Chapter 143

Aiden

Christmas day felt like static—white noise filling every corner of the apartment, pressing in on me until even breathing sounded wrong. There was wrapping paper still on the counter from the team’s gift exchange, a leftover mug of cocoa gone cold, and my phone face down beside it like the damn thing could bite me.

I’d read his message so many times I could see it burned behind my eyelids.

What we had is dead. Just as I am dead.

I didn’t even know what that meant. The words were jagged—raw in a way Noah never was when he was lying. If he’d wanted to hurt me, he could’ve done it easier. He could’ve said, I’m with her now, or I’m happy. But dead?

Why the hell would he say that if he was with the woman he loved, living the life he wanted?

I’d tried to rationalize it at first—he was angry, dramatic, cornered. But every time I looked at the message, I felt something split wider inside me.

He’d never sounded so final.

I’d thought I knew pain. Turns out, there are whole new kinds waiting once you run out of denial.

I’d walked around the house for hours after reading it. Pacing. Sitting. Standing. Drinking water like that would fill the hole in my chest. Somewhere around mid-day, I found myself pulling out my laptop, opening transfer portals, half-considering what it would mean to just... disappear.

Walk away before someone forced me to.

If I quit the Wolves, maybe they wouldn’t dig too deep. Maybe I could claim burnout, personal issues, a family emergency. If I left voluntarily, there’d be no hearings, no disciplinary board, no chance of the wrong text or photo falling into the wrong hands. No whispers about coercion or misconduct or “inappropriate relations.”

It was the coward’s move, but for a second it felt like mercy.

Maybe if I got out fast enough, I could still control the story. Free Noah from having to cover for me as well if that was part of what he was trying to do.

I could find another program, maybe across the country—some mid-tier team desperate enough to take a chance on damaged goods. Some place where his name wouldn’t echo down every hallway, where I wouldn’t see his number burned into my locker.

No Noah in the cafeteria. No Noah on the field. No Noah in my goddamn head.

Except there was no such place.

Because Noah wasn’t a person I could outrun; he was a heartbeat I couldn’t shut off.

Even if I left tomorrow, he’d still be there every time I closed my eyes. Every word, every touch, every look that had undone me from the inside out—those things don’t vanish when you pack a bag. They haunt you.

I dropped onto the couch, palms over my face. The clock on the microwave blinked 15:47 PM. Outside, snow was falling lazy and soft—too quiet for a day that had already torn something vital out of me.

I turned the phone over again. My thumb hovered over the message like touching it might bring him back.

The phone buzzed, sharp against the silence. I flinched.

Micah: Just checking on you, Sir.

For a moment I just stared at it. I hadn’t expected anyone—not today. Micah had always known when to reach out, though. The timing was uncanny, like he could still read my headspace even from a distance.

I almost didn’t reply. What the hell was I supposed to say? Hey, yeah, Merry Christmas, I’m losing my mind over the boy I replaced you with….

But the blue bubble blinked again.

Micah: You don’t have to answer if you’d rather be alone. Just wanted you to know I’m around.

Something inside me cracked. I typed before I could overthink it.

Aiden: I’m fine.

A lie.

Micah: That bad, huh?

I let out a humorless breath, leaning my head back against the couch.

Aiden: Don’t play smart with me, boy.

Micah: Meee? I just know your plain ‘fine’ all too well, Sir.

That Sir hit harder than I expected. Not in the way it used to—not the quiet pull of obedience—but in the way it sounded like someone still believed I deserved respect, even when I couldn’t stand myself.

He waited. Then:

Micah: Let me buy you a coffee. Nothing serious. Just two people catching up.

I stared at the blinking cursor for a long time. My reflection in the phone looked like someone halfway through breaking. I didn’t want to see anyone. I didn’t want to talk. But maybe that was the point.

Maybe I needed to stop bleeding in silence.

Aiden: Where?

Micah: That little café off 4th. The one with the red awning.

I hesitated after typing the word Okay, thumb hovering over Send.

Then I hit it.

Because sitting here drowning in what-ifs wasn’t going to change a damn thing. Maybe coffee wouldn’t either. But at least it meant moving. Breathing. Doing something other than staring at ghosts.

I shoved my coat on, grabbed my keys, and stepped into the cold, the words What we had is dead still burning behind my ribs like a brand I couldn’t erase.

Micah was already there when I walked in, two coffees on the table, steam curling between us. He looked up like he’d been waiting a lifetime and smirked.

“You actually came,” he said. “I wasn’t sure you would agree to hear me out.”

“You said coffee,” I told him. “Not confessions.”

“Oh, I brought both.” He pushed one cup toward me. “Still take it black, right?”

I sat. “You remember.”

He smiled, small but deliberate. “I remember everything, Sir. Especially the parts you’d rather I forgot.”

“Let’s get to the point, Micah. What are we doing here?”

He leaned back, studying me. “We’re catching up. You’re pretending you’re fine.”

“It’s been two years, Micah,” I said. “What do you really want?”

“You,” he said without hesitation.

“Try again.”

He held my stare, and for a second, all the easy charm in him went still. “I want to stay. I want to be by your side again. I—I love you.”