Chapter 31: New Area

The tire was flat. Jesse stood over it in silence, arms crossed, eyes scanning the pavement as if it might offer an explanation.

“We can walk,” Molly said, tugging at the sleeve of her cardigan. “It’s not that far.”

Jesse gave the tire one last glance, then nodded. “She’s always late anyway.”

Molly didn’t ask who he meant. She already knew, Erika. Always unpredictable, always orbiting just outside whatever plan Jesse tried to structure.

As they walked through the gravel-paved lanes of the private neighborhood, the mansion behind them loomed silent. Craig’s glowing lens watched from the window like a sleeping eye pretending not to see.

When they reached Maya and Calvin’s front steps, the lights were already on. Warm, almost welcoming. But Jesse knew better. So did Molly.

The door opened before they could knock. Calvin stood there in a button-down shirt and slacks, smiling with the cool hospitality of someone who had memorized every social rule just to break them strategically.

“Look who made it,” he said, voice warm. “You’re right on time.”

Molly returned the smile. Jesse didn’t.

“Come in. Maya’s got something sweet lined up.”

As soon as they stepped inside, Calvin gestured to Jesse. “Walk with me, yeah? Got something by the lake.”

Jesse threw a glance back at Molly. She gave him a small, uncertain nod.

Maya stood in the kitchen with a tray of drinks and her signature soft laugh, already pouring juice into thin-stemmed glasses. Her eyes sparkled with something more than friendliness when she looked at Molly.

“So,” Maya said, extending a glass, “when did you two meet?”

“University,” Molly answered, taking the drink. “We were—uh—"

“And the baby?” Maya interrupted softly. “It’s his?”

Molly hesitated. “Yes. Of course.”

Maya smiled, but it didn’t reach her eyes.

Outside, Jesse followed Calvin past the trimmed hedges toward the back patio. The lake shimmered under a darkening sky, still and unnatural.

“I see a lot of Gary in you,” Calvin said, lighting a cigar.

“I don’t.”

“He was a man who thought in blueprints. Quiet, observant. Not always good at love, but good at war.”

Jesse looked away, jaw set. “You didn’t like my mother.”

Calvin exhaled smoke through his nose. “Linda was… loud.”

“She was honest,” Jesse said, voice low. “You don’t like honest women.”

Calvin said nothing.

A knock echoed from the front door.

They both turned toward the sound.

Molly peeked out from the patio curtain as Erika stepped inside, windblown and flushed. Nathan followed close behind, shirt clinging to his torso, hair wet from a quick wash.

Molly, already holding her untouched glass, leaned toward a large potted plant and dumped the juice into the soil.

“I didn’t like the smell,” she muttered.

Erika raised an eyebrow but said nothing.

Maya’s expression sharpened when she saw Erika.

“So,” she said, not missing a beat. “Peter told you something before he disappeared, didn’t he?”

Erika nodded. “He said there was another. A brother.”

Maya’s smile curved tighter. “There was. Or might’ve been. Gary never believed he was his. Quiet type. But you know the dangerous ones don’t scream.”

Erika’s gaze didn’t waver.

Back outside, Calvin led Jesse and Nathan down the dock to a fishing boat, the small motor already prepped.

Jesse hesitated, watching Molly still standing on the patio, her face unreadable.

“Come on,” Calvin said.

They boarded.

Halfway across the lake, Calvin cut the engine. The silence was thick as oil.

“I know what you did,” Calvin said to Jesse. “You watched Veronika. You hated her. Because of what your mother went through.”

Jesse turned slowly. “What are you talking about?”

Nathan leaned forward. “What’s he talking about?”

Calvin smiled. “You wanted her to suffer. And she did.”

Jesse’s voice turned ice. “What did you see the night my father disappeared?”

Calvin’s grin grew thin. “Nothing. But I saw you… the night Veronika was taken.”

Then it exploded.

Calvin slammed the oar across Nathan’s chest, sending him crashing into the edge of the boat. Jesse lunged, grabbing Calvin’s arm, they struggled, tipped sideways and both tumbled into the lake.

In the annex, Erika ducked as Maya suddenly lunged, grabbing her throat.

“You think you know this place?” Maya hissed, shoving her against the glass table. “This house, this whole neighborhood? It doesn’t belong to Gary. It belongs to us.”

Erika gasped, reaching for a fork, slashing across Maya’s shoulder.

Outside, under the water, Calvin unsheathed a knife.

Jesse gasped, eyes wide, blood pouring from his side as the blade slid into his stomach.

Nathan surfaced, sputtering and saw Calvin rise with a revolver in one hand.

“Drop it!” Molly screamed from the balcony.

“Back up!” Calvin shouted.

Nathan charged him just as Calvin raised the gun. They collided.

The first shot fired wide.

The second never came.

BOOM.

Calvin’s head jerked back and exploded.

Blood misted the lake as Jesse rose behind him, holding a small black pistol, arm shaking from the wound.

Inside, Maya reached above the fireplace and yanked down a hunting rifle. Erika ducked behind the overturned table, cut and bruised but breathing.

Molly screamed as the shot from the lake echoed across the water.

Then silence.

The kind that follows a storm.

The kind that warns it’s not over yet.

Molly’s scream tore through the night.

Calvin's body collapsed backward into the dark water, blood unfurling like ink beneath the moonlight. Jesse stood over him, gun still raised, chest heaving. Nathan, panting, lowered himself onto the deck, one hand pressed against his bruised ribs, the other on the dock’s splintered edge. The silence was sharp, a blade dragged across the nerves of everyone still standing.

Then another shot.

From inside.

Maya.

The scream of the rifle echoed through the trees, rattling the windows of the mansion and bouncing across the water. Jesse jerked his head toward the house. Erika and Molly were already sprinting.

Inside, smoke curled upward from the muzzle of the hunting rifle. Maya stood wild-eyed in the shattered dining room, her mouth twisted into a snarl.

“You bastards,” she hissed. “Someone’s going to show up! I called the police on your ass already.”

“Maya, stop!” Nathan rushed in behind the girls, raising his hands.

“You don’t get it,” she barked. “Linda, Linda was going to ruin everything. I didn’t kill her, but I—I helped. I was the reason.”

Jesse stepped forward, his arm slowly extending, pistol aimed squarely at her chest.

“What did you do?” he asked, voice flat.

She turned toward him, rifle lifted. “We faked her death, Jesse. She was about to expose Gary and Calvin. About the stolen money. The counterfeiting. Everything. Linda was too emotional, she didn’t understand the scale. So we made her disappear.”

Erika’s voice rang out, sharp and furious. “You’re lying.”

“I’m not,” Maya said. Her eyes glistened with something, pride or madness, it was hard to tell. “She got sloppy. She was going to go to the press.”

Maya began backing toward the door, dragging the rifle’s barrel across the floor like a warning.

“She never made it because Calvin and I staged it. She didn’t die… until we made her die.”

Suddenly, Erika lunged and knocked the rifle upward just as Maya pulled the trigger.