Chapter 33: Collateral Damage
Chapter 33: Collateral Damage
Ivy
Andy was kissing me. This was real. Andy—my Andy, the boy I had secretly loved for what felt like forever—was really kissing me.
For one frozen moment, time suspended. His hands still gripped my arms tightly, almost bruising, but his lips moved against mine with desperate urgency.
He was trying to coax me into kissing him back, tilting his head, pressing deeper, as if sheer force could rewrite the past few days. My traitorous body responded with a faint vibration of excitement—the boy I had wanted all my life was finally touching me, finally seeing me.
But I didn’t kiss him back. He wasn’t Leo.
He didn’t light my entire body on fire the way Leo did. Leo’s kisses consumed me, turning my blood to molten lava and making my skin tingle with electric need.
Andy’s kiss felt… different. Familiar in a painful way, but lacking that all-encompassing heat.
Yes, I felt something—a nostalgic flutter in my chest, a confusing ache low in my belly. But it wasn’t an inferno. It wasn’t the wild, breathless passion that made me forget everything else. This felt forced. Wrong. Like a dream that had arrived too late and in the worst possible way.
“What is going on here?”
Andy froze instantly. His mouth tore away from mine, and he pulled back to stare at my face, eyes wide with sudden horror, as if he had only just realized what he had done—and to whom.
The golden boy looked shattered, regret crashing over his features like a wave.
“Ivy… I’m sorry,” he whispered, voice hoarse with shock. “What have I done?”
“What is this?” Marcel’s voice cut through the tension again, sharper this time as he descended the stairs. His footsteps were authoritative.
We both turned. Marcel stood midway down the staircase, one hand on the railing, his expression a mixture of disbelief and disapproval. The light cast long shadows across his face, making him look imposing.
I gasped, the sound breaking the heavy silence. Taking advantage of Andy’s momentary distraction, I wrenched my arms free and shoved him backward with all the strength I could muster. He stumbled slightly. I bent down quickly, snatching my purse from the floor where it had fallen earlier, and sprinted past Marcel without meeting his eyes.
Marcel had just seen Andy kissing me.
Oh my God. What must he think of me now? He probably saw me as a slut—trying to get with two brothers at the same time, stirring up drama in his already complicated family. The thought made my stomach churn with shame.
Tears welled up instantly, blurring my vision as I rubbed my lips furiously with the back of my hand, trying to erase the lingering feel of Andy’s mouth.
I couldn’t look at Marcel. I just kept my head down, cheeks burning, and ran up the stairs two at a time. My heart pounded so hard I could hear it in my ears. Every step felt like an escape from a nightmare I had accidentally walked into.
I burst into my bedroom, slammed the door shut, and locked it with trembling fingers. Sliding down the wooden surface until I sat on the cool floor, I buried my head in my hands. Hot tears fell in fat, heavy rolls down my cheeks, soaking into Leo’s oversized hoodie.
Why had Andy done that? After months of ignoring me, treating me like background noise while chasing Maddie, why kiss me now? Jealousy? A moment of weakness? Or something more calculated?
Leo’s intensity had awakened something in me. Andy’s kiss had only stirred up old pain.
Less than ten minutes later, a soft knock sounded at the door. The handle twisted futilely.
“Ivy, open the door. Please,” Andy’s voice came through, muffled but pleading.
“Andy, go away!” I sobbed, my voice cracking. “Leave me alone.”
But he didn’t listen. The handle kept twisting, persistent and desperate. “Ivy, please. Open up. Let me explain.” His tone carried genuine remorse, regret thick in every word.
Tonight wasn’t about understanding Andy or making excuses for why he had never treated me like a priority.
Tonight, I wanted to stay angry.
He hadn’t respected me—as a person, as a woman. He had taken what he wanted in a moment of jealousy, ignoring my clear signals.
I touched my lips again absentmindedly, still feeling the ghost of his unwanted kiss. Who knew what Marcel thought now?
And Maddie… God, if Maddie ever found out, she would never believe it wasn’t mutual. Andy had forced it. That was the truth. But in her eyes, I would become the jealous little sister trying to steal her man.
Marcel might believe me if I explained. He was fair. But the damage was done. I had become the girl caught between two worlds, two men, and it made me feel dirty. Used. Confused.
Andy knocked again, louder this time. “Ivy, I know you can hear me. I know you’re in there. Please open the door.”
I didn’t answer. Instead, I clapped a hand over my mouth to stifle my sobs, crying like a fool into the darkness of my room. The tears came harder— for the years I had wasted pining after someone who only noticed me when I slipped away, for the excitement Leo had sparked that now felt tainted, for the mess I had somehow landed in the middle of.
“Ivy, please. I’m begging you.”
“And I’m begging you, Andy! Leave me alone! Get lost! I don’t want to see you!” I screamed back, my voice raw and broken.
Only then did he finally retreat. His footsteps faded down the hall with a quiet, defeated, “I’m sorry, Ivy.”
I don’t know how long I sat there in misery, knees drawn to my chest, the hardwood floor cold beneath me.
Eventually, I gathered enough strength to peel off my clothes and stepped into the bathroom. The hot water cascaded over me, but it didn’t wash away the confusion.
I scrubbed my lips gently, then harder, as if I could erase Andy’s kiss while preserving Leo’s marks on my neck. The hickeys were faint but visible under the bathroom light—small claims Leo had left on my skin. They made me smile through the tears for a brief second.
I crawled into bed with puffy eyes, the sheets cool against my overheated skin. Sleep came in fragments, haunted by dreams of golden hair and dark, intense eyes pulling me in opposite directions.
\~~~~
The next morning, I had already conditioned my mind to avoid Andy at all costs.
I planned to slip downstairs quietly, grab something quick for breakfast, and head straight to Poppy’s room to vent or distract myself with talk of Leo’s surprise date.
But as I walked past his bedroom door on the way to Poppy’s, it creaked open without warning. A strong hand shot out, grabbing my wrist and yanking me inside before I could react. The door slammed shut behind me.
“I’m sorry,” Andy said immediately, his eyes red-rimmed and exhausted. Then he pulled me into his arms, hugging me so tightly I could barely breathe.
I froze for a split second, the familiarity of his embrace stirring old feelings. But then the memory of last night crashed back—his forceful kiss, the way he had ignored my protests. I began pushing him back, shoving hard against his chest.
“Don’t touch me! I don’t want you anywhere near me!” I hissed, finally breaking free.
Andy staggered back a step, then hunched over, leaning his weight on his knees as he breathed heavily, like he had just run a marathon.
Only then did I really look at him. He looked disheveled—hair in wild disarray, dark bags under his usually bright eyes, worry etched deeply into that perfect face I had once adored. His shirt was wrinkled, as if he hadn’t slept either.
“Don’t ever touch me again, Andy,” I warned, my voice steady despite the tremor in my hands. I turned toward the door, ready to leave.
But before my fingers could fully grasp the handle, I felt him behind me again. His arms wrapped around my waist from behind, and his forehead dropped to rest against the back of my neck. His breath was warm, shaky.
“Forgive me, Ivy. I’m truly sorry.”
For a fleeting second, I almost let myself be silly. I almost believed I was important enough to him that he couldn’t bear losing whatever fragile connection we had. That his begging meant something real.
But Andy had a way of always putting me back in my place whenever I started feeling too significant.
“Please don’t tell Maddie,” he whispered, voice cracking. “I’m begging you. I thought you were Maddie. I’m sorry, Ivy.”
I went rigid in his arms, the air rushing out of my lungs. I thought you were Maddie. Of course. Even in his moment of jealousy, even when he was kissing me, I was still just a substitute. A shadow of my sister. The realization hollowed me out, leaving a painful void where fragile hope had briefly flickered.
I shoved him off again, harder this time, turning to face him with tears stinging my eyes. “You thought I was Maddie? That’s your excuse? After everything?”
Andy reached for me again, but I stepped back, pressing against the door. His face crumpled with regret, but it didn’t erase the sting. I could hear distant sounds from the kitchen downstairs, normal life continuing while mine fractured.
“I was angry, confused… seeing you with Leo made me lose it,” he tried to explain, running a hand through his messy hair. “You’ve always been there for me, Ivy. Last night, something snapped. But it was a mistake. A stupid, stupid mistake.”
“A mistake that involved forcing a kiss on me,” I shot back, voice trembling. “While Marcel watched. Do you have any idea how that makes me look?”
He winced. “I know. I’m an idiot. I talked to dad. Explained it was my fault. Just… please don’t tell Maddie. It would destroy her. Destroy us.”
The “us” hit hardest. He was still protecting his relationship with my sister. I was the collateral damage, the secret to be buried.
I laughed bitterly, though it came out more like a sob. “You know what, Andy? I won’t tell her. Not because you deserve it, but because I’m tired of being in the middle.”
His eyes searched mine, desperate. For a moment, I saw the old Andy. Last night’s kiss didn’t change the way I saw him. It only highlighted how lost he was.