows this isn’t just a drink. There’s a flicker of worry in his eyes, though he plays it cool. “Yeah, sure,” he says with a forced casualness, giving us a quick nod before turning back to Sofia. “Just an hour, alright?”
“Don’t worry,” she says, hugging her books with a grin, “I’ll try not to read through everything while you’re gone.” She hugs Cole, and I notice the way he looks at her for a second longer before we head out the door, leaving her to her schoolwork.