Chapter 44: Ivy… I’m Sorry
Chapter 44: Ivy… I’m Sorry
Ivy
It was five days later when I was finally able to see Andy.
Maddie had been glued to his side since the day of the surgery, never letting anyone else come close or have a turn to be around him.
The doctors had warned against having more than two people in the room at the same time, but Maddie treated the rule like a suggestion she could ignore.
She slept in the uncomfortable chair by his bed, ate hospital food without complaint, and only left for short periods when Julia or Marcel forced her to.
She wasn’t at the hospital today because she had to attend an important event in Kansas.
She had been distraught about leaving Andy, crying in the hallway about traveling and staying away for five whole days.
But Julia and Poppy had convinced her that this was important—she needed the job and needed to impress the boss if she wanted to keep advancing in her career.
So finally, she left early this morning, taking the first flight out with a promise to return as quickly as possible. Her goodbye to Andy had been tearful, full of whispered “I love yous” and reluctant kisses.
My legs felt like jelly with each step I took forward toward Andy’s room. I didn’t know what to expect. I hadn’t seen him immediately after the surgery, but judging from how Poppy had run out crying and screaming and how Marcel had just slid to the floor with his head in his hands, I knew it was bad.
Leo had been angry, and he was a boxer. Those two were a lethal combination. Poppy noticed my hesitation and nudged me gently.
“Don’t be scared,” she whispered. “He’s recovering fast. He actually looks a lot better now. A whole lot. You’re lucky you didn’t see him right after the surgery.”
I exhaled shakily and slowly pushed the door open.
Andy was looking at his hand. That was the first thing I noticed.
He had his right hand raised in the morning light filtering through the window, examining it almost like he hadn’t seen it before. Or maybe there was something on it.
Then I noticed the thick bandage wrapped around his head, the mess that was his face—swollen, bruised, stitched in places. His left eye was still partially shut, and there were dark purple marks along his jaw and cheekbone.
“Oh my God,” I gasped, covering my mouth with both hands. But it was too late—he had heard me.
He sat up immediately, wincing at the movement, and looked in my direction. “Ivy?”
I rushed forward, half-running and full-on sobbing. “Andy! I’m so sorry.” I cried, throwing myself into his arms as gently as I could manage.
He winced and withdrew a little. I hated myself instantly for forgetting how injured he was. I pulled back immediately. “Sorry. Sorry. I’m so sorry.” I apologized, touching his face gently with trembling fingers. “How do you feel now? Does it hurt?”
The swelling around his eye looked like it had reduced a bit, but when he tried to smile, it still looked like it took tremendous effort. His voice was hoarse when he spoke. “I’m fine, Ivy. All thanks to you.”
I shook my head vigorously. “No. I didn’t do anything.”
“Maddie told me what happened,” he said quietly. “If you hadn’t used your body to shield mine, I probably would have been dead a long time ago. I guess I owe you my life.”
“No. You don’t,” I replied, wiping my tears. “You saved me once, remember? Consider it a favor returned. Besides, Leo would have never forgiven himself for that if I had just stood there and watched him do it.”
Andy laid back against the pillows, clearly not a fan of where the conversation was heading. “Leo.” He said the name calmly, but his jaw clenched. “You still care about him, don’t you?”
I nodded immediately. “Of course.” I said. “Andy, he never meant to hurt you. I know that for a fact. He was just angry. Because of what you said to him—”
“He hasn’t come to visit,” Andy cut me off. “He feels no remorse, Ivy. If anything, he feels anger. You stopped him from completing what he set out to do. He wanted to kill me.”
“Because he was angry, Andy. You angered him.” I defended, though the words felt heavy. “I’m not saying he was right. But I’m only saying you’re not innocent in all this either. You started this by saying all that to him. Why would you say that? What did you mean by that?”
He looked away, jaw clenching so hard I could see the muscle jump. “Nothing. That was nothing.”
I walked closer until I was sitting on the edge of his bed. “That was not nothing, Andy. If it got Leo so pissed off, then I want to know what it was. What did you mean?”
He looked away again, refusing to meet my eyes. “Nothing. I meant nothing.” He insisted, finally turning to look at me. “Stop thinking about that.”
I wanted to push further, but I stopped myself. It was clear he wasn’t going to say anything more. No matter how much I pressed.
“Do you need me to do anything for you?” I asked softly, changing the subject. “Do you need water or—”
“I saw the both of you. At the lake.” He said suddenly, his face hardening. “You and Leo.”
It felt as if the world stopped rotating on its axis. Everything froze. My breath caught in my throat.
Andy… was watching us? He saw Leo do all those things to me?
I gasped loudly and tried to pull away, but Andy’s hand held onto mine. “You were watching us?” I asked, horrified and deeply embarrassed. Heat flooded my face as memories rushed back—the hot car hood, Leo’s mouth on me, my moans echoing by the water.
He didn’t deny it. “He doesn’t like you, Ivy. Stop whatever it is you’re doing with him. He doesn’t deserve you—”
“And who does? You?” I blurted out, anger rising sharp and fast. “I can’t believe you’d spy on us like that? I feel violated, Andy!” Tears dropped from my eyes. “Why would you do that to me?”
“You don’t understand, Ivy. I never meant to hurt you. I just—”
“You just wanted what?!” My voice climbed higher. Anger, shock, and disgust overwhelmed me. “I feel exposed, Andy! I don’t want you looking at me! I feel disgusted! Why would you do that to me?!”
He tried reaching for me again, but I stepped further back. His face fell. “Ivy, please don’t be mad. Please listen to me—”
“No!” I screamed. “I’m not listening to you. I don’t care what you have to say! It’s still the same bullshit as always! ‘Don’t be with Leo. He’s using you. He doesn’t like you.’ I’ve heard enough, Andy!”
He looked hurt. He actually had the nerve to look hurt, like he was somehow the victim in all this. “Ivy… I’m sorry.”
The door opened and Poppy walked in, looking between us and immediately sensing the tension. “What’s going on? I heard yelling.”
“Why won’t you leave me alone? Why do you like to see me miserable and unhappy?” I asked him, voice breaking.
“No! That’s not true. I want you to be happy, Ivy. I just don’t want you to be with the wrong guy. Leo is the wrong guy for you. He doesn’t love you. He’s only using you. He told me himself. He just wants your virginity. He wants to be your first—”
“Stop!” I screamed. “Stop talking! Enough of this! Stop saying that word!”
“Ivy, calm down,” Poppy said slowly, stepping closer.
I ignored her, facing her brother. “Maybe I want to be used. Maybe I want to be fucked by him so badly that I don’t care what agenda he has in mind. Have you thought about that? Maybe I like the attention even if it’s all fake. Who are you to tell me otherwise? It’s my life. It’s my body. I don’t need your permission, Anderson!”
He looked broken, guilt and shame painting his bruised face ghostly white.
I wiped the tears from my face and grabbed my bag. “I’m glad you’re okay. I’m glad you’re awake.” I said, voice trembling. “But that doesn’t excuse what you did. It doesn’t erase the fact that you watched me in my most intimate and vulnerable moment, Andy—”
“What?” Poppy said, shocked, eyes widening. She turned to her brother. “Dude, are you out of your fucking mind?!”
“I would never do that to you, Andy. So it hurts that you’d actually do that to me. I feel utterly violated and very disgusted. I feel like my own body isn’t mine anymore. I never gave you the right nor permission to see me that way.”
He looked torn. “I’m so sorry, Ivy. I never meant to hurt you—”
“Yeah.” I chuckled bitterly. “You just meant to watch me naked.”
Poppy gasped. “Andy! What did you do?! What were you thinking?!”
“You know something, Andy?” I continued, throat tight with a sob. “With how I feel right now, there’s no difference between what you did and actual rape. It actually feels like you raped me ten times—”
His whole body went rigid. His face turned deathly white. “Don't say that.”
“It feels like the worst kind of violation. Like you forced yourself on me. It feels like you stole something from me. Something I can never get back.” I said, voice breaking completely. “I’ll never forgive you for this, Andy. Ever.”
I ran out of the room, tears blurring my vision. Poppy called after me, but I didn’t stop. The hallway stretched long and white, my footsteps echoing as I fled the hospital, heart shattered in new ways I hadn’t expected.
The lake day that had started with pleasure and promise had ended in blood and betrayal. And now, even the boy I had once loved felt like a stranger who had taken too much.
I didn’t know where to go or who to turn to. But one thing was clear: everything had changed. And there was no going back.