Chapter 189: ONE NINTHY

I blinked. “I wouldn’t go so far as to call her a submissive.”

“Whatever. Maybe it’s just a trust and safety thing. She loves you, and she trusts you, and the idea of putting herself in your hands and getting all that pleasure...” Alice’s voice trailed off as her eyes unfocused a bit, but she squeezed my dick a little tighter in her hands.

“Want me to go down on you right now?” I asked quietly.

“Yesss...” Blinking from her reverie, Alice looked up at me and blushed, finishing, “But uh, no not yet.”

“Well now that you mention it, I think there’s a certain level of intimacy Sam shares with me when we have anal sex. For all of the girls, actually, it’s so much more ... personal ... special ... like Neevie’s bit about her sacred core. A girl letting me into her ass is like the ultimate representation of putting her trust in me, of expressing how safe she feels with me to let me do that to her, even if it’s not the most comfortable thing.”

“Yeah, it’s the discomfort part that worries me the most. I mean, I trust you Matty, and I feel safe with you. But it just looks so painful.”

I shrugged. “Don’t knock it ‘til you try it.”

“I have.”

My eyebrows popped. “You have?”

“Well, not with your dick, obviously. But Neevie’s played around with my butt a little bit. Pretty early on, actually, she was going down on me and I was super-close to orgasm and she popped a finger in my ass and started wiggling it. It stopped me from cumming and just freaked me out. She got all apologetic.”

I frowned. “Having Neevie surprise you with a finger is different from truly ‘trying it’. Honestly, Belle got me to put my thumb into Sam’s butthole one time and just like you, it freaked her out. But now, obviously, she’s much more into it.”

“I didn’t say that was the ONLY time I’ve tried it. After Neevie turned into the Anal Queen and wouldn’t shut up about it, I got around to having her try it again, this time with me at least expecting it. But honestly? It’s just sorta ... weird.”

I held up my hands. “I’m not gonna argue with you. Neevie’s tried playing around with MY butt too while she was going down on me. It uh ... I didn’t like it.”

Alice started guffawing and she actually choked on her own spit for a second. At the same time, the discussion about my girlfriend sticking her fingers in my ass was not arousing in the slightest, and at some point Alice had stopped stroking my dick. I was deflating, and when she noticed, she pulled her hand away and gave me a thoughtful look.

“Maybe it would be different if you were the one playing around with my butt.”

I blinked in surprise. “Excuse me?”

Alice sighed. “Messing around with the girls has been ... eye-opening. I mean, having anyone’s tongue wrapped around my clit, male or female, is pretty awesome. I don’t mind going down on them either because fair is fair and to hear a girl moaning from an orgasm -I- gave her is a bit of a rush. But at the end of the day, I think I’m pretty straight. And while Neevie is hot and all, I’m not super-attracted to her. So like I said: maybe it would be different if it was you.”

With that, Alice stood up and started tugging down her skirt and panties. I gawked at her, a bit of a deer-in-the-headlights expression on my face.

“Go down on me first. Get me warmed up,” she said matter-of-factly. “And then when the mood seems right, go ahead and start playing around back there. Just as long as you know that licking me and putting your fingers in my butt is as far as you’re gonna get.”

I gave her a questioning look, one that asked if she was sure.

“What?” Alice smirked. “Hasn’t this basically been your role in the BTC for years already? Let us girls experiment with you, test our boundaries with a safe guy we know will never push us past what we’re comfortable with? This is the next step I want to explore, and I want to explore it with you.”

“Well when you put it that way...” I gave her a warm smile. But rather than slip off the couch and immediately start eating her out, I pulled the half-naked girl into my arms, abruptly dipped her over my lap, and sealed my lips over her mouth. She squealed in surprise but swooned when I started kissing her. I knew Alice would be perfectly happy to make out with me, and the adrenaline rush of feeling like she was falling for a second spiked that pleasure.

Knowing that the end goal was to get her comfortable with me playing around with her ass, I knew I should have patience and take the time to really work her up to it. So we made out for at least five minutes first.

I couldn’t hold her in my lap forever though, and I wound up shifting Alice over a bit until her head was supported by a pillow propped against the armrest to my left. I slid my right hand up her torso, circled it around to her back, and flipped the clasp of the lacy black bra she’d worn in stark contrast to the peach-colored scoop-neck tank top that had been showing off her cleavage to me all morning. I paused to brush dark bangs back from her pretty face, obviously highlighted by her makeup to give her an even more exotically-beautiful appeal while at the same time remaining quintessentially “Alice”. And I smiled in obvious admiration to make sure she understood just how lovely she was to me before I bent down to capture her lips with mine once again.

I fondled her breasts and scraped my tongue against hers. I slid my fingers down her belly and through her neatly-trimmed pubic hair before gently caressing her protruding clit. She moaned into my mouth and then pulled her lips off mine to gasp against my neck when I penetrated her pussy with two digits. I kissed my way down her neck, pulled the neckline of her tank top down and underneath her big boobs so that the peach fabric held the massive mounds up and together invitingly. I accepted my self-made invitation and began to lick and slurp and suckle at her proffered pink teats. And she whimpered and shivered and finally squeaked an orgasm into my ear when my nipple-suckling combined with fingerbanging combined with my thumbing of her clit to bring her up and over a small peak.

Only then did I slip off the couch and orient Alice’s body upright. Tugging on her buttcheeks, I dragged her ass right to the edge of the couch so I would have unfettered access to her sweet snatch. I dove in and feasted, wrapping my tongue around her clit right away. And she moaned and grabbed my hair, pressing my face even deeper into her crotch before groaning gutturally, “Ah, fuck, Matty. Eat me! Eat me!”

I ate her. I ate her and I fingerbanged her. I ate her, fingerbanged her, and then I flipped her over onto her stomach. She wound up with her chest and torso atop the couch cushion but her knees on the floor while I licked her slit from behind. I then dragged my tongue along her happy trail, from pussy across the perineum and finally to her winking rosebud. I licked all around that crinkled little sphincter while re-introducing my fingers into her wet box. And while I fingerbanged her cunt with three digits, I stiffened my tongue and pushed it through her anus.

Alice’s head popped up and she groaned in obvious pleasure. She reached out with both arms, clasping at the backrest and the cushions to either side. She grabbed the same pillow against the armrest and pulled it to her face, smothering herself for a moment before she bared her teeth and bit down on the top of it.

By now I’d started stashing an extra bottle of lube underneath the couch since I’d started having so many anal encounters with the girls in the family room. Just yesterday, I’d used the bottle to show off Belle’s new butthole trick, so it only took a few seconds of blindly searching with my left hand to find it. And after popping open the cap, I stopped giving my best friend a rimjob and instead squirted out a healthy glob of the slippery stuff right atop her anus.

Alice shivered and looked back at me, asking, “What are you—OHHHHHH!!!”

Her question got cut off when I removed my fingers from her cunt and instead pushed first one and then a second finger through the glob of lube and into her tight asshole. She’d clenched up in surprise but then relaxed a second later. I then ducked my head back down to resume licking her clit, working hard to send pleasure signals into her brain while slowly pumping the two fingers in and out of her ass.

“Turn over again, Alice,” I said gently and went back to eating her out.

Her eyes were clenched shut and she moaned as I fingerbanged her little asshole, but she responded nonetheless by rolling first onto one side, and then all the way back around while I used my free hand to hoist her body back up to the couch.

Now in her original position once again, shoulders reclined against the backrest with her ass hanging off the edge, I was able to bend over and really wrap my lips around her clit while fingerbanging her butt below. The half-naked Korean babe reached out with both hands to either side, searching for something ... anything ... to grab onto. And in the end she came up with her video game controller.

After hitting a button, the TV blazed back to life as the racing game unpaused. Her eyes wavered, but Alice stared straight at the screen. She grasped the controller with both hands and started pushing buttons. From behind me, I could hear her start a new 1-player game. And I chuckled to myself before bearing down to really feast on my best friend’s pussy, and even added a third finger into her ass while she played her game.

We went on like that for about three minutes. Twice, it seemed like Alice was about to climax as her eyes rolled up into her head and her head lolled to the side. But both times she fought off the orgasm like a sleepy driver trying to stay alert behind the wheel. She sat up a little straighter, inhaled sharply and focused on her racing. But a few seconds later, the pleasure took over again, and her head started to nod once more.

I have no idea what place she got in the race. It doesn’t really matter. All that matters to me is that as soon as the race was over, she finally dropped the controller, let her head fall back, and she absolutely SCREAMED in ecstasy, “EEEEYYYYAAAAAAAUUUUUGGGHHH!!!”

Her butthole clenched around my invading fingers. Her legs snapped shut around my ears. Her pelvis bucked off the mattress and actually bumped my nose. And Alice vibrated and shuddered on the couch as the most powerful climax I’d ever seen her have exploded throughout her entire body.

“EEEEYYYYAAAAAAAUUUUUGGGHHH!!!” she screamed again.

“EEEEYYYYAAAAAAAUUUUUGGGHHH!!!” she screamed one final time.

And then she went limp.

I decided to keep licking her as she came down from her orgasm. Nothing super intense - I just sort of lazily dragged my tongue up and down her soaking wet pussy while keeping three fingers buried in her asshole. I actually thought of introducing a fourth, since her orgasm had definitely loosened her up. But I resisted the urge and looked up at the beatific smile of heavenly bliss plastered all the way across her face.

Finally, I pulled my head up. “Enjoy that?”

“Put your cock in my ass, Matty,” she groaned, grimacing a little while helpless to even raise her head.

I blinked in surprise. “Umm, excuse me?”

“Shove your fucking big dick into my fucking tight ass,” she grumbled in an annoyed tone.

I couldn’t be hearing her correctly. “We haven’t even had regular sex yet.”

“Is there a rulebook saying I have to lose my pussy cherry before I lose my anal cherry? Shut up and shove it in there before I change my mind.”

“Alice, maybe--”

“Dick. Ass. NOW!”