Chapter 26: Best Of Both Worlds
Chapter 26: Best Of Both Worlds
Ivy
“Ivy?” Leo’s voice rumbled through the phone, low and expectant. “Did you hear me?”
The question snapped me out of my daze like a crack of thunder. Palms sweaty, heart stuttering, I nodded vigorously even though he couldn’t see me. “Yes—yes, I heard you,” I stammered, the words tumbling out too fast.
I hadn’t actually processed half of what he’d said. My mind had been spinning in circles for the past ten minutes, juggling two completely different futures for the same night. But Leo didn’t wait for clarification. He never did.
“Perfect. See you at eight, my lady.”
The line went dead before I could say another word.
The moment his voice disappeared, the energy in the room shifted. Julia’s animated chatter about pride and excitement for tonight faded into silence, and just like that, it was only Poppy and me left in my bedroom. The late afternoon sunlight slanted through the half-open blinds, painting golden stripes across the rumpled sheets.
Poppy leaned against my dresser, arms crossed, one perfectly arched brow raised in that signature skeptical look she’d perfected over the years.
“So…” she drawled, tilting her head. “You’re picking Leo now?”
I blinked, still staring at the floor of my bedroom as if it might magically offer me a third option. “I never even agreed,” I protested, my voice higher than I intended. “I only wanted to tell him that I heard him. That’s it.”
Poppy let out a short, disbelieving laugh. “You’re not saying anything meaningful, Ivy. You’re supposed to have made up your mind already. You’ve only got a few hours left. And last I checked, you can’t be in two places at the same time.”
I groaned, dragging both hands down my face. The reality of the situation crashed over me again, heavier this time.
“I can’t, Poppy,” I whispered, the words laced with genuine panic. “What am I supposed to do? Andy expects me to be ready by six for the concert. Leo expects me front row at his boxing match, cheering like my life depends on it. How am I supposed to split myself in two just to keep both of them happy? I can’t ghost Leo—it's not fair and he’d lose his mind. And I sure as hell can’t disappoint Andy. Not after everything…”
My voice trailed off. I didn’t need to finish the sentence. Poppy knew exactly what “everything” meant.
She pushed off the dresser and paced a few steps, her expression already sliding into bored exasperation. This wasn’t the first time we’d had some version of this conversation recently.
“Girl, pick a side,” she said bluntly. “You can’t be here and there and everywhere. Which one is more important to you? Choose that one and stick with it. Otherwise, this summer is really gonna burn, Ivy. You can’t please both of them. Not tonight.”
I opened my mouth to argue, but nothing came out. She was right, and we both knew it. My silence stretched between us like a guilty confession.
Poppy’s eyes narrowed, studying me. Then her lips twisted into a wicked little smirk, the kind that usually preceded trouble.
“Well… technically,” she added, voice dripping with mischief, “you can’t please both unless it’s a threesome.”
The word hit the air like a grenade.
I wrinkled my nose instantly, cheeks flooding with heat. “Ew, Poppy! That’s disgusting.”
I'd never had sex before. And the reason for that was embarrassing. But that was a story for another day.
Even as I said it, my traitorous brain had already conjured up a vivid, completely inappropriate flash of images—strong hands, tangled limbs, heated glances—and my face burned an even deeper shade of crimson. I buried it in my hands, mortified.
Poppy burst out laughing, the sound bright and unapologetic as she collapsed onto the bed beside me. “Girl, please. Be real for once in your life.” She nudged my shoulder with hers. “You can’t be at Andy’s concert and at Leo’s match when both things start at basically the same time. Who are you even gonna go to first? Hmm?”
I bit down hard on my lower lip, mind racing through logistics, excuses, and worst-case scenarios. The concert venue was downtown, traffic would be insane. The boxing arena was probably on the other side of the city. Timing was already razor-thin.
“Andy,” I said finally, the decision slipping out before I could second-guess it. “I’ll stay with Andy for a little while at the concert, then I’ll slip out early and race over to make it on time for Leo’s match. That could work, right?”
Poppy shook her head slowly, her expression a mixture of amusement and pity.
“You’re still picking and putting my jerk brother first,” she huffed, rolling her eyes dramatically. “How the hell did he get to be loved like this? Makes no fucking sense to me. Andy’s so annoying. I can hardly even stand him most days.”
I couldn’t help the soft smile that tugged at my lips. “You love him too. Don’t pretend it’s just me.”
Poppy’s head snapped up immediately, eyes flashing with defensive fire. “Because he’s my brother!” she shot back, her tone sharper than necessary. “That’s the only reason. I wouldn’t even want to be around him if he wasn’t blood. So damn annoying.”
She folded her arms tightly across her chest, muttering under her breath about “overgrown man-children” and “ego the size of Texas.”
I watched her for a second, then threw an arm around her shoulders, pulling her into a half-hug. She resisted for half a heartbeat before melting against me, the tension easing just a little.
“Don’t worry,” I said gently, trying to sound more confident than I felt. “I’ll make it to Leo’s match. I’m not gonna miss that for the world. I’ve never been to a real boxing match in my entire life. Why would I give up my first experience—especially when it comes with front-row tickets? Please. I’m gonna be right there in front, cheering like a complete mad woman. You know I will.”
Poppy huffed again, but this time there was a reluctant smile playing at the corner of her mouth. “You’d better be there. Else Leo’s gonna get mad—”
Everything inside me stilled. There it was again.
“Leo’s gonna get mad.”
The phrase landed differently this time. Heavier. It echoed in my chest like a warning bell I’d been trying to ignore all summer.
Was that what this entire balancing act had become? Walking on eggshells so Leo wouldn’t lose his temper? So he wouldn’t spiral? So I wouldn’t have to deal with the version of him that scared me just a little?
The thought made my stomach twist.
I pushed it down—deep, deep down—where I kept all the uncomfortable truths these days, and forced a bright smile instead.
“I’m gonna have so much fun tonight,” I announced, mostly to convince myself. Poppy was now practically leaning her full weight on me, her head resting against my shoulder. “Seriously. Best of both worlds. Concert vibes with Andy, then electric energy at the boxing match with Leo. What could possibly go wrong?”
Poppy let out a low, skeptical chuckle. “Yeah… right.”
I ignored the doubt in her voice and stared at the ceiling, letting myself imagine it: the pulsing bass of the concert, Andy’s excited grin when he saw me, the roar of the crowd at the stadium, Leo’s intense gaze finding mine from the ring. Two different kinds of adrenaline. Two different versions of myself I was trying to be for two different boys.
“I’m serious,” I insisted, squeezing her shoulder. “Tonight is going to be amazing. I can feel it.”
But even as the words left my mouth, a quiet voice in the back of my mind whispered the truth I refused to acknowledge out loud.
I had spoken far too soon.
The summer sun was beginning to dip lower, casting longer shadows across the room. My mind buzzed with the reminder… “Get ready for Andy– 5:15 PM.”
My chest tightened.
Two doors. Two nights. Two hearts. And only one of me.
I stood up slowly, walking over to the mirror. The girl staring back at me looked excited on the surface—flushed cheeks, bright eyes—but I could see the cracks if I looked close enough. The uncertainty. The guilt already blooming before anything had even gone wrong.
Poppy watched me from the bed, quiet now, her usual sarcasm tucked away for the moment.
“You know this is gonna blow up in your face, right?” she asked softly, no trace of mockery left in her voice.
I met her eyes in the reflection.
“I know,” I whispered. “But I don’t know how to stop it.”
She didn’t reply. She didn’t have to.
Outside, the city hummed with evening energy—cars honking, music drifting from distant speakers, the promise of a night that could either be unforgettable… or unforgettable for all the wrong reasons.
I took a deep breath, reached for my makeup bag, and tried to ignore the growing knot in my stomach.
Whatever happened tonight, one thing was certain:
I was about to find out exactly how thin the line between “best of both worlds” and total disaster really was.