Chapter 39: Pressuring Ivy
Chapter 39: Pressuring Ivy
Andy
Ivy was quite pale-skinned.
That was the first thing that struck me as the scene unfolded in front of me like some twisted private show I couldn’t look away from.
I guess I had never really taken a good, honest look at her before now—not like this, not when she was laid bare under the blazing sun on the hood of Leo’s car.
Her skin glowed almost ethereally against the black metal, flushed pink in places from arousal and the heat. Her body was soft, curvy in ways I had never allowed myself to notice, breasts full and tipped with rosy nipples that hardened under Leo’s mouth. Her thighs trembled, legs spread wide as he devoured her.
I would be lying if I said I didn’t mean to watch them. I had intentionally followed, slipping away from Maddie under the pretense of needing to find Ivy.
I told myself it was to make sure Leo wasn’t pressuring Ivy into something she didn’t want. Yes—pressuring. That was the story I clung to as I hid behind a thick cluster of reeds and a sturdy tree trunk, heart pounding.
She doesn’t want this. That much is clear, right?
Leo is using her to get to me. Ivy is just excited that someone—anyone—is finally interested in her. She’s not used to that. And that’s not me insulting her.
I’ve known Ivy for more than a decade. I know her dating life has been nonexistent. She’s never really dated anyone. Ever.
Quiet, always in the background while Maddie shone. And now, out of nowhere, Leo Teague is interested? Of course she thinks it’s genuine. That’s why this obscene scene is playing out right in front of me.
That bastard was thrusting against her—violently, possessively, his hips snapping forward as he humped her from behind like an animal.
She doesn’t deserve that. She’s too fragile, too innocent to be treated like a toy. Eventually, he’s going to break her. Just like he breaks everything he touches.
My knuckles turned white as I clenched my fists. I wanted nothing more than to storm over there and pummel him until his pretty face was unrecognizable. To drag Ivy away and tell her this was all a game.
Then, to make matters worse, Leo looked straight at me.
His eyes locked onto mine across the distance as he thrust harder, deliberately, putting on a show just for me. That sick grin spread across his face.
He knew I was watching. He was doing this on purpose—rubbing it in, claiming her to punish me. He licked her pebbled rosy-pink nipples, sucking hard while squeezing her breasts with brutal strength, all while staring me down.
Just to show me he could. To remind me of old debts. To collect in the most painful way possible.
How dare he? Ivy is… God, what am I even thinking? She’s not mine. She’s never been mine. Never will be. That’s absurd.
Me being here, hiding like a sick creep and watching them get intimate, is absurd. Me getting this furious that Ivy is finally exploring adult things is absurd. Me wanting to smash Leo’s face every time his hands roamed her naked body is absurd.
But what’s even more absurd—what makes me feel truly disgusted with myself—is the way my body is reacting.
Blood rushed downward, my cock stirring to life against my will as I watched Ivy’s nude form writhe on that hood. Her soft moans carried faintly on the breeze, her back arching, legs shaking.
My nails dug into the rough bark of the tree until they bled. I clenched my teeth so hard my jaw ached.
This shouldn’t be happening. I’m disgusted with myself for thinking of Ivy like this. She’s like my little sister. She and Poppy grew up together, always underfoot, always family. And it’s already bad enough that I forced that kiss on her last night.
I’m truly losing my mind. What the hell is wrong with me?
I should be with Maddie right now. I should be beside her, apologizing for being a jerk earlier when she begged me to join her in the water. I had brushed her off rudely, too consumed by jealousy to care. I need to make things right.
But just as I turned to leave, I saw them finishing. Leo helped Ivy fix her bikini, gentle in a way that twisted the knife deeper. She looked satisfied, glowing, almost like she was thanking him for the world.
I don’t know where the crazy impulse came from, but I waited behind the tree until she jogged away. Then I stepped out and walked straight toward Leo. He was still staring in the direction she had gone, a satisfied smirk on his face.
“Did you enjoy watching me give your little sister her first orgasm?” he chuckled, not even bothering to turn around fully.
Rage blinded me. I shoved him hard against the hood of the car. “You bastard!” I hissed. “So you were putting on a show back there! You’re sick!”
He laughed, turning to face me with that infuriating grin. “And you were hiding, watching eagerly as your ‘little sister’ got fucked and used. You’re the sick one here, Anderson.”
He straightened, stepping closer until we were nearly chest to chest. Every instinct screamed at me to throw the first punch—to make him bleed, to make him regret ever touching Ivy.
“That tiny, pretty pink pussy,” he continued, kissing his teeth like he was savoring the memory. “Ivy really doesn’t know what she’s been hiding between those legs.”
Rage flared hotter in my bones, white-hot and consuming.
Leo leaned in, mouth right beside my ear. “You watched me eat her out, Anderson. She was fucking delectable. I didn’t want to stop. Bet she tastes sweeter than Madison ever could.”
I shoved him again, barely restraining myself from swinging. The only thing stopping me was the thought of explaining this to Maddie and the family. “Don’t speak about my fiancée like that,” I warned through gritted teeth. “Keep Maddie out of your games.”
He laughed, folding his arms casually. “Fiancé of the year. Brother of the year. Yet you watched her writhe under me, heard her moan my name, watched her spread her legs for me. You saw every inch of her naked body without blinking.”
My throat went dry. Shame burned through me, but so did something darker—arousal I couldn’t deny, no matter how much I hated myself for it. Ivy's body is a huge turn-on.
Leo smirked, knowing he had won this round. “You respect and care for Ivy so much, yet you got hard at the sight of her pussy. That doesn’t add up, Anderson.”
The words hit like a gut punch. I wanted to deny it, to punch him, to run. But the truth lingered in the air between us.
I had watched. I had wanted. And now, everything was spiraling out of control.
Leo stepped back, still grinning. “Stay away from her, Anderson. She’s mine now. And next time, I won’t just let you watch.”
I hated Leo. I hated myself more.
But most of all, I hated how much I still wanted her.