Chapter 43: Catfights Sure Are Entertaining

"Hey, that's not too friendly." Donovan followed Livia, pestering her. "Angelo was clearly pissed just now. How on earth did you manage to rile him up? It's not like just anyone can get under his skin."

Livia couldn't believe it. "His mood is always unstable, okay?"

"And how exactly do you tolerate his fiery temper?" Donovan dramatically leaned back.

"Say that to his face, and he'll definitely show you his emotions," Livia joked.

Donovan chuckled, speaking covertly, "It's all you who's got him wrapped around your finger. Trust me, over these years, he has never flaunted any lady like that in public. You're the first."

Livia didn't buy it. After all, she had seen some bombshell clinging to his leg before.

"Wasn't Valentia the first one?" Livia peered through the crack of the door and saw Valentia had already moved to sit next to Angelo.

Donovan smiled awkwardly. "They're history now. You're in the present tense. We're all friends here, don't sweat it."

Livia watched Valentia lean affectionately towards Angelo, almost brushing shoulders before artfully distancing herself and then inching closer again, repeatedly. It all seemed quite innocent.

But to any onlooker, their rapport was anything but ordinary.

Livia walked in and sat down beside Angelo, sandwiching him between two women.

Lockrey sat in a corner, silently observing the scene.

"Valentia, come sit by me," Donovan called as he walked in. "Let's not interrupt them."

Valentia glared at Donovan. "We're all single; why force the issue?"

"What do you mean 'all single'? Angelo's got a girlfriend now. You need to keep your distance," Donovan said as he pulled Valentia away, seating himself squarely between her and Angelo.

Livia was actually very grateful for Donovan's intervention. She had wanted to do the same but had restrained herself to maintain her poise.

Valentia pinched Donovan's arm, glaring fiercely at him. "Have you been single for so long that you're on the hunt for a girlfriend? Maybe I should set you up?"

"Sure," Donovan responded breezily. "You're single too, maybe we should just pair up."

From his corner, Lockrey glanced at the unserious Donovan, poured himself a drink, gently swirling it, enjoying his own company in silence.

Valentia rolled her eyes, "You're not my type."

"Your type is already in someone else's territory," Donovan hinted with a sly undertone.

"Even if he's taken, what's bitten can still be spat out," she fired back, full of defiance.

"Aren't you worried about the mess?" he prodded playfully.

Valentia and Livia overheard, both cursing Donovan silently.

Valentia pinched Donovan again. "You're the filthy one."

"How would you know? You've never tried. Why don't we test that theory at my place later?" Donovan proposed, his grin devilish.

"Go to hell!" Valentia snapped, anger flaring.

Donovan laughed triumphantly. "Look how fast you lose your cool. Relax, you're not my type."

"Thanks for that," Valentia said sarcastically, shifting her seat to put distance between them.

Donovan's gaze then snapped to the man brooding in the corner. "Lockrey, how about we partner up?"

Lockrey choked on his drink.

Livia was equally stunned by Donovan's proposal.

Angelo shot Donovan a sharp look. "Do you ever stop talking?"

"If I shut up, the mood here would be dead," Donovan stood, taking the mic with a grin. "Let's liven up the party. I'm going to sing a solo for y'all, 'The Bachelor's Ballad.'"

Donovan started his performance.

Indeed, the place was anything but dull or awkward with Donovan around. Eventually, the group began playing cards.

Livia abstained, while Valentia joined in the game.

"Miss Ashcroft, do you play Blackjack?" Donovan gathered the cards and asked Livia.

Livia waved her hand dismissively. "It’s not my kind of game."

"It's alright if you don't know how. All that matters is you know how to pay out." Donovan shuffled the deck with a cunning smile. "I've lost a pretty penny to Angelo already. I've got to win something back from you."

Livia glanced at Angelo, who said nonchalantly. "Play if you want to play."

"Go easy on me," Livia said as they switched seats.

Lockrey didn't get involved, so it was just Donovan, Valentia, and Livia.

Maybe it was the rivalry between Donovan's potential flames that set the mood. Donovan, caught in the crossfire, relished the tension.

Several rounds in, Livia was down over a grand while Valentia raked in the winnings.

"Turns out, some battles you just can't win, even if you stand your ground," Valentia remarked, a victorious glint in her eye as she gazed at Livia.

Never one to back down, Livia snapped back, "You're telling me. I could never beat Miss Jammie at cards. You know the saying, 'Lucky in love, unlucky in cards.' Imagine if I were winning at both. Now that'd be something."

At that, Valentia's confident grin vanished.

Donovan glanced between the two women, thoroughly amused by the sparring match.

Valentia and Livia weren't holding back anymore. They were going head-to-head. Angelo, on the other hand, seemed oblivious to their words, remaining silent throughout.

"The real winner here is Angelo. He must be thrilled, having two beauties vie for his attention," Donovan said with a smirk, eager to stir the pot even more.

Angelo cast a sidelong glance at Donovan. "Lockrey, I heard about a killer bar recently, all top shelf girls there. You interested in checking it out? You might just meet your dream girl."

Donovan tensed up immediately. "Quit playing matchmaker."

"Lockrey's been single for ages. It wouldn't hurt to get him some love," Angelo said provocatively, eyes on Donovan.

"Since when does he want a relationship? Lockrey, is that what you want?" Donovan asked him.

Suddenly, the center of attention, Lockrey, looked at Donovan's slightly anxious face and took a sip of his drink, "I'm open to it."

Donovan's eyes widened in surprise.

Angelo raised his glass, toasting to Donovan with a wicked grin.

Livia always felt like there was some kind of backstory between Donovan and Lockrey.

Her phone vibrated. She checked Facebook, and it was Lucas asking if she was free to hang out at his place.

As she was about to reply, Angelo leaned in and whispered, "Don't reply."

Livia looked up and met Angelo's threatening gaze.

She pursed her lips and whispered back, "It's rude not to."

Angelo just stared at her intently without a word.

Under the weight of his stare, Livia eventually gave in and put her phone away.

Their interaction didn't escape Valentia's notice. She downed another drink and then blurted out loudly to Livia, "Miss Ashcroft, how many men have you had before Angelo?"