Chapter 140

Aiden

When I got home after the club, I couldn’t tell what emotion ruled me—anger, regret, longing, shame. They all felt the same now. My veins buzzed with them, like I’d been filled with static instead of blood.

I had gone there to forget, but all I’d done was remind myself of everything I’d lost.

I’d betrayed him simply by stepping foot in that place without him. The moment I’d seen Micah kneel at my feet, a jolt of guilt tore through me. I’d thought I could handle it, that it would be harmless—a distraction, a mask I could wear for a few hours until the ache dulled. But the truth was, letting him kneel there had felt like a knife to the heart. It was a mistake before it even began.

The whole scene was punishment. Not just for him, for leaving me once, not even for Noah—though God knows a part of me wanted to hurt him for those pictures with her, for looking so happy when I was coming apart—but for myself. For every decision that had led me here. I lashed out through the motions of control, trying to reclaim something I’d never really had.

Nothing happened after. Not really. Micah came home with me because I shouldn’t have been driving; I’d had more to drink than I should have. I remember unlocking the door, collapsing onto the couch while he tidied up the mess I’d made leaving that morning. I remember him speaking softly, saying something about second chances. I told him my heart wasn’t his to mend. That it never would be. Told him about Noah, about losing him, about things I should've never said…

He didn’t argue. He just pulled a blanket over me, brushed his thumb once over my temple, and sat nearby until I drifted. I dreamed of Noah.

I could swear I heard his phone's ringtone, that single buzz that used to make me smile no matter where I was. I reached for it in my sleep—half-awake, half-hopeful—but there was nothing. Just the quiet.

When I woke hours later, Micah was gone. The house was still. His scent lingered faintly, fresh cologne over leather. For a moment, I thought it was Noah’s. I buried my face in the pillow and tried not to breathe.

Maybe this was what I deserved—echoes of the wrong people, ghosts that looked like the ones I’d loved.

I sat up, rubbed my hands over my face, and laughed under my breath. It sounded cracked. Christ, I’m losing it.

The screen of my phone glowed beside me. No messages. No calls. Just silence.

I should have felt numb by now, but somehow the silence hurt worse than anything else.

I stood, poured the last of the whiskey down the sink, and let the glass roll from my fingers into the drain. The sound it made—hollow, final—felt like punctuation.

If Noah was out there somewhere, smiling in another life, then this was how I’d love him now. From far away. Quietly. Without expecting anything back.

I’d broken enough things trying to hold on.

The next morning, I woke to a soft chime—Micah’s name flashing across my screen.

Micah:

Good morning, Sir. I just wanted to thank you… for that night. For trusting me enough to let me close again.

Still “Sir.” He never forgot.

I closed my eyes and sighed.

Me:

Thank you for helping me get home. Not my brightest moment.

The typing dots pulsed for a few seconds before his next message appeared.

Micah:

Would it be alright if I came by? We don’t have to do a scene. We could just talk… or sit for a while. It’s almost Christmas.

For a second, I nearly said yes. The house was too damn quiet, and the air too heavy. But I knew what that visit would turn into—comfort, blurred lines, and regret.

Me:

Not a good idea. Not right now.

I tossed the phone aside and went through the motions of my day—coffee, shower, nothing that resembled life. Christmas Eve crept up like an obligation. My fingers itched to call Noah, to hear his voice, to tell him I still love you even if he didn’t want to hear it. But I didn’t.

Not because I gave a damn about the Harts, but because I didn’t want to risk making his life harder than it already was.

I’d planned so many things for that night.

A quiet dinner. A movie he liked. The small tree I’d bought weeks ago when I still thought maybe we’d celebrate together. There was even a stack of gifts under it—things I’d chosen with ridiculous care. A signed football from his favorite player. A leather bracelet engraved on the inside with Yours, always. A silver pen for his desk, though I knew he hated writing by hand. And a picture frame I’d meant to fill with our first photo together. Still empty.

The house glowed softly with the lights I hadn’t bothered to take down. I refused a few invitations—one from my colleagues, another from the staff party I’d long since stopped attending—and ignored Micah’s final offer: “You don’t have to be alone tonight, Sir. Please.”

I told him I had plans. I didn’t.

Christmas Day came heavy. I made coffee, didn’t drink it. The silence was a living thing.

At some point, I gave in. “You know what? Fuck it,” I muttered, grabbing my phone. “Better this than calling him.”

I opened the app, scrolling mindlessly through the feed I swore I’d stopped checking. His profile, his media pictures… Pictures of players, alumni, random holiday posts—and then… there it was. The last entry, pinned to his name by over a dozen people.

Noah Blake and Lexie Hart: Engaged.

The words hit like a blow to the ribs. The photo showed them in front of a glowing Christmas tree, her hand lifted to show off the ring, his arm around her waist.

He was smiling.

No.

No, please.

It couldn’t be real.

The room tilted. My phone slipped from my hand and hit the floor. I dropped to my knees beside it, staring at the screen until the image blurred. My chest constricted, breaths coming in ragged gasps.

Finally, I picked it up with shaking hands and typed the only thing I could manage.

Me:

Is it true? Please tell me it isn’t true. Not after what we had.

The three dots blinked.

And blinked.

And then stopped.

A minute later, his message appeared.

Noah:

Forgive me. What we had is dead.

There was a pause, like he’d stopped breathing before typing again.

Noah:

Just as I’m dead.

My vision tunneled. The words swam, the room seemed to dissolve around me. I could almost hear his voice—flat, hollow, defeated.

I stared at the message until the screen dimmed. Then I dropped the phone again, pressing the heels of my hands into my eyes, trying to push the ache back into whatever dark corner it had crawled out of.

But it was too late. The ache had teeth.

I whispered into the empty room, voice raw and shaking.

“Then so am I.”

The lights on the small tree flickered once and went still, throwing long shadows across the walls. Somewhere outside, the world was celebrating.

Inside, I finally broke.