Chapter 46: Quinn pretends
Nathan returned just as the sun crept above the horizon, the snow outside melting slightly in the soft orange light. The door to the annex clicked shut behind him. Erika, still in her robe, stood by the kettle, pouring hot water into two mugs. Her expression was distant, drawn.
“She’s not well,” Erika said without turning. “A doctor came. Something happened to Molly maybe the baby.”
Nathan froze halfway out of his jacket. “What? No, that’s not possible. I saw her yesterday.” He stepped closer, lowering his voice. “She was fine. And she’s changed her hair.”
Erika turned now, facing him. “What?”
“Yeah. Brunette. I thought it was odd, but maybe it was just hormones, I don’t know. She didn’t talk much.”
But Erika’s eyes narrowed. Something clicked, briefly a sliver of clarity that felt like ice in her lungs. Molly had always been sensitive about her look, especially her hair. And she never jogged. Ever.
Nathan caught the tension in her silence and quickly changed the subject. “Listen, we’ve been in here too long. What if we just… left for a few hours? Said we were going to buy groceries or something? We could go to town, clear our heads.”
“You know we can’t,” Erika replied flatly. “We have to order. It’s part of the damn contract deliveries only. We’re not supposed to be seen outside the property.”
Nathan exhaled. “It’s driving me insane. These long days. The silence. The surveillance.”
He reached for her waist. “Then fuck them. Let’s forget about it.”
Erika hesitated only a second before letting him pull her toward the bed.
Outside, Quinn had wandered too close to the annex while circling the grounds, her nerves frayed. She stopped by the window when she saw them, Erika, tangled in Nathan’s arms.
She didn’t mean to stare. But she did.
For a heartbeat, Nathan’s eyes locked on hers through the frosted glass.
Then she ducked and disappeared.
Her heart thundered as she returned to the mansion, slipping into her room without a word. She crawled under the covers and stared at the ceiling, forcing her breath to slow.
This was a mistake.
Jesse, meanwhile, sat by Molly’s bedside, his voice slow, careful.
“What did you tell Erika?”
Molly blinked at him, expression unreadable.
“And the doctor… what did he find out?”
Still no answer.
Jesse’s fingers tightened around the edge of the sheet. “You think your sister is a saint, don’t you?”
Molly finally turned her head, her voice hoarse. “She’s worse than you.”
He flinched. “What?”
“She’ll never forgive me. You think you’ve broken me, Jesse. But Quinn? You can’t break her. That’s why I stopped talking to her. She’s not normal. She’s a psycho.”
He didn’t answer. Instead, he opened the drawer, pulled out a fresh vial, and injected her once again.
Morning.
The snow had turned to powder underfoot. Erika tightened her scarf, opened the annex door, and stepped outside for her routine footing. It had become a ritual ten minutes of silence, breath, movement. Sanity.
But as she turned onto the path by the woods, she stopped.
Molly no, the woman pretending to be her stood by the porch steps, stretching. Dressed in athletic gear. Looking alert. Too alert.
“Mind if I join?” she asked casually.
Erika blinked. “You never wanted to jog with me before. You said you were tired. That first day—”
“I feel better now.” She smiled. “The fresh air will help.”
They started slowly. But Erika’s eyes never left her. The gait was off. The rhythm too practiced. And then came the questions.
“How long have you and Nathan been… together?” Quinn asked, her breath steady as they jogged side by side.
Erika didn’t answer.
“Do you trust Jesse?” she added.
Still no answer.
“Do you think the money’s real? The inheritance?”
Erika slowed slightly. Her heart wasn’t in the jog anymore. Her mind reeled back to that image—the photo from Molly. We are two.
She stopped running.
“You look tired,” Erika said coolly.
Quinn stopped too. “Just hungry.”
They stood for a moment in silence. Erika stared into those eyes, the ones she had grown familiar with over weeks of tension and secrets. But now… they were different.
“I’ll go make breakfast,” Quinn said, jogging back toward the house.
Erika didn’t move. Her breath came out in a puff of steam. Something was very wrong.
She’d always been the better liar.
Quinn stirred her tea gently, the spoon tapping the sides of the porcelain like a clock ticking in her chest. Jesse stood across from her, arms crossed, eyes low, and something unreadable simmering beneath the surface of that smug calm.
They had been circling each other for two days. Him watching. Her pretending not to notice. And now he was closer, reaching for the honey, his fingers brushing hers like it was by accident.
“You’ve adjusted well,” he said, voice smooth. “Almost too well.”
Quinn tilted her head, smiling in that disarming, feline way. “I told you. I’m used to adapting.”