Chapter 7: Chapter Seven

Isaac finished his dinner in record time. “Thank you for everything,” he told Caleb as he stood to leave.

Caleb’s gaze landed on Leanne, who wasn’t even half-way done with her plate. “Of course. We love having you over,” he said, his attention returning to Isaac. “Which means you can’t leave before dessert. We made your favorite.”

Leanne perked up at that. “You made a lava cake?”

Isaac’s eyes snapped in her direction. “You remembered,” he said, surprised. She looked equally surprised that he’d actually spoken to her.

Shoot. He hadn’t meant to. It wasn’t that he didn’t want to talk to Leanne, but it made staying away that much more difficult. And that was what he’d need to do to retain his sanity. What if he let her in, and then she left again? She’d already done it once when a better opportunity presented itself. It had taken the entire two years to finally start functioning again. He was pretty sure another heartbreak would finish him off.

“Yes, Bree and I learned together,” Caleb said, exchanging a meaningful look with his wife. It was hard to decipher what it meant, though. Ever since they’d married it was almost like they’d developed a secret code between themselves. “And I have to say, it turned out pretty dang good for our first try.” He turned a smile on Isaac, then glanced pointedly at his chair.

Fine. He’d sit back down. But only for the lava cake. It had nothing to do with Leanne or how beautiful she looked tonight or how she had remembered what his favorite dessert was. Nope. Nothing to do with any of that.

The conversation died as the others finished their food, apparently not in a rush to get this night over with. He impatiently waited, his knee bouncing up and down. Hopefully the lava cake was still warm, its chocolaty center still liquid.

Isaac had once thought it cute how Leanne took her time when eating, savoring each bite. Now it tormented him. As soon as she’d taken her last one he said, “Now, where is this elusive dessert I’ve heard so much about?”

“In a hurry, are we?” Bree asked, rising and gathering up the plates. Caleb stood to help his wife, grabbing the dirty utensils.

“Didn’t you know,” Caleb asked her. “Isaac is obsessed with that new TV show, So you think you can Mime. Can’t miss an episode.”

Isaac tried to scowl, but ended up laughing instead. Not only did he not own a TV, but Caleb knew that Isaac was terrified of mimes. They were far creepier than your run-of-the-mill clown.

He wasn’t the only one laughing. Leanne was bent over, tears streaming down her cheeks. Okay, it hadn’t been that funny. “Have you actually seen him when around a mime?” she finally choked out.

Oh no. Not this story. He still had PTSD from the experience and would probably have nightmares for at least the next month, just from thinking about it. “Really, we don’t need to go into the details.”

“Actually, I think we do,” Caleb said, a wicked gleam in his eye. He placed the utensils he still held back onto the table and leaned forward.

It seemed everyone was intent on ignoring Isaac, because Leanne continued without even a glance in his direction. “We’d gone to the city to shop and had just rounded a corner when he nearly ran straight into one.”

“Let me guess,” Caleb said, “he high-tailed it in the opposite direction.”

Leanne shook her head and took a moment to regain her composure before continuing on. “At first he apologized, not realizing who it had been. But when the mime didn’t answer back, and instead tried to give him a hug to show that all was forgiven…” She burst into another fit of laughter. “Isaac jumped backwards, tripped over his own feet, and crab walked through a crowd of people that had just exited one of the mall’s department stores. He had shoe prints on his hands for the rest of the day.”

“Sounds familiar,” Caleb said, throwing a grin Isaac’s way. He was no doubt thinking of the Speedo incident. Apparently Isaac’s default setting was to crab walk.

“Their silence is unnerving,” Isaac interjected before his friend could bring up yet another embarrassing moment. One was enough for right now. “It’s especially bad on the loud streets of the city, where you never know when you’ll run into one. You round a corner and then, BAM, a mime is in your face and trying to hug you, or get you to smell a flower or—” He shuddered. They needed to find a new subject. Everyone else thought his fear of mimes was hilarious, but he didn’t like being confronted by someone who hid behind a mask of paint and silence. They were unpredictable and had almost an inhuman like quality about them.

Leanne sobered when she saw Isaac’s expression. He wondered what she saw. Pain? Horror? “I was much more empathetic at the time,” she said quickly. “But time heals all wounds, right?”

“Or it creates them,” Isaac muttered, not meaning to speak aloud. But he did, and the rest of the group fell silent. The awkward tension had returned in full throttle.

Bree plastered on an obviously fake smile and said, “I think it’s time for dessert.” Her tone was far too chipper for the circumstances, but everyone went along with it as she hurried out with the dirty plates. Caleb followed her, but they didn’t take their time like they had earlier. Isaac could see them speeding around the small kitchen, grabbing bowls and spoons, then the ice cream from the freezer. “Darn it,” Bree said. “The ice cream is still hard. Is there a way we can get it to thaw quicker?”

It took a moment before Isaac realized that Leanne was staring at him. Their eyes met. Too late to pretend he hadn’t noticed. “You just had to tell that story.”

She raised a shoulder, and her gaze dropped to her hands. “You used to laugh about it too. Not when it happened of course, but after.”

“I used to do a lot of things I don’t do now.”

Leanne’s gaze found his again. “You still surf. And lifeguard. And eat dinner with Caleb, though Bree is a new addition.” She paused. “It seems the only things you don’t do anymore have to do with me.”

“What did you expect?” Isaac asked. “That you could leave me—ignore me—and I would be happy to see you when you came strolling across the beach, red high heels in hand?” Okay, that was a little harsh. Or a lot harsh. To be fair, that had been his expectation as well. He had thought they had dated too long—loved each other too long—for anything to come between them.

Isaac had been wrong.

He shook his head and stood, pushing his chair back, trying to ignore the pain that flashed across Leanne’s face. “I never should have let Caleb convince me to come inside.”

Leanne stood, matching his stance. “Why? Because I’m here? Fine. I’ll leave. But even if you’ve stopped loving me, is it too much to ask for you to stop hating me as well?”

Isaac stilled. Not because she was right, but because she was so wrong. He could never hate Leanne. If he did, he wouldn’t feel the need to run the opposite direction every time she came near. It wasn’t hate that sent his heart reeling, but an intense longing for something that could never be—and that he no longer wanted. Or at least, he didn’t want to want it. Isaac knew it made no sense, but love rarely followed the rules of logic.

Bree and Caleb walked in at that moment, saving him from needing to answer. Their gazes flitted between Isaac and Leanne, who probably looked like they were having a stare-off. Bree’s fake smile faltered for a moment, but then her overly chipper tone returned in full force. “We made individual cakes so everyone would get the good, gooey stuff.” She placed four bowls on the table, each with a miniature chocolate Bundt cake and a large scoop of chocolate chip ice cream on top.

Isaac had, once again, been ready to walk out. But his friends knew his weakness, and as the ice cream began to melt on the still-hot lava cake, his resolve crumbled. He knew there was chocolaty awesomeness ready to ooze out from the middle. He didn’t sit back down though, out of principle, and took his bowl to the window where he sat down on the ledge and ate in silence. Or, almost silence. He couldn’t quite keep a small moan escaping as he took the first bite.

“So, does that mean we succeeded in making the best lava cake you’ve ever had?” Bree asked, a smile playing on her lips. And this time it was genuine. She seemed pleased to see him enjoying his dessert so much.

Isaac returned her smile. “This is one of the best things you’ve ever made.” He paused. “And now that I know you can make it…”

“This is not an every-week kind of thing,” Caleb interjected, though he wore a smile that said he was also enjoying the compliments.

Isaac once again finished before everyone else and said his good-byes before they could stop him from leaving. His farewell was generic, meant for everyone in the room, so as to not make things more awkward than they already were. As he reached the bottom of the steps and placed a hand on the doorknob to leave the building, Caleb caught up to him.

Great.

He expected Caleb to go on about how he needed to give Leanne a chance, like he had before dinner. It was only to get Caleb off his back that he had agreed to come upstairs in the first place. That, and the food that had been promised. Isaac never turned down a free meal if he could help it. As an avid surfer, most of the little money he made from lifeguarding went to new gear.

“Hey,” Caleb said. “I’m sorry. For tonight. I don’t know what I had expected, but…we just thought—”

“If you got us both into the same room, forcing us together, we’d realize that we were still madly in love and couldn’t live without each other?”

A grunt. “Yeah, something like that.” At least Caleb had the decency to sound embarrassed. “You did the same for me, forcing my hand to ask Bree out on our first date.”

“But you two already liked each other. Everyone could see that you two just needed a nudge. With Leanne—things are different. We don’t need a nudge, we need a…a…time machine.” Isaac gave a quick shake of his head, feeling the impossibility of the situation. They couldn’t get back together, and yet, he didn’t know how he was going to live in the same small town with her. It wasn’t going to be just Caleb and Bree that tried to force them back into a relationship. The whole town was going to take on the task, as if they were personally assigned, and most of them weren’t going to be as subtle as Caleb and Bree had been—if that could be called subtle.

Jessie had probably already started baking the wedding cake.

“I’m afraid I’m fresh out of time machines,” Caleb said. Isaac couldn’t see his expression, but he sounded disappointed, even a bit sad. Where was Doctor Who when you needed him?

It was already growing late, the sun beginning to set over the ocean. It was Isaac’s favorite time of night. Many surfers preferred going out at dusk, but not Isaac. Early mornings were for surfing. Right now, it was for finding peace. “I’m going to head to the beach,” Isaac said. It was where the town congregated each evening, everyone coming together at the end of the day to witness one of God’s miracles. And Heaven knew he needed a miracle right now.

“I’m assuming you’d prefer to go alone,” Caleb said.

Did Isaac want to be alone? No. But he was tired of being the tag-a-long to everyone else’s life. Caleb was basically Isaac’s surrogate brother, but Caleb also had a family of his own now. One that Isaac wasn’t a part of.

“Yeah, I think that would be best.” Isaac shoved his hands in his pockets as he walked away. A breeze picked up and whistled through the plants that surrounded the small path he walked. As he rounded the corner of the laundromat, he was greeted with the oranges and yellows and reds that filled the sky and they reflected off the ocean’s surface. It was hard to tell from this distance where one ended and the other began. He knew that feeling well, often feeling like he was caught between reality and an illusion.

“Hi Isaac,” someone called as they rode past on their bike. Isaac flashed a grin in their direction, but in the fading light couldn’t tell who it had been.

But it didn’t matter. Because they knew who he was. They knew his name. Everyone in town did.

They were family too.

And that was reason enough to stay.

Even with Leanne back in town.