Chapter 39

Lily’s POV

The day dragged on like a slow bleed, each hour a fresh cut I couldn’t bandage. My cheek still ached, the bruise hidden beneath the concealer I’d smeared on in the bathroom after my outburst.

I kept my hood up, my eyes down, dodging every corner where I might see Crew. My chest felt heavy, by the memory of his hurt face when I yelled at him to leave me alone. I had broken something this morning—something fragile and beautiful—and I couldn’t take it back.

June wasn’t talking to me either. She’d been my only real friend, my excuse to my dad, and when he’d called her mom last night, the lie had unraveled. I’d seen her in the hall after the first period, her arms crossed, her lips tight. “You could’ve told me,” she snapped when I tried to explain. “I looked like an idiot.” Then she’d walked away, her ponytail swinging as she walked away.

I didn’t blame her—I’d dragged her into my mess without asking—but it stung. She was my best friend, and now she is gone too. I’d lost everything in one stupid, perfect afternoon with Crew.

By seventh period, I was a wreck, my nerves frayed to threads. Psychology class. The one place I couldn’t avoid him.

We’d been paired as partners weeks ago, a random draw that’d felt like fate back then—his easy smile, his teasing voice making me blush every time we worked together. Now it was a trap,I couldn’t escape.

I slipped into the classroom late, hoping to sit on my desk, but Miss Smith’s voice cut through the hum. “Lily, good. Take your seat. We’re pairing up today.”

My stomach dropped. I scanned the room, and there he was—Crew, sitting near the window, his dark hair messy, his eyes locked on me the second I walked in. My breath hitched.

He looked… wrecked. Tired shadows under his eyes, his jaw tight, like he had something to say to me. The bruise on my cheek burned under his gaze, and I tugged my hood lower, as I walked over to him,sliding into my chair beside him.

The air between us was thick with everything we weren’t saying.

Miss Smith clapped her hands, her cheerful tone oblivious to the storm brewing at our table. “Alright, everyone, pair up with your partners. Today’s discussion is on trust and attachment—how they shape behavior. I want you to brainstorm examples from your own lives. Go!”

The room buzzed with chatter, but our corner stayed silent. I stared at my notebook, my pencil trembling in my hand, the blank page staring back at me. Crew shifted beside me, his knee brushing mine under the table, and I flinched, pulling away. I couldn’t look at him—couldn’t face the hurt I’d carved into him this morning.

“Lil,” he said finally, his voice low, rough, like it’d been scraped raw. “We need to talk.”

I shook my head, my throat tight. “No, we don’t. Just… write something down. Let’s get this over with.” My words were clipped, cold, but inside I was breaking. His nearness—the warmth of him, the faint scent of his cologne—stirred up yesterday, that kiss, that fleeting taste of freedom. It hurt to be this close and know I couldn’t have it.

He leaned closer, his breath brushing my ear, and my heart stuttered. “I’m not doing this,” he whispered, fierce and quiet. “Not after this morning. What’s going on with you? That bruise—don’t tell me it’s nothing.”

I clenched my jaw, my eyes tearing up. “It’s not your business, Crew. Please, just stop.” My voice was breaking, betraying me, and I hated it. I wanted to scream at him again, push him away harder, but the fight was draining out of me. He was too close, too real, and every word hit at the wall I’d built.

“It is my business,” he shot back, his tone edged with something desperate. “You think I can just sit here and pretend I didn’t see it? That I didn’t hear you scream at me like I’m some stranger? Yesterday, you—” He stopped, his voice low, and I risked a glance at him.

His eyes were dark, stormy, pinned on me like I was the only thing in the room. “Yesterday meant something, Lily. To me. To you too, I thought. What changed?”

Everything. My dad’s threats, my mom’s blood, the necklace he pinned on me—they’d changed everything. I swallowed hard, my fingers twisting the pencil until it nearly snapped. “It doesn’t matter,” I said, barely above a whisper. “It’s done. We’re done. Just leave it.”

He laughed, a bitter, low sound that made my chest ache.

“Done? You think I can just switch it off like that? I saw you get hit last night, Lil. On your porch. I was there. And now you’re bruised, and you’re shutting me out, and I—” He raised a hand through his hair, his voice dropping. “I’m going crazy here. I care about you. More than I should, maybe, but I do.”

My breath caught, a sob clawing up my throat. He’d seen it. He knew. The shame burned hot, mixing with the longing I couldn’t kill. I wanted to tell him—spill it all, let him hold me like he had yesterday, make it better. But I couldn’t. My mom’s face flashed in my mind, crumpled and bleeding, her cries echoing. If I let Crew in, she’d pay for it. I’d promised my dad—promised with that necklace—and I couldn’t break it.

“Crew,” I said, my voice shaking as I forced myself to meet his eyes. “You don’t get it. You can’t fix this. I need you to stop. Please.” Tears welled up, and I tried to shovel them back, but one slipped free, trailing down my cheek. His hand twitched, like he wanted to wipe it away, and the tenderness in that almost broke me.

“I don’t want to stop,” he said, softer now, his gaze locked on mine. “I don’t know what’s happening, but I’m not walking away from you. Not after yesterday. You’re scared—I see it. But you don’t have to be scared of me.”

I shook my head, my heart breaking. “It’s not you I’m scared of,” I whispered, the truth slipping out before I could stop it. His eyes widened, searching mine, and for a moment, I thought he’d push harder, demand answers.

But then Miss Smith’s voice cut through, calling time, and the spell broke.

I turned away, scribbling nonsense in my notebook, my hands trembling. Crew stayed silent, but I could feel him—his heat, his presence, his unspoken questions pressing against me.

When the bell rang, I bolted, grabbing my bag and fleeing to my dorm before he could say more. My heart pounded, a frantic rhythm of loss and love, because that’s what it was—love, sharp and impossible, blooming in the wreckage of my life.

I’d pushed him away again, but this time it felt different. He wasn’t giving up, and part of me—buried deep, defiant—didn’t want him to.

as I ran down the hall, tears blurring my vision, I wondered how long I could keep running before it pulled me back to him.