Chapter 142
Noah
Lexie stared at the steam rising from her mug like she was reading memories in it. “When I was little, it was… constant. Tutors, lessons, interviews. There were rules for how to smile, how to sit, what to wear, what not to want. Reporters would come to the house and Dad would tell me to stand a certain way and answer a certain way, and I’d do it, because making him proud felt like oxygen. But I was never… enough. It was always ‘Lexie, eyes up,’ ‘Lexie, shoulders back,’ ‘Lexie, we don’t say things like that.’”
Holy shit… Just when I thought my childhood sucked…
My chest tightened. “That’s a lot to put on a kid.”
“I know. And when I hit twelve, thirteen, I realized I could either be perfect or be seen as a problem. So I tried perfect. Straight A’s. Violin. Community service. Cheer. Smile until my face hurt.” She paused. “And then one day I just… snapped. I cut off all my hair with my mom’s sewing scissors. Like—boy short. It was the only thing I could control.”
I tried to picture her like that—the ‘perfect princess’ with a defiant crop. “What did he do?”
“He didn’t yell,” she said, and that seemed to bother her most. “He called a stylist. Told them to ‘fix it.’ Told me mistakes happen, but we learn. And then he doubled my calendar.”
I frowned. “So you pushed harder.”
“Yeah.” She traced the rim of her mug. “I started counting calories like they were sins. Shrank myself until clothes hung off me and the house staff whispered, and my mom began to freak out. Dad called doctors. Nutritionists. I got better enough to smile at the next gala, so everyone decided I was cured.”
“But you weren’t.”
She shook her head. “I wasn’t. I was lonely. The only people I saw were adults who wanted something or kids who wanted to be seen with me. So I ran. Literally. I climbed out my window at sixteen and took the bus to Denver with two hundred dollars and my cousin’s ID.”
My eyes went wide. “You? Little Miss Trouble?”
“Don’t,” she said, but she was smiling now—sad and real. “I slept at a friend’s for a week. Her parents thought I was ‘rebellious but spirited.’ It felt like breathing. We went to a Halloween party and I drank cheap vodka that tasted like paint thinner and laughed at nothing. It was the first time I’d ever been in a room where nobody cared who my father was.”
“How did it end?”
“He found me.” Her fingers tightened around the mug. “He always does. He showed up at the door with that fake smile and a driver and told me I’d had my fun. He didn’t yell in front of them. He waited until we were in the car and said, real quiet, ‘You’ll pay for this, Alexis.’”
My stomach dropped. “Did he…?”
She shook her head. “He didn’t hit me, if that’s what you mean. Not then.” She looked down at her drink. “He doesn’t have to. He scares people in other ways, controlling everything until you can’t even breathe without his permission.”
She exhaled shakily. “I tried to get away again later. Different way this time. I started seeing an older guy. He said he loved me, but he really didn’t. He just wanted control, same as my dad. He told me what to wear, who to text, when to eat… Then he became possessive and really scary. I thought it was love for a while, but it wasn’t. It was just another cage. Dad found out when some pictures almost got leaked. I got very depressed, started to take the wrong things too…”
I felt heat crawl up my neck. “Lexie…”
“He buried the story,” she said, eyes fixed on the window now. “Then he buried me.” She laughed once, sharp. “Not literally. I mean, he sent me to a ‘retreat center’ in the country. Big house. White walls. Gardens. Soft music, soft voices. ‘A place to heal,’ the brochure said. There were locks on the doors. It was some psychiatric center.”
My hand found the table edge. “How long?”
“Long enough to forget what day it was,” she said. “They called it treatment. Maybe some of it was. I needed help; I won’t lie. But they also needed me quiet. Needed me thin and compliant and grateful. I saw my mom once a week. Dad came twice. Every time, he’d sit and fold his hands and say, ‘Are we ready to be done with drama, Alexis?’ and I’d nod and say ‘Yes, Daddy,’ like a good girl. Because if I said anything else, I was staying.”
She finally looked at me. There were tears in her eyes that she was trying very hard not to let fall. “I learned to be perfect there. Not because I wanted to be. Because I wanted to go home.”
I didn’t realize I’d reached across the table until my fingers were over hers. “I’m so sorry,” I said. It felt small compared to what she’d just handed me. “I thought… I thought you had this charmed life. I didn’t see…”
“You weren’t supposed to,” she whispered. “That’s the point.”
Outside, a float rolled by with kids dressed as nutcrackers tossing glitter. Inside, the diner went quiet except for the hiss of the espresso machine.
“After I got out,” she went on, voice steadier, “I did everything right. Straight back to straight-A Lexie. Cheer captain. Charity boards. Smiling for cameras. I told myself if I was perfect enough, I’d feel safe. I dated boys Dad approved of. I waved to photographers. I went to sleep early and told myself I liked being watched.”
“Did you?” I asked.
She shook her head. “I stopped feeling much of anything. Until you.”
I swallowed. “Lex…”
“You were the first real thing in years,” she said, the words tumbling out now. “You were messy and honest and on fire. When you looked at me, it was me, not the photo. When you laughed with me, it wasn’t for the camera. And when Dad approved—when he actually encouraged it—I thought maybe this was my one chance of happiness. Like if he loved you, he’d love who I was with you.”
I couldn’t breathe for a second. “I need to say this, because it’s true,” I said. “I care about you. I don’t want you hurt. I’m… I’m sorry I’ve been half a person with you.”
She squeezed my hand. “You’ve been more real than anyone else in my life,” she said, and I had to look away because guilt burned hot behind my eyes.
“Can I ask something?” I said. “If he’s like this—if he does all of this—why tell me now?”
She studied me like she was deciding whether to jump. “Because I trust you,” she said simply.. “I was going to leave. Before you. I had a plan. A shitty one—cash, a friend three states away, a burner phone. I would’ve been gone by graduation. I think he knew it. Then you happened. And for once, the thing I wanted and the thing he wanted matched. I thought that meant freedom for the both of us.” She blew out a shaky breath. “I’m not so sure anymore.”
We sat there a while, watching the parade through the glass, our hands still locked like we’d both finally grabbed onto something that didn’t move when the ground did.
Eventually she sniffed and laughed a little. “Okay, sad hour’s over. We have a carousel to ride twice because the first time I blinked and missed the horse I wanted.”
“You’re insufferable,” I said, standing and grabbing our coats.
“That’s one more thing we have in common,” she shot back, eyes bright now—not fake bright, just… brave.
On the drive back, the sky went that early-winter purple and the mountains looked like they were breathing. After a while, her head tipped against the window and her eyes fluttered shut. I drove slower than I needed to, just to give her sleep a few extra minutes, just to let the road keep moving under us while my brain tried to figure out how to protect two people from the same man.