Chapter 25: What Silas Left Behind

Eveline Shore — First-Person POV

The rain had been relentless since dawn.

Not dramatic rain. Not the kind that slammed itself against the lighthouse in violent sheets. No—this was steadier, colder, almost methodical. A thin, cold tapping that felt like it was counting down to something. The sky outside the lantern room looked bruised, swollen with storm, the glass fogged at the edges where the cold pressed inward.

Jonas and I stood side by side at Silas’s journal, the small metal desk between us. The pages were already damp at the corners from the humidity creeping in through the old stone walls. The ink on some entries had bled into soft gray shadows—but the sketches were sharp.

Sharper than I remembered.

I traced a fingertip down one of the jagged lines.

“What if these aren’t drawings?” I murmured, voice barely above a whisper. “What if they’re maps?”

Jonas leaned in, bracing one hand on the desk. His shoulders were tense—coiled. He’d barely slept last night. Neither had I. Every time I closed my eyes I saw the door splintering, the darkness spilling in, the voice that wasn’t Silas whispering my name like it owned it.

Jonas swallowed. “They’re pieces of something,” he said quietly. “But definitely not a map of the island’s surface.”

I pushed another page aside, revealing smaller diagrams underneath—circles within circles, arrows that descended. Not north-south lines. Downward.

“No,” I breathed. “Not this island. Something under it.”

A heavy silence filled the room.

Jonas finally said it. The word both of us had been avoiding.

“The catacombs.”

The air felt colder instantly.

Everyone in Marrowick Island knew the legends—the tunnels carved by prisoners during the earliest lighthouse construction; the underground chambers older than the first settlers; the children who vanished during storms and were found days later with no memory of how they’d gotten belowground.

But Silas… Silas had never believed they were legends.

My throat tightened. “I think he found something down there.”

Jonas nodded, jaw ticking. “It looks that way.”

I forced myself to look at the scrawled lines of handwriting wrapping around the margins. Silas’s writing had always been messy but controlled. Here… it was frantic. Uneven. As if his hand couldn’t keep up with what he was trying to say.

If they find this, they find her.

Jonas doesn’t know.

Time is running out.

My pulse stuttered.

Why hadn’t Silas told me?

I reached the last line on another page. The ink had smudged but was still legible:

Eveline must not see the door—

The sentence cut off. Ripped mid-word.

A tremor rippled through me. “He was scared.”

“Yeah.” Jonas’s voice was low, thick. “He was.”

I looked up. Jonas had his arms folded, his weight braced against the desk like he needed something solid to anchor himself. His eyes were trained on the page but unfocused, as if he was seeing something else—something from that night.

The night Silas vanished.

A memory tried to rise—half-formed, jagged at the edges. I pushed it back down.

“Why didn’t he tell me?” I whispered. “He wrote all of this, but he didn’t say anything.”

Jonas hesitated.

Then, with a quiet exhale, he admitted something I wasn’t prepared for.

“Because you’re the only thing Silas ever tried to protect without asking for anything in return.”

I blinked—too quickly.

Jonas didn’t usually talk like that. Not about Silas. Not about me.

He looked like he regretted saying it the moment the words left his mouth. His gaze flicked away, jaw flexing once, twice, like he was wishing he could pull the confession right out of the air and shove it back into his chest.

I swallowed. “And what about you?”

He stiffened. “What about me?”

“You protect me too,” I said softly. “Constantly.”

A muscle jumped in his jaw—guilt, frustration, something he didn’t want me to see. He turned away and closed the journal, shutting it sharply.

“This isn’t about me,” he muttered. “Right now it’s about whoever broke into the lighthouse yesterday trying to take you.”

My skin prickled. I wrapped my arms around myself. The memory of that cold breath at my ear sent a tremor through me.

“We need answers,” I said. “Real ones.”

“Which means,” Jonas said, sliding the journal toward him, “we need to go down there.”

My head snapped up. “Into the catacombs?”

He didn’t blink. “It’s the only way we figure out what Silas was trying to tell you. Or what he was hiding from you.”

I looked back at the pages—at the downward arrows, the twisting tunnels, the jagged symbols inked with frantic strokes. My stomach knotted. Every instinct screamed that nothing good waited below this island.

But Silas had left these pages behind.

And he’d written them for me.

“We follow the map,” I said. “We find out what he didn’t want me to see.”

Jonas nodded once. No hesitation. “Then we go now. Before whoever—or whatever—is after you figures out we know more than they do.”

He took the journal and zipped it into his jacket pocket with slow, deliberate care, as if he was locking away something dangerous.

I stepped back from the desk, the floor creaking softly under my weight. Jonas reached out, his fingers circling my wrist with a gentle firmness that stopped me mid-step.

“Eveline.”

I met his eyes.

“If anything goes wrong,” he said quietly, “you stay behind me. Promise me that.”

I lifted my chin. “No.”

His brows drew together. “Eve—”

“We go in together.”

The storm cracked overhead, thunder shaking the lantern room glass. Jonas’s expression twisted—exasperation fighting with something softer.

“Fine,” he muttered. “Together.”

We descended the spiraling staircase, the air growing colder with each step. The deeper we went, the more the shadows thickened, clinging to the corners like living things. The lower level of the lighthouse carried a chill that hadn’t been there days ago—one that seemed to seep from the floor itself.

The trapdoor lay flush against the tiles, its iron latch rusted but intact.

Jonas knelt and pried it open.

The hinges groaned.

A rush of cold, stale air swept up the moment the opening widened. It smelled of earth, of stone, of something old and untouched.

“Ready?” Jonas asked.

No.

Not even remotely.

But I nodded.

Because Silas had left this map behind for a reason. Because someone—or something—had tried to stop us from seeing it.

And because the last words Silas ever said to me had been:

“Don’t go below without me.”

But he wasn’t here anymore.

Jonas helped me down the first metal rung. The darkness below swallowed the lantern light above us, folding over the edges, greedy and patient.

I took a breath, tasting damp air and fear.

If Silas left a map for me…

He wanted me to follow it.

So I would.

Even if it meant walking straight into the tunnels he had died trying to escape.