Chapter 191: Cousin Sally 003

She had a far off look in her eyes, and she cuddled up next to me again. We laid side by side for a while, and then I had to get up and leave for work. I was going to be a little late, but I am pretty much on flex time so it is no problem. Sally didn't have a class until late morning, so no harm was done.

That evening when we both got home, we were a little uncomfortable with what we had done, and we didn't talk about it. When it got late, and we headed down the hall to our rooms, she stopped me and said "Can I sleep with you? I don't want to be alone."

"Sure. Come on in my room." We went in, and both started to undress. She stopped with her underwear still on, and looked at me for a hint. I stripped all the way down, so she did too. We got into bed, and hugged each other.

She took my cock in her delicate, tiny hand and fondled it, and it quickly grew hard. Her little hand made it look bigger that it is. She felt my balls with a light, fluttering touch. I thought about the fact that at 19 this was the first time she had played with a mans cock and balls.

I started to guide her down to my cock, but she stopped me. She said "I want to really do it." She reacted to the look on my face, and said "I want you to fuck me!"

"Sally, do you know what the most dangerous thing we could do is?"

"Get caught?" she answered.

"Well sure, but if we were to have a child, the child might have severe genetic issues. And we would also get caught!"

"Does that mean we can't do it?" she almost sobbed.

"Well, there are ways, if you trust me."

I reached down and gently touched her tiny asshole. She understood what I meant, and she looked apprehensive. I pushed my middle finger into her tight asshole. She squirmed and looked alarmed. I said "Trust me, remember?"

She was still holding my cock, which was now as stiff as a steel rod. She whispered "I don't think you can get this in me that way. It is so long it will never all fit in me."

I went into the bathroom, and returned with a tube of lubricant. I gave it to her, and said "Put just a little right on the tip of my cock. Just on the head."

She gingerly used one finger, and smeared the lube all over the head of my cock. I handed her a towel, and she wiped off her hands. I got her to understand that I wanted her to lie face down, and I climbed on top with my legs outside of hers.

I completely covered up all 110 pounds of her, and I was careful not to put any weight on her. She looked back at me over her shoulder, with an expression of nervous anticipation. Her cute, girlish butt was mine for the taking.

Her pink pussy lips were visible between her legs, but her ass-crack covered up and hid her asshole. She was trembling, waiting to be fucked for the first time.

She didn't know how to do anything to help me get it in, so with one hand I took one butt cheek and spread it to the side. With my other hand I guided the tip of my cock up against her asshole, and with that hand now free, I spread the other cheek.

I hope this doesn't sound weird, but she has a pretty asshole. No hair or dark skin around it, just a tiny pink hole. I pushed, but the tight ring of muscle at the entrance resisted. I pushed harder, and she whispered "Ow!"

I pushed even harder, and the lube finally did the trick, it slid in. She flinched, and made a noise like a mouse squeaking. I just said "Trust me." I eased it into her, deeper and deeper, until it was about half-way in.

She was making little grunting noises, and seemed to be uncomfortable. I stopped pushing to give her a chance to get used to it. I let go of her ass-cheeks, and the view now was of my cock just disappearing into the crack of her butt.

I keep bringing this up, but you need to understand that while I have been saying she is slender, most people would just say she is skinny. I am 6' 2" and athletic, she is nineteen and totally legal, but she looks like a much younger girl.

I have had anal sex with a few other women, including one first-timer, but it was never like this. She wasn't just tight at the entrance, she was tight all the way in. I decided that enough was enough, and just started to fuck her with half of my cock.

I slowly and steadily slid in and out of her, just an inch or so. She was completely submissive, and accepted it. It wasn't long before I felt myself starting to cum. I whispered in her ear, "I am going to cum like I did in your mouth." I think that aroused her even more, and she looked back at me with misty, dreamy eyes.

I pushed in just a little deeper, and shot a huge load into her. She made murmuring sounds and closed her eyes. I huffed and puffed for a minute, and slowly pulled it out. Because it was only half-way in, some of my cum oozed out of her asshole and trickled over her pussy lips. It dribbled onto the bed into a puddle.

Sally said "I'm sorry. We wasted that, and I know you don't like to have that happen." "Don't worry," I answered "there will always be more later."

We laid side-by-side for a few minutes, and then she went to the bathroom, and came back with a warm, wet washcloth. She wiped and cleaned my cock with it, although there really wasn't anything to clean off.

We talked for a while, and she told me that she was surprised by how far I went into her. I told her "That was only about half-way." I could see the wheels of thought turning in her head, as she imagined receiving the rest of it.

We slept together in a spoon position all night. When I woke up, she had my cock in her hand again. She obviously likes it. We got up and had some breakfast together, and I got ready to leave for work. She said "I have some appointments to look at apartments, and interview potential roommates. I should be back early." She was not enthused.

When I returned home, she was not in the kitchen or living room. I went into my bedroom, and there she was, naked and on all fours at the edge of the bed. Neither of us said a word, I just stripped down and got into position right behind her. I could see that she had applied some lube to her anus.

I asked her "Did you get the lube way up inside you?" She said "No, I guess not." I found the tube of lubricant, and said "Reach back behind you." I put a gob of lube on her middle finger, and said "Put that all the way up your ass."