Chapter 27: What A Gentleman
Chapter 27: What A Gentleman
Ivy
I was ready before the clock even struck six.
I stood in front of the full-length mirror in my bedroom, turning slowly from side to side, the late-evening light catching the faint shimmer on my black leather pants.
The faded rock band tee hugged my frame just right, and the cropped leather jacket gave the whole look an edge I hoped screamed “concert-ready” without trying too hard. My hair was swept up into a high ponytail, a few loose strands framing my face, and my makeup was light—smoky eyes, glossed lips, just enough to look polished but not overdone.
Versatile. That was the word I kept repeating to myself. Something that could survive both a sweaty concert pit and a loud boxing arena.
I wanted tonight to be perfect. Or at least, I wanted to look perfect for Andy. And Leo.
Because disappointing Leo wasn’t an option.
My phone screen glowed with the time: 6:17 p.m. No knocks. No texts. No Andy.
The first flicker of anxiety twisted in my stomach like a live wire. I chewed on the edge of my thumbnail, a habit I thought I’d broken years ago, but old fears had a way of crawling back when you least wanted them.
“You think he bailed on me?” I asked, my voice smaller than I intended.
Poppy sat cross-legged in front of the vanity, carefully applying mascara to her right eye. She was already dressed for Leo’s match—ripped jeans, a sleek top, and effortless confidence. She paused mid-stroke, one eye dramatically bigger than the other thanks to the fresh coat.
“Maybe he already took Maddie and ditched me,” I added, the words tasting bitter on my tongue.
Poppy didn’t answer right away. Instead, she grabbed her phone with her free hand and dialed her brother’s number. The familiar ringtone echoed faintly from somewhere else in the house—down the hall, maybe the living room. She hung up without a word, then turned back to the mirror.
“That prick is still in the house,” she said flatly, returning to her mascara with practiced precision.
The confirmation should have relieved me. Instead, it made everything worse.
I sank onto the edge of the bed, the leather pants creaking softly. Minutes stretched into what felt like hours. The longer I sat there, the louder the doubts became.
Was my makeup too subtle? Did the ponytail look childish? Was the outfit trying too hard to be cool? I picked at a loose thread on my shirt, imagining Andy’s eyes glazing over the moment he saw me. Would he even notice the effort?
I was spiraling. Hard.
Before I could talk myself into tearing apart my closet for a third wardrobe change, a single knock sounded at the door. It swung open without waiting for an answer.
Andy stepped inside.
He looked good—too good. Dark jeans, a dark red shirt with the sleeves rolled up to his shoulders, exposing the lean muscle of his arms. His golden hair was styled in that effortlessly messy way that always made my chest ache. But his eyes didn’t find me. Not at first. They went straight to Poppy.
“Why’d you call me?” he asked, voice casual, like I wasn’t even in the room.
Poppy didn’t bother turning around. “Nothing to say to your date tonight? What a gentleman.” Her voice dripped with sarcasm. “If I hadn’t called, you wouldn’t have remembered you’ve got some explaining to do?”
Only then did Andy’s gaze shift. It landed on me like an afterthought.
“Shit. Sorry, Ivy. I didn’t notice you there.”
The words hit like a blade between my ribs. I forced a smile, the kind that hurt my cheeks.
“It’s okay,” I lied. “Are we still on for tonight?”
For the briefest second, confusion flickered across his face—there and gone so fast I almost believed I’d imagined it. He recovered quickly, tapping the side of his head with two fingers. “Oh yeah. Of course. The concert, right?”
Poppy turned fully now, arms crossed, watching the exchange like it was a mediocre soap opera.
I swallowed. “It’s past six. You said we’d leave at six.”
Andy scratched the back of his neck, that one golden lock falling over his eyebrow in the exact way that used to make me weak. “Yeah, that’s true. But I’m actually waiting on an important call right now.”
I frowned. “What important call?”
“Maddie—” he started.
The rest of the sentence blurred into static. My ears rang. Of course it was Maddie. It was always Maddie. My own sister. The woman who had claimed his heart long before I ever let myself hope.
I drifted somewhere outside my body while he kept talking. When I finally floated back down, Andy was gently tapping my shoulder.
“Ivy? Did you hear me?”
I blinked rapidly. “Huh? What did you say?”
Poppy beat him to it, her tone bored but sharp. “Maddie asked him to pick up a package for her. That’s why he’s wasting your time. It hasn’t arrived yet.”
The words carved themselves into my chest. A billion tiny fractures spider-webbed across my heart all at once.
I looked at Andy, but he wasn’t looking back. His eyes were glued to his phone screen, thumb scrolling impatiently, jaw tight with that familiar tension he got whenever Maddie needed something.
I wanted to cry. I wanted to scream. Most of all, I wanted to punch myself in the face for being so pathetic.
What kind of idiot begs for scraps of attention from her own sister’s fiancé?
Me, apparently. A big, delusional, hopeless idiot who kept handing out second, third, and fourth chances like they were free samples.
The clock on my nightstand read 6:58 p.m.
“When does the package arrive?” I asked, my voice steadier than I felt.
Andy didn’t even glance up. “It was supposed to be here already. Maybe they delivered it to the wrong address.”
Poppy snorted. “Obvi. Maddie’s an idiot. She probably put in the wrong address. Now you’re running around like a headless chicken for her.”
“She’s not an idiot,” Andy snapped, defensive fire flashing in his eyes. “People make mistakes all the time.”
I felt sick. The way he defended her so quickly, so fiercely—it was a reminder of where his loyalty truly lay. Not with the girl sitting in leather pants and a rock tee, waiting like a fool.
“What’s in it?” I forced myself to ask, swallowing the massive lump in my throat.
“Her makeup stuff, I think. Some skincare products too. She’s really into all that.” He said it so casually, like it was the most reasonable thing in the world. Like my feelings were the unreasonable ones here.
I wanted to laugh. A loud, ugly, broken sound that would make them both stare. Makeup and skincare? That was why he’d forgotten our date? Her glowy skin and perfect eyeliner mattered more than the girl who had spent forty minutes getting ready just to stand beside him for one night?
“So…” My voice cracked. I cleared it. “I guess you’ll wait for it to arrive before we go to the concert?”
He nodded without hesitation. “Yeah. I’ll pick it up myself and hold onto it for her. She was worried the neighborhood kids might mess with it. There’ve been complaints about stolen deliveries lately.” He looked at me then, expecting understanding. Expecting me to smile and nod like the supportive side character I apparently was.
Instead, I turned to Poppy.
“Hurry up, Pops. Leo’s going to be looking for me. I don’t want to disappoint him.”
The room went dead silent.