Chapter 139
Noah
I used to think having it all meant freedom.
When I pictured rich people, I figured they could buy anything—fancy houses, shiny cars, friends who pretended to care, the kind of toys and comforts that made life easy. I never imagined how heavy all that comfort could feel when it wasn’t yours.
Growing up, having it all would’ve meant heat in the winter and food that lasted more than a few days. It would’ve meant a Christmas tree that didn’t come from the curb after someone else threw it out, and shoes that didn’t belong to three other kids before me. I used to dream about unwrapping something new—just once.
Now I was drowning in new. Designer sweaters stacked like trophies. A gold watch that could feed my family for months. A pair of leather boots worth more than my mother’s rent. William Hart’s idea of generosity.
Meanwhile, I couldn’t stop seeing their faces—Mom and Emily huddled in that cold little apartment, praying the heat didn’t get shut off again or that my father wouldn't come home drunk and violent once more... My chest ached thinking of it. This was Christmas: crystal chandeliers, champagne, laughter loud enough to drown out the guilt.
Every gift around me meant nothing. Not the mountain of boxes, not the applause when Eleonora unwrapped the vintage wine set “I’d” supposedly chosen.
William had picked every damn thing. He’d even handed me a black Amex and said, “Make Lexie feel adored.”
I’d been using that card all month for dinners and gestures I thought were okay. But truth was, I had no idea what to give a girl who already had everything.
The night before, I’d given her something that actually came from me—a new Groveton jersey with my name and number, signed with love. It wasn’t expensive, but it was mine. The way her face lit up when she unfolded it softened something inside me I didn’t know was still capable of warmth.
Maybe that was why tonight hurt even more.
So there she was, radiant in red silk, glowing with gratitude as she opened a tiny designer purse, a diamond necklace, and another box filled with little luxury trinkets I couldn’t name—all gifts from “me.”
None of them were mine. None of them were me.
The only gift I’d truly chosen, weeks ago—back when I still had hope—wasn’t for any of them. It was for Aiden.
A simple silver keychain engraved with Your Baby Boy.
Something small enough to hide, but real enough to mean everything. I’d imagined him holding it on his keyring, brushing it with his thumb, remembering.
Now it sat buried at the bottom of my bag like a wound I couldn’t stop pressing.
Applause broke out as Lexie thanked me for the gifts William had picked. I smiled, nodded, played along. Every “thank you” sounded hollow, every kiss on my cheek another nail sealing my silence.
When it was my turn, she handed me her presents—a gleaming gold chain with a small charm shaped like a wolf, a cologne I’d actually used before, a beautiful leather jacket for my bike. I liked it, genuinely. And that somehow made it worse.
Before I could say anything, William’s voice carried across the room. “And now, I have one more gift for you, Noah.”
The crowd quieted. Every time he spoke, the air seemed to shift, like we all existed inside his show. He motioned for me to follow, and a wave of movement followed us—Lexie, her mother, a few cousins, a handful of cameras. No surprise there. Every gesture in this family came with a photo op.
We walked through the glass doors to the back of the mansion, the winter air sharp against my lungs. The Hart estate looked like something out of a snow globe—fountains frozen mid-cascade, strings of gold lights wound around the trees, the world gilded and unreal.
William’s arm landed on my shoulder with practiced warmth. “You’re a man now, son. A man who’s going places. I can’t have my star quarterback riding my daughter around on a small motorcycle.”
My pulse spiked. I forced a chuckle that didn’t sound human. That small motorcycle was my most priced possession. Aiden's gift to me.
He smiled, broad and grand. “So I figured you’d need something more fitting. More secure. More… professional.”
The garage doors hummed open.
And there it was.
A brand-new car—sleek, dark metallic, probably more expensive than my childhood home. The leather interior gleamed under the chandelier lights of the estate, the kind of luxury that didn’t seem real.
For a long moment, I couldn’t speak. My throat went dry.
“I—I can’t accept this, sir,” I managed. “It’s too much.”
“Nonsense.” William’s grin widened, camera flashes catching in his teeth. “You’ve earned it. And besides, you’ll need something suitable for when you’re representing Groveton—and the Harts.”
Lexie clapped her hands, thrilled. “It’s perfect, Daddy! Isn’t it, Noah?”
I looked at her—at her joy, her innocence—and felt the ground tilt beneath me. “It’s… unbelievable,” I said softly, taking the keys he pressed into my hand.
Dozens of pictures followed—me behind the wheel, Lexie in the passenger seat, her mother waving from the steps. I smiled until my face hurt, played the part until the camera flashes blurred into snowflakes.
The car smelled like leather and betrayal.
When the crowd began to drift back inside, Lexie leaned into me, her voice a melody of excitement. “Come on, take it for a spin!”
I forced a smile and kissed her cheek. “Soon,” I promised. “As soon as we’re done… I have one last gift for you back inside.”
Her eyes lit up. “Another one? Noah Blake, you’re going to spoil me.”
If only she knew.
I was still in a daze as we stepped back into the sitting room, when William caught my eye and gave a small nod. My stomach dropped.
Time.
I reached into my pocket and pulled out the last box. The one I’d been ordered to give.
Lexie’s eyes lit up, confused but excited. The chatter around us dimmed, and then, as if on cue, the room transformed. The lights softened to amber. A violinist appeared near the fireplace, bow poised. Someone dimmed the chandelier.
Eleonora gasped. Cameras flashed. The family’s personal photographer stepped forward.
I wanted to disappear.
Lexie turned toward me, breathless. “Noah?”
I forced myself to smile. I could feel everyone watching—William’s pride, her mother’s tears, the gasps and murmurs of the perfect Christmas story unfolding before their eyes.
I dropped to one knee.
Her hands flew to her mouth. The music swelled, strings trembling like my heart.
The ring box snapped open in my shaking hand. Diamonds. Big enough to blind me.
“Lexie Hart,” I said, somehow steady though my throat was closing, “you’ve given me more kindness than I deserve. More light than I knew I could have.” My voice wavered; they’d think it was emotion. “Would you—” I had to stop, swallow. God, forgive me. “Would you marry me?”
Gasps. Tears.
William’s grin was a monument to triumph.
Lexie sobbed and nodded, throwing herself into my arms. Cameras flashed like lightning. Somewhere, someone cheered.
I held her tight, blinking hard as tears spilled down my face. They thought it was joy. Gratitude.
It wasn’t.
It was grief.
Because in that single moment—on my knees, with everyone clapping and cheering, with her arms around my neck—I felt my whole life break apart.
I’d saved Aiden. I’d saved his career, his name, his future.
But mine was gone.
And when she whispered “I love you” into my ear, I whispered it back, because lies were the only thing I had left to give.