Chapter 38

Crew’s POV

The words hit me like a punch to the chest, sharp and sudden, knocking the air out of me. “Leave me alone!” Lily’s voice cracked through the morning chaos of the school courtyard, loud and raw, slicing right into me.

I stood there, frozen, my hand still half-raised from reaching for her, my brain scrambling to catch up. Her eyes—those soft, warm brown eyes I’d drowned in yesterday—were wild now, and furious, locked on me like I was the enemy. The bruise on her cheek, the split lip—they stared back at me too, ugly marks I couldn’t unsee.

And then she was gone, shoving through the crowd, leaving me rooted to the pavement with her words ringing in my ears.

I didn’t move until Luke and Marcus came and dragged me away.

My chest felt tight, like someone had wrapped a fist around my heart and squeezed. What the hell just happened?

Yesterday, she’d been laughing, her lips soft against mine, her hand warm in my grasp. She’d looked at me like I was something special, like I mattered. And now? Now she’d screamed at me like I was poison, like I’d burned her. “Get away from me!”

The memory of it stung, a lash across my skin, and I flinched, my hand dropping to my side.

I replayed it, over and over.

I’d seen her coming off the car, her hood up, her steps quick—like she was hiding. I’d called her name, jogged to catch up, because I’d been worried.

I ended up sending her a message —You okay?—which went unanswered, and then I saw her face. The bruise. The cut on her lip.

My stomach had dropped, a sick lurch of dread, and I’d needed to know she was alright. But she wasn’t. She’d flinched from me, yelled at me, and the hurt in her voice—it wasn’t just anger.

It was something deeper, something broken.

I walked slowly in between Luke and Marcus as they both looked confused but they said nothing. I stopped suddenly as I looked at them both.

“You guys go on. I'll catch you up later.”

They looked at each other before Marcus spoke. “You sure dude?”

“Yeah.” I nod slowly. “Okay.” They said as they both left.

My head buzzed, a storm of confusion and ache I couldn’t quiet.

She’d been fine yesterday—better than fine. Perfect. We’d spent hours together, her laughter lighting up every corner of my world.

That kiss—God, that kiss—had felt like a beginning, like a promise. Her first, she’d said, blushing, and I’d felt this stupid, overwhelming pride that it was me she’d chosen.

I’d held her hand, teased her about stealing my fries, watched her glow in the outfit she’d been so nervous to wear. She’d been free, alive, and I’d thought—I’d hoped—it was because of me.

But now? Now it felt like I’d dreamed it. The Lily who’d screamed at me wasn’t the same girl. This Lily was a stranger, her face bruised, her voice hooked with something I couldn’t name. Fear? Pain? Both?

I clenched my fists, my nails biting into my palms, trying to ground myself. The bruise—I couldn’t shake it. Has someone hit her? Her dad? I’d seen it last night, that blur of movement on her porch, the way she’d stumbled. I’d told myself I’d imagined it, that the shadows had tricked me just as Anthony had said.But now, seeing her, I knew. I fucking knew. And it made me sick.

My chest burned, a slow, simmering rage mixing with the hurt. If her dad had done that—if he’d laid a hand on her—I’d kill him. I didn’t care who he was, didn’t care what it cost me. She didn’t deserve that. No one did, but especially not her.

She was soft, bright, the kind of person who made the world better just by being in it. And someone had hurt her. Someone had taken that light and crushed it, and she was pushing me away because of it.

I stopped in the hallway, leaning against a locker, my breath coming fast. Why me? Why was she shutting me out? I’d seen the tears in her eyes when she yelled, the way her voice broke on “I mean it!” It wasn’t just anger—she was scared. Scared of me? No, that didn’t fit.

She trusted me yesterday, told me her secret, leaned into me, let me kiss her like it was the most natural thing in the world. This wasn’t about me. It was about something bigger, something choking her, and I was caught in the crossfire.

My throat tightened, a lump I couldn’t swallow. I wanted to chase her, grab her shoulders, make her tell me what was wrong. I wanted to fix it, to pull her back into that bubble we’d had yesterday where nothing could touch us.

But she’d told me to go, screamed it loud enough for the whole damn school to hear. And the look in her eyes—wild, desperate—it pinned me in place. She didn’t want me near her. She’d made that clear. But it didn’t stop the ache, didn’t stop the way my heart twisted every time I pictured her running away.

I slid down the locker, sitting on the floor, my head in my hands. The hallway emptied out, students staring at me as they entered classrooms, but I didn’t move. I couldn’t.

All I could see was her—smiling yesterday, broken today.

That bruise. That yell. It was like she’d ripped something out of me and taken it with her when she ran.

I liked her—more than liked her. I’d felt it yesterday, that pull, that certainty that she was different. Special. And now she was gone, pushing me away like I was nothing, and it hurt more than I knew it could.

Was it my fault? Had I pushed too hard, too fast? The kiss—maybe it’d been too much. She’d said it was her first, but what if she wasn’t ready? What if I scared her, made her feel trapped? I ran a hand through my hair, angry.

But no—that didn’t fit either. She’d kissed me back, smiled after, rested on me.

This wasn’t about the kiss. It was about that bruise, that fear, that shadow I’d seen on her porch. Was her dad. It had to be. He’d done this—hurt her, scared her—and now she was shoving me away to protect herself.

I let out a shaky breath, my eyes stinging. I wasn’t mad at her—not really. I was mad at him, at whatever he’d done to turn her into this. But the hurt? That was all hers. She’d cut me open, left me bleeding in front of everyone, and I didn’t know how to stop it.

I wanted her back—the real her, the one who’d laughed with me, trusted me. But she was gone, locked behind that wall she’s locked in, and I didn’t know how to reach her.

The bell rang, sharp and jarring, pulling me out of my head. I stood, my legs shaky, my chest panting. I’d see her again—class, the halls, somewhere.

But what then? She’d told me to stay away, and maybe I had to. Maybe she needed space, time, something I couldn’t give her yet.

But letting her go felt like losing a piece of myself, and I wasn’t ready for that. Not after yesterday. Not after her.

I walked to class, her voice echoing in my skull, her face—bruised and beautiful—burned into my memory. She’d broken my heart out there, and I didn’t even know why. But I’d wait. I’d watch.

And if she ever let me back in, I’d be there. Because Lily wasn’t just a game to me anymore. She was everything. And I wasn’t giving up on her—not yet.