Chapter 18: Why Me?
Chapter 18: Why Me?
Ivy
The sarcasm was so blatant it almost threw me off, my frown deepening as I tried to process whether he was genuinely pretending not to understand or if he was simply enjoying pushing my buttons.
“What do you mean we’re not dating?” he continued, placing a hand dramatically against his chest as though wounded by the very idea. “Ivy, I’m hurt.”
For a brief second, I just stared at him, caught somewhere between confusion and disbelief, because the way he said it—so casually, so convincingly—almost made it sound real, almost made it feel like I was the one missing something obvious.
But I wasn’t. I couldn’t be.
“We are not dating, Leo,” I said firmly, emphasizing each word as though repetition alone could force him to acknowledge the truth. “We’ve only got a month together to hang out and…” I gestured vaguely with one hand, frustration bleeding into the motion. “Do whatever the hell this is—”
“You know that actually sounds like casual fucking, right?” He said, cutting me off. “Are you with me for my body?”
I gasped. “What?! What are you even saying—”
He laughed. “You’re mine for a month, Ivy.”
The interruption came smoothly, his tone calm, almost lazy, as though he had simply corrected a minor detail rather than completely shifting the weight of the conversation.
I stilled.
There was something about the way he said it—something quiet, something certain—that made the words settle deeper than they should have, sending a strange, unwelcome ripple through my chest that I couldn’t quite explain.
I leaned forward instinctively, closing the already minimal distance between us, my face now dangerously close to his as I searched his expression for any sign that he understood the implications of what he had just said. “That still doesn’t mean we’re dating.”
He shrugged slightly, the movement subtle beneath me, his gaze unwavering. “Why not?”
The simplicity of his response only made my frustration grow, because it was as though he genuinely didn’t see the distinction, as though the line I was trying so hard to draw didn’t exist in his world.
“Besides,” he continued, his tone shifting into something more thoughtful, though the faint smirk remained, “how was I supposed to introduce you to my dad, hmm? Got any smart ideas?”
I opened my mouth to respond, but before I could form a coherent answer, he beat me to it.
“Was I supposed to say, ‘Oh hi, Dad, meet Mom’s new stepdaughter’s best friend who I have a huge crush on but she’s only got eyes for Mom’s new stepson who is now engaged to her sister, and she’s so pissed about it that she angrily agreed to go out with me for a month just to piss him off because she knows we’ve got bad blood and he seems to have a problem with us being together’?”
His voice shifted into an exaggerated, almost theatrical pitch as he spoke, the entire explanation delivered in one breathless stream that was so absurd, so specific, that it left me momentarily speechless.
“Would that have been better, my lady?” he finished, his expression expectant, as though he had just presented a perfectly reasonable alternative.
But I barely heard the last part.
Because my mind had latched onto something else entirely.
“You have a crush on me?”
The question slipped out before I could stop it, my voice quieter now, stripped of the earlier frustration and replaced with something closer to disbelief.
Of all the things he had just said—of all the chaos packed into that ridiculous explanation—that was the part that stuck.
That was the part that mattered.
“Why?”
The word felt inadequate, too small to carry the weight of what I was actually asking, but it was all I had in that moment, all I could manage as I stared down at him, waiting for an answer that made sense.
He looked at me like the answer was obvious. Like I had just asked why the sky was blue.
“You didn’t pick that up?” he asked, his tone genuinely surprised now, his brows drawing together slightly. “This whole time?”
I shook my head slowly, my confusion only deepening. “Why me?” I pressed, even though a part of me knew how ridiculous it sounded. “Everyone has a crush on Maddie.”
The name felt heavy on my tongue, carrying with it a weight I hadn’t fully unpacked, a comparison I had grown used to but never quite learned how to handle.
“They’re either blind or dumb or just stupid,” he said casually, as though dismissing the entire concept with a single sentence. “Now, back to the main point.”
Just like that, the moment shifted again.
“You’re with me for the month,” he repeated, his gaze locking onto mine with a quiet intensity that made it difficult to look away. “So it’s only fitting I introduce you as something closer to that—”
“Still not technically your girlfriend, Leo,” I cut in quickly, clinging to the distinction as though it was the only solid ground I had left. “What happens after the month is over? What do you tell your dad then if he asks about us?”
For the first time, he didn’t respond immediately.
He just watched me.
And then, slowly, a smile spread across his face—not the teasing, playful grin from before, but something more controlled. The kind of smile that suggested he already knew the answer to a question I was still trying to figure out.
“So you think I’m not charming enough to make you swoon after a month?” he asked, his tone light but his gaze anything but.
“You sound cocky,” I said, though the words lacked the bite they should have had.
“No,” he corrected smoothly, his voice dropping just enough to send a subtle shiver down my spine. “I’m confident.”
The certainty in his expression, in the way he held my gaze without hesitation, made something in my chest tighten, a mixture of anticipation and unease that I couldn’t quite separate.
“Just you wait, Ivy,” he added softly, his voice steady, unwavering. “You’ll be mine before the month is over.”
And the way he said it—like a promise rather than a possibility—made it impossible to tell whether I should be worried… or already losing.