Chapter 17: We’re Not Dating?

Chapter 17: We're Not Dating?

Ivy

“Leo!” I screeched, the sound ripping out of me before I could stop it. A sharp hiss followed right on its heels as the ice pack—still freezing—pressed flat against the bare strip of skin on my belly where my sweater had ridden up during the tumble.

The cold hit like a slap, stealing my breath and sending goosebumps racing across every inch of exposed flesh.

My stomach tightened as I jerked slightly against him, trying to pull away from the source of the cold, but his grip—firm without being painful this time—kept me exactly where I was, suspended in that strange, disorienting position where everything felt too close, too intense, and far too easy to misinterpret.

He, on the other hand, looked entirely unbothered.

In fact, he looked entertained.

Leo threw his head back against the floor, the sound of his laughter filling the room in a way that felt almost too loud for the space we were occupying, too carefree considering everything that had happened not too long ago, as though the earlier tension, the accidental violence, the strange shift in his demeanor had all been wiped clean and replaced with this version of him—the teasing, infuriating, dangerously charming version that seemed to exist solely to throw me off balance.

“That was funny,” he said between laughs, his chest rising and falling beneath me, the movement impossible to ignore given how close we were. “You were distracted by my looks, weren’t you?” His eyebrows lifted in an exaggerated wiggle, his grin widening as though he had just uncovered the most amusing secret in the world.

Heat rushed to my face so quickly it felt like I had been caught standing under a spotlight, exposed in a way I had not prepared for, and the worst part—the truly humiliating part—was that there was some truth buried in his accusation, something I could not entirely deny even if I wanted to.

The memory of that fleeting moment, the thought that had crossed my mind just seconds before the cold shock had interrupted it, lingered stubbornly, making it difficult to meet his gaze without feeling like he could see straight through me.

But still, I lied.

“That’s not true,” I said, my voice tighter than I intended, the words coming out just a little too quickly to sound convincing. “Keep telling yourself that.”

“Oh, really?” Leo’s smirk deepened, lazy and knowing, like he could see straight through every layer I tried to hide behind.

He was still flat on his back on the rug, hands now laced casually behind his head, elbows out like he had all the time in the world to torment me.

The position only made things worse—my knees straddling his hips, my palms braced on the floor on either side of his head, our faces inches apart.

I could smell the faint woodsy scent of his cologne mixed with the clean fragrance of his shirt, and the way his dark eyes caught the light like polished obsidian.

“So you weren’t fantasizing about kissing me and taking advantage of me, Miss Lenon?”

My breath caught.

The words sounded heavier than they should have been, not because of what they meant, but because of how close they came to something I had not said out loud, something that had existed only in the quiet, fleeting corner of my mind.

Something I had barely acknowledged before it had been ripped away from me by the shock of cold against my skin.

“Did not,” I shot back, but the denial felt weaker this time, my voice betraying me with its slight tremor, my face growing hotter under his unwavering gaze.

“So you weren’t wondering what my lips felt like?” he continued, relentless now, his tone almost thoughtful as though he was piecing together a puzzle he had already solved. “You weren’t almost leaning in to kiss me? Hmm?”

My heart stuttered violently against my ribs, the rhythm uneven and loud enough that I was convinced he could hear it, feel it, sense it in the way my body had gone rigid above his.

A flicker of panic crept in, because there was no logical explanation for how accurately he had described what had been nothing more than a passing thought, something so brief I had almost convinced myself it hadn’t even happened.

Had I said something?

Had I moved closer without realizing it?

Or was he just—

“Now you’re wondering if I’m psychic or just very perceptive.”

The words slipped from his lips with ease, cutting straight through my spiraling thoughts and leaving me momentarily stunned, my eyes widening slightly as I stared down at him, searching his expression for any sign that he was bluffing, that he was guessing, that this was all just a coincidence.

But there was no uncertainty there. Only amusement. Only confidence.

He shifted slightly beneath me, settling more comfortably against the floor as he laced his hands behind his head, his posture completely relaxed in a way that contrasted sharply with the tension coiling tightly in my chest. “You’re conflicted,” he added, his gaze never leaving mine, his voice softer now, almost observational. “And also very shy, Ivy.”

“I’m not shy,” I refuted immediately, the words coming out stronger this time, fueled by a sudden need to push back against whatever narrative he was constructing about me. “But you’re a liar. A very good one.”

One of his brows arched slowly, his expression shifting into something that resembled mild surprise, though the hint of a smile tugging at his lips suggested he was far from offended. “I am? Gee, thanks for the compliment. You just made my day.”

The ease with which he deflected the accusation made my frustration spike, because it was as though he genuinely didn’t see anything wrong with what he had done, as though lying—effortlessly, convincingly—was simply another tool in his arsenal, something he used without hesitation and without consequence.

“You think this is funny?” I asked, my voice lowering as I leaned slightly closer, the proximity between us shrinking even further, though I barely registered it in that moment. “You lied to your dad. You told him I’m your girlfriend. Why? Why would you do that? We’re not dating, Leo. You know that.”

“Wait…” His eyes widened in exaggerated shock, his lips parting as though I had just delivered the most unexpected news. “We’re not? We're not dating?”