Chapter 14: Darkness Has a Sound
The moment the stranger’s voice seeped through the lantern-room door, something inside me snapped taut—like a rope pulled past its limit. Eveline’s breath hitched behind me, and yet I couldn’t turn toward her. Not now. Not with him on the other side of the door.
“She deserved to know the truth long before now.”
His words were a knife—sharp, deliberate, aimed to wound.
Eveline didn’t know it, but the stranger wasn’t wrong.
I pressed a hand against the door, steadying myself, forcing my breath to slow. I needed a clear head. Panic wouldn’t protect her. Panic was what had gotten Silas into this mess to begin with.
“Jonas…” Eveline whispered. Not frightened this time—hurt.
I closed my eyes.
Not now. Please not now.
“Stay back,” I murmured. “Please.”
The handle rattled again. A soft metallic scrape followed, one I recognized instantly.
He had a lockpick.
I swore under my breath. “Damn it.”
Eveline stepped closer—I could feel her body heat, her fear vibrating off her in trembling waves. She was too close. Too vulnerable. Too trusting.
I angled myself so I blocked the door fully, bracing a shoulder against the old metal frame.
“He can’t get in,” I lied.
The truth was… the lantern room door was older than both of us combined. One good kick, and the stranger could break it clean off the hinge.
But Eveline didn’t need that truth.
Not yet.
The scraping stopped.
A pause.
Then the stranger’s voice, low and controlled:
“You don’t have the right to keep this from her.”
My stomach twisted hard.
Eveline inhaled sharply behind me.
“What truth?” she demanded.
Her voice split me open.
I swallowed hard and didn’t turn around. If I saw her face, the guilt would crush whatever resolve I had left.
The stranger continued, louder this time—directed at her:
“Silas trusted him. And he—”
“Enough!” I barked.
My fist slammed against the door so hard it vibrated. Eveline flinched behind me.
Silence. Heavy and dangerous.
Then, in a voice dripping with venom, the stranger whispered:
“You’re going to lose her too, Jonas.”
My blood went cold.
Eveline’s breath stopped entirely.
And then—quiet footsteps retreated down the metal staircase.
One step.
Two.
Three.
A slow, controlled descent.
Not fleeing.
Leaving.
Because he wanted me to feel the threat in his absence.
I stayed pressed against the door for several seconds after the footsteps faded. My pulse hammered in my throat, but I didn’t move—not until I was certain he was gone. Even then, I waited a moment longer, because facing Eveline felt harder than facing the stranger.
Finally, I forced myself to turn.
Eveline stood in the center of the lantern room, arms wrapped around herself, tears streaking silently down her cheeks—but her eyes…
Her eyes were fire.
“Jonas,” she whispered, “what aren’t you telling me?”
I swallowed. Hard. My mouth felt like it was filled with ash.
“This isn’t the time,” I managed.
“It has to be.” Her voice cracked but didn’t break. “Jonas… please. I’m not a child. You can’t shield me from this.”
I looked down.
She stepped closer, voice trembling. “If Silas is alive—”
“I don’t know that,” I said sharply.
A lie.
A coward’s lie.
Her face twisted in pain. “Then why did that man say you knew the truth?”
I dragged a hand through my hair. My heartbeat was so loud it drowned out the wind outside.
“Eveline… I made mistakes.”
Her breathing hitched.
“I didn’t tell you everything because I thought—” My voice broke. “I thought I could fix it before it broke you.”
Her chin trembled. “Fix what?”
I exhaled shakily, staring at the fog-covered glass, unable to meet her eyes.
“The night Silas disappeared…” My throat tightened. “He wasn’t supposed to be alone.”
Silence.
Eveline’s voice came out as a whisper: “What do you mean?”
I forced myself to continue, each word tasting like guilt.
“He called me that night.”
Eveline’s breath caught—a soft, wounded sound.
“He told me something was wrong. He told me not to let you near the cliffs. He said someone was watching him.” My voice wavered. “He sounded terrified.”
A tear slid down Eveline’s cheek.
“Jonas…” she whispered.
“I went looking for him,” I said quickly, needing her to understand. “I swear I did. But by the time I reached the cliffs—he was gone.”
Her hand covered her mouth.
“I didn’t tell you,” I said quietly, “because I knew you wouldn’t stop searching. You would’ve thrown yourself into the ocean after him.”
Her stare pierced straight through me.
“You didn’t get to make that choice for me.”
My chest tightened painfully. “I know. I know that now.”
She shook her head, tears falling freely.
“Jonas… if Silas called you for help, why didn’t you tell the police? Why didn’t you tell me? Why didn’t you—”
I stepped forward, unable to stop myself.
“Because I didn’t know who I could trust.”
Her eyes widened, fear flickering.
I let the truth slip—quietly, hopelessly:
“And because Silas wasn’t the only one being watched.”
The wind howled around the lighthouse, shaking the glass.
Eveline stared at me—broken, bewildered, terrified.
“Jonas…” she whispered, “what have you done?”
I wanted to answer.
I wanted to tell her everything.
But a soft sound echoed from below—another footstep on the metal staircase.
Not the stranger.
Someone heavier.
Someone slower.
Someone who had been waiting for the perfect silence to move.
Eveline’s eyes widened.
I felt my stomach drop.
“We’re not alone,” I whispered.
The lantern flickered.
And the lighthouse suddenly felt too small to hold all our secrets.