Chapter 179 Chapter One Hundred and Seventy-Nine

Chapter 179 Chapter One Hundred and Seventy-Nine
Evan nods his head, taking another bite of food. "What is it?" He asks, his mouth full.

Erin looks up at me and then back to Evan. "Well, I wasn't driving around last night. I was in Erin's room. We are dating." I say.

Evan looks at me with an expressionless face. "Well, nah fucking shit Sherlock. How fucking stupid did you think I was? Even Levi knew you were full of fucking shit and he didn't even look at your phone."

My eyes go wide. "You looked at my fucking phone?"

Evan laughs, looking very amused. "Yes. I did. You know what the first thing I saw was? My sister's name. Right there, hundreds of texts going back who knows how long."

"Why would you look at my damn phone? Have you not ever heard of privacy?" I snap.

Evan scoffs, shaking his head. "Privacy? Are you fucking serious with me? How about trust? Have you not ever heard of trust?"

"We didn't mean to break your trust Evan." Erin says.

"Well you did. I knew way deep down that there was something going on between the two of you, but I kept telling myself no. No, my best friend and sister wouldn't do that to me. They are the two people I can trust the most. I gave you both hundreds of chances to tell me what was going on. I asked you specifically if you guys were into each other, and you lied to me over and over. You could have just told me. Would I have been pissed off? Yes, I would have. Would I have hit you? Probably. Would I have gotten over it? Yes, eventually. I thought you guys would never lie to me. I was very wrong about that, wasn't I?" Evan asks, looking between the two of us.

"We didn't want to keep it from you. We were just worried about how you would react." Erin says, sounding like she is on the verge of crying.

"Worried about how I would react? How I would react?" Evan snaps, standing up and walking over to the two of us. "What did you expect? I have the right to be pissed off. You two have been fucking around behind my back for I don't even want to know how long, and what you were just going to keep it a secret? Let me keep thinking you were a great sister and that I had the best friend in the whole fucking world. Someone I could trust with my life. I can't even trust you with my fucking sister." Evan snaps.

"I didn't want to ruin our friendship." I say.

"Well, it's to fucking late for that. You are backstabbing bastard. I will never trust you again. You took our friendship and threw it out the fucking window for my fucking sister. So, I hope fucking her for a few months is worth losing a lifelong friendship. She will get tired of you and move on to someone else. That's what she did with Christian, right? She cheated on him with you. Once a cheater, always a cheater." Evan says.

"I am not a cheater." Erin snaps.

"Well then what are you Erin?" Evan asks. "You know, I was going to apologize to you for how I treated Christian. Turns out I should be apologizing to Christian, not you. I should say I'm sorry I punched you Christian, I didn't realize my sister was a cheating whore."

Erin slaps him hard. Hard enough to make his head turn to the side. "I am not a fucking whore. Do not call me that." She snaps, pointing at him, her eyes filled with tears.

Evan rubs his face, looking over at her. "We will see about that. You have already fucked Keaton and probably Christian. Did you fuck Cory and Levi too? Did Levi get his wish for a threesome? Are you going to fuck the rest of the football team too? All the guys are dying to get inside your pants. Maybe they can line up and you can do them one right after the other."

"That's enough Evan." I snap.

Evan laughs, walking forward until his face is only inches from mine. "Or what, Keaton? Are you going to hit me?" He laughs again. "I fucking dare you to hit me. Give me a fucking reason to beat the fucking shit out of you."

When I don't say anything, Evan looks between the two of us and says. "I want both of you to stay the fuck away from me. Don't ever fucking talk to me again." Evan turns to walk out of the kitchen, stopping and turning back around. "Oh yeah. One more thing." Before I can ask what he is talking about, he punches me directly in the mouth. "FUCK YOU!" Evan says.

Erin gasps and Evan turns, walking out of the kitchen. Erin cups my face. "Oh my God! Are you okay?"

I rub my face and nod my head. "Yeah. I'm okay." Honestly, I deserved that and more. I'm actually surprised it took him that long to hit me.

A single stream of tears rolls down Erin's cheek and I reach out wiping it away. "Don't cry baby."

"I'm sorry." She whispers. "This is my fault."

I shake my head. "This is not your fault, Erin. Nothing that has happened is your fault." I say, as I pull her into my chest, wrapping my arms tight around her.

Her mom comes into the kitchen looking at the two of us with a very concerned expression. "Is everything alright?"

Erin sniffles, shaking her head. "We told Evan about us." I say, rubbing Erin's back.

Her mom nods her head. "Oh, I see."

Erin turns around to face her mom. "Mom, Evan thinks I am a whore."

"Sweetheart, he doesn't think you are a whore. He is just mad. He needs time to cool off. You already knew he wasn't going to take it well." Her mom says.

"H-he hates me now." Erin says, as the tears flow faster.

"No, he doesn't hate you. Listen sweetie. Evan is upset, you broke his trust. It's going to take time for him to process everything." Her mom says, giving her a reasuring smile. Erin sniffles, wiping at her tears.

"What if he never forgives me?" Erin asks.

"I'm sure he will. Maybe not any time soon, but eventually." Her mom says.

Erin nods her head. "I hope so."

Her mom walks over and kisses her on her forehead. "I love you, Erin. Take a minute, wash your face and take some deep breaths, but then you have to go to school, okay?"

Erin nods her head. "I love you too, Mom." She says, as she turns and walks out of the kitchen.

Her mom turns her attention to me and for a second, I'm not sure what to expect. Is she mad at me? Will she kick me out? Is she going to tell me I can't date Erin anymore? I don't like the thought of any of those options.