Chapter 24: Prove Me Wrong, Milano
I stepped out of the walk-in closet with my hair half-dry and a pale gray satin pajama set. Comfortable, but unfortunately way too thin for the kind of emotional armor I needed tonight.
At least the color was neutral. Not exactly “let’s get in bed,” but not “don’t touch me” either.
I figured I’d find the bedroom empty, or at the very least, Reagan sprawled on the couch. But of course not.
Because Reagan Milano has no concept of personal boundaries.
He was lounging on the side of the bed, shirtless, wearing nothing but black boxer briefs that blended far too perfectly with his sun-kissed skin. Reading glasses perched low on his nose, an iPad in his hands, and an expression so focused it looked like he was deciding the fate of the world.
I froze in the doorway, my back against the wooden frame, my whole body going still. Because that sight… wasn’t just sensual. It was dangerous nostalgia that slapped me with the weight of the past.
I looked at him. His messy black hair, the dip of his head, that sharp jaw set tight, the slow rise and fall of his chest with every breath, and the memories rushed back.
Ten years ago. The moment he slid a thin band onto my finger under the afternoon sun on campus. Reagan Milano, the sexy bad-boy nerd with an athlete’s body, a cunning mind, and a smile that felt like a sin.
And the worst part? He was still the most gorgeous man I’d ever met, even with those nerdy glasses and that distracted frown. Or maybe… because of them.
Straightening my spine, I lifted my chin and crossed to the bed with every ounce of dignity I had left. The satin might as well combust from his body heat, but I refused to let him have that power.
“Wow,” I said flatly, setting my phone on the nightstand. “Going for the college look again?”
Reagan turned his head slowly, raising one brow over the rim of his glasses, those storm-gray eyes locking on me with equal parts mischief and… triumph.
“Investment reports,” he said casually. “You know I’ve always been a nerd when it comes to numbers.”
I scrunched my nose. “And you’ve always been shirtless when handling numbers?”
His mouth curved. He swiped at the screen, then looked at me with pure sin. “Are you complaining?”
I ignored him, sitting on the far side of the bed and tugging the blanket over my legs. My phone lit up. Group chat.
Naomi: GIRL. ARE YOU ALIVE? Blink twice. I’ll send SWAT if he tries— (Cut off by another ping.)
Joy: you’re still at his place? Send your location. I’m not kidding. That smile is a kidnapping tool.
I typed quickly.
Gretta: Alive. Mostly sane. Sort of.
I backed out of the chat, only for another notification to pop up. Mom. One photo. Caption: “Your Abuela says she can smell sin from twelve kilometers away. She’s praying for you.”
I opened the picture. Abuela, rosary in hand, with a look that could melt church candles out of sheer disapproval.
I closed my eyes and groaned. God. My family.
A sound beside me made me turn. Reagan was setting his iPad on the table, sliding his glasses off… slowly.
“Who was that?” he asked, leaning back against the headboard, abs shifting as he moved.
“The anti-sin task force,” I said dryly. “They just want to make sure I’m still breathing.”
His low laugh rolled over me. “Tell them… I’ll be keeping you breathing tonight.”
The room dimmed as I flicked off the light, and just like that, the air shifted. Warm shadows wrapped around us, pierced only by the faint glow from the half-open window. Moonlight slipped inside, touching the edge of the bed like a quiet invitation.
He moved closer, his body radiating heat, drawn to me like gravity. We lay on our sides, facing each other, though I did my best to keep my eyes on the ceiling, the wall, anywhere but him.
Reagan shifted, resting his left arm on the pillow while his right hand slipped under my chin, gently turning my face toward his.
“Look at me,” he whispered, like it was a request.
But I wasn’t stupid. Anything out of his mouth eventually became an order I’d have trouble refusing.
“I’m tired,” I murmured, pushing at his chest, which, obviously, was hard and too warm for someone I was trying to keep at a distance.
He laughed low, his breath ghosting over my skin. “You’re always tired when I want to talk.”
“And you always want to talk when I want to sleep.”
His grin widened, and in one sudden move, he pressed his face into my neck. Not a kiss. Not even a tease. Something else, something that made me both squirm and want to laugh.
His nose skimmed along my throat, up to my jaw, then back down to my shoulder. I laughed part ticklish, part exasperated.
“Rey!!” I shoved at him, still laughing, tempted to throw a pillow in his face.
He only inhaled deeply, still pressed close, before murmuring, “I missed this. The sound of your laugh. The way you shove me like I’m some oversized puppy.”
“An oversized puppy with way too many issues.”
He chuckled again, then went quiet. Silence stretched.
I met his eyes, exhaling slowly, and asked softly, “When did you build this place?”
I blinked, then rested my head in my hand, studying him like I was trying to figure out a game.
“Why ask now?”
I narrowed my eyes. “Because of this house. The giant glass windows. The fireplace. The pine forest. You can’t tell me this is just a coincidence, Reagan. This is… Twilight.”
He chuckled, turning fully toward me, one leg draped over mine. “Oh no. Don’t start with your vampire fixation again.”
I pinched his chest, hard. “Don’t change the subject.”
“Gretta, sweetheart… do you really think I built this house just to revive your obsession with a teenage vampire movie from 2008?”
I squinted, pinching him again. “Reagan Milano, you once laughed at me for keeping a picture of the Cullen house on my Pinterest. But now… you’ve built a replica.”
He raised an eyebrow, his innocent look far too fake. “I’m just saying my architect has good taste. Big windows are great for natural light.”
“And the stone fireplace? And the sleek black staircase railing? And… the lake?”
He deflected, of course. “The lake is for peace and quiet,” he said, his hand slipping under the pillow. “It has nothing to do with some low-budget teen vampire movie you somehow consider cinematic art.”
I snorted, then pinched his straight nose without mercy. “Bull shit. You built this house for me. For my Twilight. Admit it, or I’ll tell your entire board of directors that you’re secretly Team Edward.”
Reagan laughed. A low, satisfied laugh. Then he pulled me against his chest, quick and possessive. “You’re too stubborn to sleep next to me without turning everything into an interrogation, Gretta.”
I curled up against him, half-reluctant, but my body was too tired to fight. His chest was warm, solid, and his breath tickled my hair. And maybe, just maybe, I gave in tonight, at least physically.
“Did you ever do this with Caleb?” In the quiet, his voice came, soft as poison.
I blinked, my brain stalling. “What?”
“Sleep like this. In the same bed. Touching, but not talking.” His tone was neutral, but underneath it… something almost possessive.
I sighed. “Caleb’s not the type who likes to sleep glued to someone.”
“No,” Reagan murmured. “Because he doesn’t know how to make you feel comfortable. Doesn’t know how to wrap you up in his arms and make you feel safe.”
I opened my mouth to argue, but he wasn’t done.
“How is he in bed?”
“Oh my God, Reagan—”
“Can he make you lose track of time? Can he make you shake with just a kiss?” His breath brushed my neck. “Or does he need a manual first?”
I hissed, partly from irritation, partly because… my heart was pounding like crazy.
He laughed, dismissive and sure of himself. “You’re not answering. Which means… he’s terrible. Or you two haven’t done it.”
I turned to face him, my eyes sharp. “We haven’t.”
He went still for a beat, then smiled wide. “Well, he knows he can’t compete.”
I wanted to argue. I really did. But my brain was on fire.
“I can make you choose me again,” he said quietly. “Soon. Because you know, Gee… there’s no one like me. No one knows your body like I do. No one knows your soul like I do.”
I scoffed. “Don’t be so sure of yourself.”
He leaned in, our faces almost touching. “I’m not sure of myself, baby. I just know you. I know how you work. I know your limits. And I know… you can’t stay away from me for long.”
I held his gaze. My breathing was heavy. “Prove it.”
He smiled like the devil who’d just won. “You’re going to regret saying that.”
I blinked slowly. “Make me regret it.”
His whisper was pure promise. “With pleasure.”