Chapter 12: The Wrong Danger
Eveline Shore
Jonas didn’t wait for my answer.
He grabbed my wrist and pulled me up from the floor, his grip firm but shaking. The lighthouse lantern flickered wildly above us, casting long trembling shadows over the walls as if the entire tower reacted to the note I held.
“Jonas—slow down,” I said, stumbling after him.
“We’re leaving,” he said, voice rough. “Right now.”
“Why? What does it mean?” I clutched the paper tighter. It felt warm from my hands, like it was pulsing with something alive. “Jonas, Silas wrote—”
“That’s exactly the problem.”
He nearly dragged me to the stairs, but I yanked my hand free.
“No.” My voice snapped sharper than I meant. “No more running me in circles. You know something. You’ve been hiding something since the moment I walked into this lighthouse.”
Jonas stared at me—really stared—and something inside him cracked. Not physically. Not visibly. But I felt it.
Like he’d been holding a door shut in his mind for too long.
“Eveline,” he whispered, “I’ve been trying to protect you.”
“From what?” I demanded.
Jonas opened his mouth.
And then—
A loud clang echoed from below.
Metal against metal.
Footsteps. Fast.
Jonas’s face blanched.
“He’s still here,” he muttered. “Damn it—he didn’t leave.”
Another set of footsteps followed—heavier, slower.
Not one person.
Two.
Jonas’s breath hitched. “Not good. Not—”
A voice boomed from the base of the stairs.
“Jonas Hale,” the rough voice called. “You should’ve opened the door.”
Jonas inhaled sharply. “We need to go.”
But the stranger wasn’t yelling anymore.
He wasn’t pounding or threatening.
He was simply climbing the stairs.
Step by step.
Deliberate.
Calm.
Like he already knew Jonas had run out of exits.
Jonas grabbed my shoulders and pushed me back into the lantern room.
“Stay behind me,” he said.
“Jonas, what is happening?”
His eyes didn’t leave the staircase.
“They weren’t supposed to find us this fast.”
“They?” I repeated, pulse spiking.
He didn’t answer.
The footsteps grew louder.
Clang.
Clang.
Clang.
The stranger’s voice carried up the spiral.
“I told you she’d read the note.”
Jonas reacted like he’d been stabbed. “Don’t talk to her!”
“Jonas,” the stranger said, “you created this mess. Not me.”
Created.
My heart dropped.
“No…” I whispered. “Jonas… what did you do?”
For a moment—just a moment—Jonas’s mask slipped.
Guilt.
Fear.
A pain he hadn’t let me see until now.
“I made a mistake,” he said, voice breaking. “I thought I was keeping Silas safe.”
My stomach twisted. “Safe from who?”
He flinched.
“From them.”
The stranger laughed from the shadows below. “Tell her, Jonas.”
“Stop,” Jonas snapped.
But the stranger kept climbing.
“Tell her what you started.”
My chest tightened painfully. “Jonas… did you know Silas was in danger?”
Jonas didn’t answer.
That silence was louder than any confession.
“Jonas,” I whispered, “did you know?”
He closed his eyes. “I didn’t know what they’d do.”
My knees weakened.
He knew something.
He knew something the night Silas vanished.
He’d been hiding it.
Protecting me?
Protecting Silas?
Protecting himself?
The stranger reached the top step.
Jonas jerked forward, blocking him from entering the lantern room. “You don’t come any closer.”
Light spilled over the man’s face at last.
He looked older than I expected.
Maybe late thirties.
Dark jacket.
Sharp eyes that missed nothing.
A scar cutting through his eyebrow.
Not a stranger.
Someone who carried familiarity like a quiet weapon.
He looked at me first—directly into my eyes—and spoke softly.
“You shouldn’t be here, Eveline.”
“Who are you?” I whispered.
He slipped his hands into his coat pockets, casual despite the tension so thick I could barely breathe.
“My name is Rowan,” he said. “And before anything else happens, you need to know something.”
Jonas bristled. “Don’t.”
But Rowan ignored him.
He pointed—not at me, not at Jonas—but at the folded note in my hand.
“At the bottom,” he said, “turn it over.”
My pulse thudded.
Slowly, I flipped the paper.
Another line—fainted, smudged, almost invisible—waited there.
Written in the same desperate handwriting.
I staggered backward.
The words were:
“Jonas wasn’t supposed to be there.”
Cold swept through me.
Jonas’s face drained of color.
I clutched the note like it might dissolve.
“Jonas…” My voice shook. “What does this mean?”
His throat worked, but no sound came out.
Rowan stepped closer.
“It means,” he said quietly, “Silas didn’t call you that night.”
Jonas stiffened—rage flaring, panic rising.
Rowan held my gaze.
“He called Jonas… because Jonas was with him at the cliffs.”
The world collapsed under my feet.
Jonas choked out, “Eveline, I can explain—”
Rowan cut him off.
“No. No more lies.”
He stepped into the lantern room, voice grave.
“There were three people at the cliffs that night.”
My heart pounded so hard it hurt.
“Silas.”
“Jonas.”
“And the one who pushed him.”
The glass windows rattled from the wind.
I couldn’t speak.
I couldn’t move.
Jonas’s voice came out broken. “Eveline, please—just listen—”
Rowan turned fully toward me.
“And now,” he said, “that same person is coming for you.”