Chapter 32: We Went Public

Chapter 32: We Went Public

Ivy

I stood on the sidewalk long after Leo’s taillights had disappeared around the corner, the warm night air brushing against my skin like a lingering caress.

My face was on fire, every inch of it burning with a mix of embarrassment, excitement, and something deeper I couldn’t quite name.

I couldn’t stop grinning—ear to ear, like a Cheshire Cat who had finally found the cream. No matter how hard I tried to compose myself, the smile kept breaking through.

Leo desired to have sex with me.

The thought sent a fresh wave of heat rushing through my body. Maybe there was truly hope for me after all.

I had never imagined a guy like Leo Teague would want me this badly. But he had proved it over and over again tonight. From the way he’d pinned me against the shower wall, to the hungry way his hands had explored my bare skin, to the shameless teasing in the car.

He was hellbent on winning me over, and part of me was starting to believe it was real.

Still, doubts crept in like shadows at the edge of a dream. There was a small part of me that remained confused about why he had chosen me.

What if this was all some sort of game? A bet between him and his friends on who could get into the naive girl’s pants the quickest?

The thought made my stomach twist. I’d seen enough movies and heard enough stories about guys like him. Rich. Famous in their circles. Bored. What if I was just entertainment?

I paused on the porch steps, fingers hovering near the door handle.

What if it was simply a way of messing with Andy? Leo had made his dislike for him crystal clear. Maybe getting with me was the ultimate jab. That would explain the teasing, the relentless pursuit, the way he seemed to enjoy pushing my boundaries.

But that didn’t quite add up either. If Leo wanted to hurt Andy, why not go after Maddie directly? She was the one Andy loved, the one he was supposed to marry. Going after the younger sister—the sister-in-law—felt like an inefficient kind of revenge. It didn’t make complete sense.

I shook my head, trying to dislodge the spiraling thoughts. Here I was, overanalyzing everything at one in the morning while the rest of the house slept.

The windows were dark, the porch light casting a soft, lonely glow on the wooden steps. Marcel and Julia had left the arena earlier, and I had told them I’d wait for Leo to finish his post-fight meetings. It had stretched into two or three long hours of waiting, but every second had been worth it.

I grabbed the door handle firmly.

Enough. I had decided to enjoy this while it lasted. If Leo was genuine, then I wanted nothing more than to be his—fully, completely. If this was just a game or a bet for him, then I would treat it as an experience.

Two could play, right? I’d have fun, soak up the attention and the kisses and the thrilling new sensations, and walk away when the time came.

He was an incredible kisser. The way his mouth moved against mine still made my lips tingle. And he had a way with words that made me feel seen, desired, beautiful.

Even the brief, shocking moment in the car when he’d pressed my hand against his hardness… my palm still remembered the heat, the impressive size and length. My hand hadn’t been able to wrap around it fully.

The memory sent an unfamiliar ache between my thighs. I was a virgin but that didn’t mean I was immune to curiosity.

It’s not like I had anything else to lose. Well, aside from my virginity—

“What’s taking you so long to walk in?”

The door was violently yanked open from the inside. Andy stood there, framed in the doorway, his golden hair disheveled and his expression thunderous.

His eyes raked over me, narrowing at the oversized hoodie I wore—Leo’s hoodie, which still carried the strong scent of his cologne.

I gasped at the suddenness of it all. “Andy…”

He grabbed my wrist and pulled me inside, shutting the door behind us with a firm click that echoed in the quiet house. I immediately wrenched my arm free and took several steps back, my heart hammering. “Don’t touch me.”

I didn’t miss the flash of surprise in his eyes at my defiance, the way his jaw tightened. He wasn’t used to this version of me—the one who pushed back instead of waiting patiently in the shadows.

“What was that out there?” he demanded, voice low but edged with anger.

“What was what?” I glared at him, fury rising hot and fast. He had ruined my night—first with the package nonsense for Maddie, now this ambush.

“So you’re dating Leo now?” His words came out like an accusation. “He announced it to the entire world that you’re his girlfriend. It’s all over the highlights already.”

I shrugged, trying to appear casual even as my pulse raced. “We went public. And so what?”

“And so what,” he repeated with a bitter laugh that didn’t reach his eyes. He stepped closer, towering over me. “It’s been three days, Ivy! Three days! Look at you—sneaking back home in his hoodie, kissing him out in public like that. Smiling like a lovesick fool on my porch.”

“What’s it to you?” I challenged, lifting my chin. “Why does it bother you so much? No one asked you to watch. Mind your fucking business and stay out of my life, Andy.”

I tried to walk past him toward the stairs, but he caught my arm again, fingers digging in just enough to make me wince. “Come back here. I’m still talking to you.”

“Andy, let go of me!” I yanked free, my voice rising. A flicker of fear mixed with my anger. I had never seen this side of him. It was frightening because I didn’t know what he was capable of when pushed.

“Why are you wearing his hoodie?” he pressed, leaning in. His eyes darkened as he inhaled. “Why do you smell like him? What did you and Leo do tonight? Did you give yourself to him, Ivy?”

“It’s none of your business!” I screamed, hoping the volume would wake someone—Poppy, Julia, anyone. “Leave me alone! You’re not my dad! You’re not my brother!”

“Keep your voice down,” he hissed, glancing nervously toward the staircase.

“Why?!” I shouted even louder. “Why should I keep quiet when you’re insulting me and harassing me over—”

He grabbed both my arms this time and pulled me toward him sharply. My purse slipped from my shoulder and thudded onto the floor. I tried to push him away with my free hand, but he caught it too, drawing me impossibly close until my body was pressed flush against his. The heat of him was familiar yet wrong—too close, too charged.

“Andy, stop it!” I struggled, panic rising. “What is wrong with you?!”

“Why did you kiss him?” His eyes were wild, pupils blown wide with something between rage and desperation. The scent of his cologne was mixed with the faint scent of Maddie's body mist.

I froze. I had never seen Andy this unhinged. My heart pounded so hard I could feel it in my throat.

“Answer me!”

I flinched at the command, but then anger overtook everything else. “Yes! I kissed him because I like him! I gave myself to him because I think he’s hot—”

The rest of my words dissolved as Andy’s mouth crashed down on mine.

It wasn’t gentle. It wasn’t romantic like Leo’s kisses. This was raw, possessive, born of jealousy and tension. His lips were firm and demanding.

For a split second, my body reacted on pure shock—stiffening, eyes wide open. This was Andy. The boy I had secretly loved for so long. The one whose indifference had broken me over and over.

But this wasn’t the fantasy I had imagined. There was no tenderness, no buildup of mutual want. Just his hands gripping my arms too tightly, his chest heaving against mine as he poured moments of complicated feelings into a single, stolen moment.

Tears pricked at the corners of my eyes. Confusion swirled with betrayal. Part of me—the old, lovesick part—wanted to melt into him, to finally have the attention I had craved.

But the newer part, the one awakened by Leo’s fire and honesty, recoiled. This felt wrong. Forced. Like he only wanted me now that someone else had claimed me.

Two boys. Two very different kinds of intensity. One who had ignored me until I slipped away, and one who chased me like I was the only thing that mattered.

Andy’s outburst tonight had complicated everything. The summer that was supposed to be simple had become a tangled web, and I was caught right in the center.