Chapter 45: I Was Broken
Chapter 45: I Was Broken
Andy
Ivy was mad at me.
She hadn’t visited since that day. It had been five days now, and the silence from her side of the world felt louder than any machine beeping in this sterile hospital room.
I honestly felt bad. Like, really bad. Maybe I shouldn’t have told her about watching her and Leo at the lake. What the hell was I even thinking?
Maybe I expected her to thank me for my honesty or brush it off like it was nothing. But that wasn’t how it went.
Ivy was hurt—deeply. And the more I replayed her words in my head, the shittier I felt.
She had likened it to the worst kind of violation. To rape. Those words cut deeper than any of Leo’s punches.
Why couldn’t I control myself when it came to Ivy and Leo? She had said it herself—she didn’t mind being used. So why did I care so much when the person in question was being used as a pawn?
I honestly felt very bad for making Ivy cry like that. But the sickest thing—the part that made me hate myself even more—was that I didn’t regret what I did or what I saw.
No matter how much I tried to forget it or shove it to the back of my mind, I couldn’t. I couldn’t stop seeing Ivy’s naked body laid out on that sun-heated car hood.
The way her pale skin flushed under Leo’s mouth. The fullness of her breasts, the way her thighs trembled, her moans carried on the breeze.
Fuck… even now I was getting hard just thinking about it. And it didn’t help that Poppy was literally sitting right beside my hospital bed.
“Andy, can you tell me exactly what transpired between you and Ivy?” she asked, clearly frustrated, her eyes red from lack of sleep. “She won’t tell me a single thing. And she’s been so sad and quiet ever since that day.”
Fuck. What had I done?
“Did you really spy on her and Leo… doing it?” She lowered her voice, leaning in. “Because if that’s the case, then you’re a lot creepier than I thought.”
I glared at her, but the shame burned hot in my chest. “That’s not how it happened. It wasn’t intentional. I just wanted to protect her. But I fear she’s too far gone.”
She gave me a “duh” expression, clearly seeing through my bullshit. “Yeah, right. You wanted to protect her by being a peeping Tom. What the actual heck, Andy. That’s disgusting. You saw her naked. Of course she’s mortified.”
I balled my fingers into a fist under the thin hospital sheet. God, the images flooded back again. My dick hardened impossibly beneath the gown.
Shame flooded my veins like ice water.
What was wrong with me? Here I was, in a hospital bed after nearly dying, and my body was reacting to memories of Ivy like some perverted asshole.
“She doesn’t want to see you,” Poppy continued. “You can’t exactly blame her.”
“It’s Leo’s fault. I’m sure he’s poisoning her mind against me—”
“Can you stop blaming Leo for everything? You caused this!” she snapped. “Leo isn’t even in town at the moment. He traveled. No one has seen him since that day. Not even Ivy. He has a match somewhere else.”
“Leo is going to hurt Ivy if she doesn’t stop now,” I insisted. “She’s not thinking straight.”
Poppy sprang up immediately. “Will you shut up? Just leave her alone. She’s an adult. Stop pestering her and making her cry. Don’t you think you’ve done enough at this point? Let her be. Even if she gets hurt, then she’ll know it’s on her. She’ll heal. She’ll be fine. Just stop.”
Before I could respond, the door opened and Maddie walked in, looking as beautiful as always in a simple dress.
But there was something off—something missing in her usual bright energy. She hurried forward and threw herself into my arms, burying her face in my chest.
“Hi, baby!” Her voice was muffled against me.
Poppy just turned on her heel and left without another word, the door clicking shut behind her.
“Is everything okay?” Maddie asked, looking up at me with concern. “Poppy looked angry just now.”
I managed a weak smile, brushing a strand of hair from her face. “It’s nothing. You know how my sister can be. She likes to start fights with me.”
Maddie laughed softly, then tried adjusting her position as she sat on the edge of the bed. Her body brushed against my still-hard cock through the thin hospital gown.
I released a harsh breath through my nose, trying to will it down, but it was too late.
She paused. Her eyes went wide, then a slow, surprised smile broke out on her face. “Andy… are you?” She covered her mouth, giggling. “You’re hard right now? Did you miss me that much?”
I managed a small smile. “Of course. I missed you a lot.” I lied.
Truth was, I hadn't thought about Maddie since she left. Not once. My thoughts had been occupied by Ivy and the ongoing issue we had.
The room suddenly felt too small. Too warm. Maddie’s eyes sparkled with a mix of surprise and excitement. She glanced at the door, then back at me, biting her lip.
Before I could say anything, she stood up and walked to the door, locking it with a soft click.
“Maddie, wait—” I started, but she was already coming back, a mischievous glint in her eyes.
“Shh. We haven't had sex in a long time, Andy,” she whispered, climbing onto the bed carefully, straddling my lap. “Maybe it’s time we also tried something different. You’re hurt, but… I can be gentle. I want to make you feel good.”
I tried to stop her, my uninjured hand pressing against her hip. “Maddie, not here. Not now. I’m still recovering and—”
She shushed me with a finger to my lips, slowly reaching under her dress and sliding her panties to the side. She pushed them aside and hiked her dress up, positioning herself over me. “Shh, baby. I’m excited for this. Let me take care of you.”
I resisted a little more, giving excuses about the nurses, the pain, the risk of someone hearing. But when she reached down, guiding my hard cock to her entrance and slowly sank down onto me, all protests died in my throat.
She was warm, tight, and wet. She moaned softly as she took me in, her body adjusting to mine.
Maddie and I were each other's firsts. She'd never been with any other guy. And I'd never been with any other girl. In all our years of being intimate, this was the boldest and most daring thing we've ever done.
We usually played it safe and decent. But this was something I could get used to.
“Oh God, Andy,” she breathed, starting to move. Her hips rolled in a slow, erotic rhythm. She was riding me—right there in the hospital bed, dress bunched around her waist.
I pulled down one strap of her dress with my good hand, exposing one breast. I cupped it, squeezing gently as she rode me harder.
She laughed breathlessly, head thrown back. “You claimed you weren’t interested before, but look at you now.”
Mentally, I kept comparing her to Ivy. Maddie’s breasts were perky and small, but I imagined Ivy’s softer, fuller ones bouncing as she rode me instead.
Maddie’s moans were sweet, but I heard Ivy’s breathy, shy ones from the lake in my head. The way Ivy had writhed on that car hood, legs shaking, coming on Leo’s tongue—it haunted me.
I thrust up weakly into Maddie, but my mind was elsewhere. On pale skin, on soft moans, on Ivy’s face as she came. Her flushed skin as Leo kept humping into her from behind.
I came hard at the thought of Ivy being the one on top of me, riding me, her virgin pussy clenching around my cock. The guilt hit immediately after, crashing over me like cold water.
Maddie collapsed against my chest, panting and satisfied. “That was amazing, baby. We should do more of that when you’re better.”
I held her, stroking her hair, but inside I felt hollow. Sad. Disgusted with myself.
Something was wrong with me. I was engaged to this wonderful woman who loved me, yet I had just used her body while fantasizing about another. About Ivy. Her own sister.
I was broken. And I didn’t know how to fix it.