Chapter 40: Feels Good
Chapter 40: Feels Good
Andy
“Stop spinning lies,” I hissed, fists clenched so tight my nails dug into my palms. “Why the hell would I be turned on by you using Ivy to get to me?”
Leo’s grin widened, sharp and predatory, like a wolf that had finally cornered its prey. “Oh… so you weren’t imagining it was you with your head between her legs?” He taunted, voice low and mocking. “So you weren’t wishing you were the one who had her squirming, moaning, and begging for more?”
“Keep talking and I might just lose all composure and punch you in the fucking throat,” I threatened, stepping closer. The image he painted—my hands on Ivy, her soft moans for me—made bile rise in my throat even as unwanted heat stirred lower.
I hated him for putting it there. I hated myself more for the reaction.
“I do love a good fight,” he said, grin spreading wider. “You know I won’t back down. So go ahead. Throw the first punch and your Madison will be walking down the aisle to a man in a wheelchair. Trust me, I’ll break your fucking legs if you dare hit me.”
I laughed bitterly, the sound hollow even to my own ears. “Threats?”
He shrugged, casual as ever. “You know they’re not empty ones.”
I pointed a finger at him, closing the distance until we were nearly nose to nose. “Stop messing with Ivy. Leave her alone. I’m the one you have a problem with. Stop going after her to get to me.”
He laughed, the sound rich and dark. “She’s not your sister nor your lover. Why does it affect you this much? Why do you believe I’m using her to get to you? Admit it, Anderson—you’re harbouring feelings for Ivy and you don’t want to admit it to her or yourself.”
“What I feel for Ivy is not your concern,” I snapped. “You don’t know a thing about us.”
“Us?” He looked genuinely amused now, eyebrows raised. “You think there’s an ‘us’ with you and Ivy?”
“Shut up.”
“You’re a spineless weak bastard, Anderson,” he said slowly, each word dripping with contempt. “You can’t even be honest with yourself. Why are you with Madison if you truly want Ivy? Because I can bet my trust fund that you wouldn’t react this way if I’d actually gone after your fiancée.”
“You think Maddie would fall for your crap?” I shot back. “Think again. She’s not as gullible as Ivy.”
“Is that so?” He cocked an eyebrow, challenge gleaming in his eyes. “Wanna put it to the test?”
“Keep dreaming,” I said, but a treacherous part of me wondered— would Maddie fall? The thought made my stomach twist. “I’m not playing your games, Leo. And neither is Maddie. Grow up.”
“Say the word and it’s game on, Anderson,” he replied smoothly. “I’ll have your lovely fiancée on her back right here on this car with her legs wide, begging for more while I fuck her—”
“Don’t make me hit you, Leo,” I seethed, anger bursting through the surface like lava. “I’m trying hard to be the bigger person. Stay away from my fiancée. And stop playing with Ivy’s feelings. She doesn’t deserve that.” I turned to leave, shoulders rigid, every step heavy with the weight of my own hypocrisy.
“Did she deserve that?” Leo called after me, voice suddenly cold. “You know who I’m talking about.”
My foot paused mid-step, too scared to lift again. Of course. It always came back to her. If not, why else would he be doing all this? He’s doing this to get back at me.
Because of that night. Because of what I did.
“Yeah. I guess the rules changed when it was someone you actually cared about, Anderson,” he said, the earlier amusement completely gone from his tone.
I turned slowly. His face was stone-cold now, nothing like the grinning devil from moments ago. He looked every bit the man with a vendetta—eyes hard, jaw set, shoulders tense with years of suppressed rage.
“Stop living in the past, Leo,” I said as calmly as I could manage. “Else you’ll keep hurting people. Like Ivy. And eventually… Julia.”
“Don’t speak about my mother,” he hissed, stepping forward. “You’re not fit to say her name nor deserve her kindness.”
I sighed heavily, the weight of guilt pressing down like an anchor. “True. I don’t deserve it. I would never and could never ask for it. I know what I did. I’m content with the knowledge that you’ll never forget it.”
“You’re a criminal, Anderson,” he said without hesitation. “And you deserve to die.”
I took a deep breath, the words stinging but familiar. “I know.”
He stepped closer, voice dropping to a lethal whisper. “I want you to live with the knowledge that if I ever get a chance to kill you, I won’t think twice. I won’t hesitate. I will kill you.”
A chill ran down my spine.
I knew he meant every word. Leo had always carried that murderous glint when he looked at me—like a predator waiting for the perfect moment.
Everyone else pretended to forget that night, swept it under the rug for the sake of family peace. But Leo never did. He never pretended. And strangely, I was grateful for that honesty.
“Better not accept a drink from me, Anderson,” he added. “Best believe I’ll poison you if you do.”
“You’d risk it all just to get revenge for… that?” I asked, genuinely stunned by the depth of his hatred.
“You ruined her. You ruined me. You ruined my family,” he said, each word a dagger. “You don’t get to live happily with a wife and a stepmom while my family is practically nonexistent.”
“I never asked for your mom to marry my dad, Leo. I had no hand in that,” I protested. “It just happened.”
He laughed, but there was no humor in it—only bitterness. “Really? You had nothing to do with that? If you hadn’t done what you did that night!” His voice rose, cracking with raw emotion. “If you had been a good, fucking decent human being and not an animal—”
“Enough!” I raised my voice, cutting him off. “I know! I know what I did! I know it’s unforgivable! I’m not asking you to forgive me! I’m not asking you to forget it! I’m just asking you to stop playing with Ivy. She has no involvement in this. Leave her alone!”
He smiled, but it was cold. “That’s where you’re wrong. It has everything to do with Ivy. Especially if it triggers you this much.”
“Jesus Christ, Leo. Stop it! I’m practically begging you!” I lowered my voice, desperation creeping in. “I know you’ve gone all the way with her. But I’m pleading with you to end things with her now while she can still recover from it. Please. You can come after me. You can do anything to me. Just not to her.”
He shook his head, laughing softly. “Nah. I kind of like this path. Oddly feels like sliding a dagger straight through your evil heart. Feels good. Plus, I get to have Ivy. Win-win.”
“What is wrong with you? She’s fucking getting attached to you!” I said, voice cracking. “Do you not feel anything for her?! Why are you okay with using and toying with her emotions like this? You don’t even like her!”
“I don’t like her?” He laughed again, genuine this time. “Who says I can’t want her and still use her? Most especially, why do you think Ivy isn’t aware of my intentions? Look on the bright side, Anderson. I get the best of both worlds. Ivy is fucking hot.”
I stared at him in shock, the words sinking in like poison. “You’re really crazy.”
He shrugged, unrepentant. “I’d take that over being a criminal. You should be behind bars, Anderson.” His eyes darkened further. “And let me tell you something interesting…”
I just looked at him, dreading what came next.
“Ivy is actually still a virgin,” he whispered, smiling like he’d won the lottery. “Of course I’m going to take that. We just haven’t gotten to that part yet. But when we do, I’ll make sure you have a front-row view of my dick being the first ever to slide into sweet, shy Ivy.”
My vision tunneled, red flooding my sight. The thought of Leo taking something so precious from her—something she had guarded for so long—made something primal snap inside me.
“You’ll watch me fuck the girl you truly love,” he continued, voice dripping venom. “And then I’ll do it again. And again. And again—”
I lost all composure.
My fist connected with his jaw in a sickening crack. The force sent him stumbling back against the car, but he only laughed—blood trickling from his lip—as if the pain was nothing.
The fight was on. And for the first time in years, I didn’t care about the consequences.