Chapter 39: 37, I love you
Sean’s POV
Sean stood up and cursed himself for letting the words slip out. Now there was nothing he could do to take it back. He had just ruined his chance to stay by Adina’s side. He waited for Adina to yell at him, but there was dead silence.
Sean turned around and saw Adina looking like her heart had shattered into a million pieces. He stopped breathing. What had he said that would cause her to react like that?
“Why don’t you want to be my friend?” she asked. There was a slight tremor in her voice. It felt like physical pain to Sean.
“Nothing, I shouldn’t have said it. Forget it,” he mumbled.
“No, Sean. If you feel like we can’t be friends, I need to know why. I won’t force you to be my friend. But I need to know what I did to make you feel like that,” she said and walked over to him.
That’s when Sean understood that Adina had interpreted his word to mean that he didn’t want to be a part of her life.
“Adina, I didn’t mean it like that. You have done nothing wrong,” he said, taking a step forward and raising his hand towards her. He caught himself before he could reach out for her and let his arm fall to his side.
“There is not much room for interpretation when you tell me you don’t want to be my friend,” she told him.
“Can we forget it? I promise I don’t want to be apart from you,” he insisted.
“No, Sean. Whatever this is, we need to deal with it. You have something you need to say,” Adina sighed. She walked up to him and placed her hand on his shoulder.
Sean couldn’t stand the intimacy of the gesture. He had been too close to let his feelings show, and it was hard for him to rein them back in when she was this close.
“Explain to me what you meant,” Adina said in a softer voice.
“Adina, I don’t want to be your friend. I want something more. I have for a long time,” he confessed.
To say the words out loud felt unreal to Sean. He had carried them around for so long that he hadn’t realised what a burden they had become.
“Something more, like….” Adina asked. Sean looked her in the eyes, and, for once, he didn’t hold back what he felt for her.
“Oh,” she said.
“Yeah. Look, Adina. I know you have Colin. He is your mate. I’m fine with it. I have always known my feelings weren’t reciprocated, and there was no hope. I haven’t told you because I didn’t want you to feel uncomfortable around me. It’s okay. I need some time to get used to you and Colin,” he told her.
He couldn’t look at her, so he looked down. He didn’t want to see the disappointment and resentment on her face.
“Sean,” Adina said softly, making it impossible for Sean to not look at her.
He didn’t see what he thought he would see. Instead, he saw her compassion and, to his surprise, a conflict.
“Please don’t send me away,” he said, without thinking about it.
“Sean, I would never send you away. There is nothing you can do to make me do that,” she said.
They both stood silent for a while, looking at each other.
“Where do we go from here?” he asked.
“I don’t know, Sean. I want to say that nothing will change, but we both know that isn’t true,” Adina answered.
“I know,” he agreed.
“I can’t say that I have never thought about us. But now there is Colin, and your mate is out there somewhere. I don’t know,” she said.
“No mate is waiting for me,” Sean told her after getting over the shock of hearing her telling him she had felt the same as him once. At least something similar. Adina smiled.
“We have had this conversation so many times. I don’t know why you insist on saying that you don’t have a mate,” she said.
Sean looked at her. His final secret. How would she look at him if he told her? Was it too much to share? But he didn’t want to keep secrets. He wanted her to know. For once, he wanted to be selfish and have her look at him and see all of him.
“I had a mate. I rejected her,” he said. He watched Adina’s eyes grow bigger, and she let out a surprised sound.
“You met your mate?” she said.
“Yes, a couple of months after you turned eighteen, we went to that pack in Italy,” he told her.
“I remember. Why didn’t you tell me?” she asked.
“There was no meaning in telling you. You would have felt bad about it and tortured yourself. It was better that you didn’t know,” he shrugged.
“You rejected your mate because of me?” she asked. Sean thought she looked terrified.
“It’s not that simple, Adina. It wasn’t like when you met Colin. I didn’t take one look at her and think that I couldn’t live without her. We saw each other, and neither of us was what the other wanted. It was mutual, and I think we were both relieved when it was over,” he explained.
“But she was your mate. You are supposed to love them above all else,” she said.
“What can I say? Even the gods make mistakes. She couldn’t be the one I loved above all else; someone else already occupied that spot in my heart,” he said and looked at Adina. There was no reason to hold back now. He was going to lay it all on the table, and then they had to figure out what to do with it.
“Maybe if I had remained in my old pack and my life had been different, she would have been a perfect match for me. But as I was chosen, my path changed, and the perfect match wasn’t perfect anymore.” he smiled at her.
“You have sacrificed so much, Sean; how can you even stand to be around me?” Adina asked.
“I wouldn’t change any of it. And I don’t blame you for it. I will be around you for as long as you let me because I love you, Adina. Not as a friend or as a brother, but as a man,” he told her.
Adina gasped at his confession.
“I love you too, Sean,” she said.
“But not in the same way?” he asked.
“I-I don’t know. I love Colin, but… This is so confusing,” she sighed.
“I’m sorry, I shouldn’t have told you,” he said.
He had ruined everything, he thought. Not only had he confessed his darkest secrets, but he had also made Adina feel uncomfortable because he wanted to feel better.
Adina’s POV
“I need to think, Sean. Is it okay if we continue this conversation tomorrow?” she asked.
“Take all the time you need. I know I have unloaded a lot of things on you. I should have left it be,” he sighed.
Adina saw how miserable he looked. She could feel his guilt rolling off him.
“I insisted that you would tell me and wouldn’t let it go. I still think we need to have this talk. I’m not sorry; I need a little time,” she smiled at him.
“It’s okay, Adina. Let’s skip the rest of the training for today,” he smiled back at her.
“Okay,” she nodded, and they walked back to the pack house in silence.
Adina didn’t know what to make of all of this. Sean’s confession had caught her blindsided. She was relieved that he hadn’t meant what she first had thought. But to know that he had feelings for her confused her.
Adina loved Colin. There wasn’t any doubt about it in her mind. She wanted to spend the rest of her life with him.
But would it be fair to Sean to ask him to stay if he had feelings for her? Could he stand seeing her with Colin? Was that what she wanted?
Adina didn’t want to lose Sean. She loved him. If she were honest with herself, she would admit that her love for him wasn’t entirely pure. Her wish that he would be her mate in her late teens hadn’t completely grown out of convenience.
But she tried to ignore those feelings when he hadn’t been her mate—knowing that both had other mates waiting.
Even if she loved him more than a brother and a friend, that solved nothing, it just made things more complicated.
Adina’s thoughts were all over the place as they walked home. How was she going to explain this to Colin? He had accepted Sean as part of their family. Would that change when he knew how Sean felt?
“I’m going to see if Jason needs help to set up for the BBQ,” Sean said as they reached the pack house.
“Okay, I’ll see you later,” Adina said. Things felt off between them. They shouldn’t have left things up in the air. But Adina needed time to think.
She headed upstairs to shower, hoping the warm water would help her think.
Colin’s POV
Colin had been inspecting the repairs to the school, and when he got back, he saw Sean helping Jason set up the BBQ. That in itself was odd. Sean’s and Adina’s training usually took a lot longer. But the look on Sean’s face told Graham something was off.
‘Jason, what’s up with Sean?’ Colin’s mind linked his gamma.
‘Haven’t got a clue. He came by about thirty minutes ago and offered to help. He has been antsy and restless and even more quiet than usual,’ Jason responded.
Colin wondered if he should talk to Sean, but then he felt that Adina would know what the issue was. If she wasn’t here, trying to fix it, something had to have happened. Colin decided to talk to her.
As he walked into their apartment, Adina stepped out of the bathroom. Her hair was still wet; she wore a pair of jeans and a t-shirt. She hadn’t noticed him, which was odd. She seemed deep in thought as she looked up, saw him, and tried to smile, but she never reached her eyes. That made Colin worried.
“Hey, little dove, what’s up?” he asked and hugged her.
“I don’t know,” she said.
“Did the talk with Sean go badly?” he asked.
“No, yes, well no, to be honest, I don’t know,” she sighed.
“That was a lot of options all in one go. Want to talk about it?”
“Yes, I think I need to tell you,” she nodded.
Colin took her and sat her down on the couch. He sat down on the coffee table so he could face her. His instincts told him that his suspicions had been correct. The big question was what they were going to do about it.
“So, Sean and I talked. Well, as I forced him to talk, he didn’t want to at first. But then…” Adina seemed to search for the words.
“He told you he had feelings for you that go beyond a brother or a friend,” Colin helped her out. Adina’s eyes shot up, and she looked at him with surprise.
“Yes, he said he loves me. How did you know?” she asked. Colin smiled at her and reached his hand out to put one of her wet locks behind her ear.
“How he looks at you when he thinks no one is watching. I know the looks because that is how I look at you all the time,” he said.
“And the little things he does. No bodyguard or friend acts like that,” he smiled at her. He wanted her to know that he wasn’t upset.
“Oh. So, I should have known,” Adina said.
“No, baby. It’s easier to see things from the outside,” he told her, and she nodded.
“He loves you. Do you love him in the same way?” Colin asked, even though he was afraid of the answer.