Chapter 44: How Many Before Him?

Valentia's outburst turned all eyes on her.

Conversations like this, though sometimes broached between very close friends in private, were impolite and even repulsive when asked so bluntly in public.

Donovan was visibly uncomfortable. "Valentia, you've had too much to drink."

Valentia, wearing a smirk, kept her gaze locked on Livia. "Why is that so difficult to answer? Is it impossible that he's the last stop on your list?"

"Valentia, mind your manners," Angelo warned her in a cold tone.

Valentia laughed lightly. “What’s the matter? We’re just chatting, right?”

She was determined to put Livia on the spot.

Livia couldn't believe that someone with such a flirtatious demeanor had never been in love or had other men.

If Angelo knew about her ex-boyfriends, he would definitely mind.

Given Angelo's strong possessiveness, he wanted to be someone's everything.

"Is Valentia really that curious about my personal life?" Livia, truly underestimating Valentia's audacity, responded coolly. "If you were a man interested in dating me, I might tell you how many men I've had."

Valentia narrowed her eyes. "Is it a touchy subject for you?"

Feeling repulsed, Livia couldn't understand how someone could present themselves as so rational in public yet be so rash behind the scenes.

She no longer wanted to be in the same space as Valentia.

Standing up, she said, "Sorry, but someone here is making me uncomfortable, so I'm not sticking around." Without waiting for Angelo, she grabbed her purse and left.

Angelo looked sternly at Valentia and rose, eyes fixed downward in contemplation. "Valentia, you're overstepping your boundaries."

When Donovan saw him leave, he hurried after him, calling out, "Valentia's just had too much to drink. Just let Miss Ashcroft know not to take it personally."

Angelo's gaze turned dark. "You think she's just drunk?"

Donovan tried to defend Valentia. "You know she's always had feelings for you. It must be hard for her to see you with another woman after all these years. Let's not hold it against her."

"I've been more than patient with her. She's the one who crossed the line, not knowing when to stop,” Angelo said, clearly agitated. “Besides, the past is the past. When she chose to leave, she should’ve realized there was no future between us.”

"She had her reasons at the time," Donovan tried to defend Valentia.

Angelo said coldly, "She knows whether those reasons were compelling."

"Do you really have no feelings for her at all?" Donovan felt sorry for Valentia. She had invested a lot in the relationship.

"Do you think that's an appropriate question right now?" Angelo challenged him.

Donovan was at a loss for words, and he sighed softly. "I just think if you still have feelings for her, you shouldn't hurt her like this."

"I have none," Angelo stated sharply. "If she wants to maintain what we have now, she should know her limits."

After saying this, Angelo walked away, leaving Donovan to drag his feet back into the private room.

He saw Valentia covering her face, sobbing, and he walked over helplessly. "You really went too far with what you said earlier."

"Why did he move on so quickly? He must hate me," Valentia looked up, her face streaked with tears, her voice choked. "I just wanted to be more capable, not to watch helplessly as he lost everything again. Was I wrong to do that?"

The sight of Valentia crying her eyes out wrenched Donovan's heart, yet he was utterly at a loss for how to comfort her.

"You left him when he was at his lowest, resolutely and without looking back." Lockrey, who had been quiet until now, suddenly cut to the heart of the matter.

"I had no choice," Valentia inhaled deeply, her voice firm with resolve, "If I had known this day would come, I would never have left him."

Lockrey made a seemingly casual remark. "If he was still penniless, would you stay by his side?"

"Of course!" Valentia affirmed with conviction.

Lockrey's gaze remained undisturbed. "There are no 'ifs' about it. When he had nothing, the one who stood by him was Livia."

Donovan jerked his head towards Lockrey, wondering how he knew.

Valentia's expression also turned to one of shock.

Upon leaving the club, Livia walked slowly along the roadside, waiting for Angelo.

If he came out after her, she felt she could negate all the grievances she'd endured at Valentia's.

Her pace was deliberate, then suddenly someone tugged at her hand.

Turning, the concern in Angelo's eyes flickered momentarily.

"Walking so slowly, waiting for me?" Angelo said as he let go of her hand, his tone light.

Livia looked at him. "Moving so fast, chasing after me?"

Angelo shot her a look, hands in his pockets. "If I hadn't had a drink, I'd have driven straight home."

"Okay." Livia gazed downward with a wistful lilt in her voice.

Seeing this, Angelo curved his arm around her path, opening up to her.

Livia raised an eyebrow after seeing his gesture. "Not afraid of being seen?"

"No one here knows me," Angelo said, a hint of impatience in his voice. "You gonna take my arm or not?"

Livia slipped her hand through his arm. They resembled a couple strolling, their simple contentment laced with happiness.

Elmrest Springs had a pretty famous nightscape.

It was rare for Livia to enjoy the night view at such moments, but she found it rather pleasant.

"Don't dwell on Valentia's words."

Livia looked up at him. "Are you trying to excuse her behavior?"

"No." Angelo responded. "I'm just looking out for your feelings."

"Thanks." Livia replied lazily but with a touch of jest, then asked with an affected nonchalance laced with underlying tension, "Have you slept with her?"

Angelo paused mid-step, glancing down. "Does it bother you?"

Livia's mood darkened.

"I don't care if you've slept with other women. I just hope it wasn't with her." Livia laid bare her thoughts.

After a long moment, Angelo's voice reached her ears. "No."

Livia stopped, tilting her face up to look at him.

Angelo said, "I never did."

A flicker of joy sparkled in Livia's eyes. “You haven’t slept with her?”

"No other women," Angelo said, his gaze fixed straight ahead, not looking at her, but feeling the gleam in her eyes.

A smug smile played on Livia's lips as her heart swelled with joy.

Love didn't matter as much now. Even if they didn't stay together in the future, she would always be his first.

A woman one can never forget.

Angelo saw the curl of her lips and couldn't fathom why he felt the need to explain this to her.

'Perhaps it's to soothe her after Valentia bullied her,' he thought.

Livia swung his hand away. "Aren't you going to ask me?"

"Ask what?"

"How many men I've been with before you."

Angelo let out a dismissive snort.

"What does that mean?" Livia frowned.

"I don't need to ask. I know the answer," Angelo said with certitude.

Livia knew what he meant. She tiptoed, whispering into his ear, "Hymens can be reconstructed."

Angelo came to a sudden stop, his prior confidence shattered by her insinuation.

"You care about that?" Livia pressed on, seeing the darkening look on his face.

"You sure?" Angelo fixed his eyes on her.

Livia pulled her hand away and started to backpedal with a sly smile on her face. "I thought you said you knew the answer."

Angelo's eyes narrowed as he approached her with a cold visage. "You’d better explain yourself."

"I won’t," Livia teased, twirling around, playfully seductive.