Chapter 28: Confession No. 14 – The Birthday List

They thought I was innocent.

They saw the pink nails, the shy smile, the quiet girl with a tote bag full of poetry books.

But they didn’t know what I kept in my Notes app.

My Birthday List.

1 Suck a cock until he begs.

2 Get fucked in front of a mirror.

3 Anal slow first, then hard.

4 Try a blindfold.

5 Hear someone moan my name.

6 Cry from how good it feels.

7 Be used by more than one man.

Tonight, I was finally 19.

And I was ready.

It started at a lowkey apartment party. Just five of us. Music loud enough to shake the walls, smoke thick in the air, and the tang of tequila on everyone’s breath.

I wore the shortest pink pleated skirt I owned and a crop top I had to tape to stay on. No bra. No panties.

Every move I made felt like a dare.

And Drew took it first.

He cornered me by the fridge and ran his palm down my exposed thigh.

“You forget your panties, birthday girl?”

“No,” I whispered, my voice syrupy and loaded. “I left them off for you.”

They gathered fast after that.

Drew, Miles, Eli,  Shawn. All friends. All familiar.

And all now staring at me like prey they’d waited too long to taste.

I climbed onto the couch and parted my legs.

They stared.

Miles stepped between my knees and leaned close. "Tell us what you want."

I smiled. "To cross off my list."

I was on my knees between them in seconds.

Drew’s cock was the first in my mouth. Thick. Clean shaven. I licked him like candy, twirling my tongue around the head, then sliding him deep until he hit the back of my throat.

Miles came up behind me, dragging his fingers between my legs.

“Jesus!!!! she’s drenched.”

He slid in two fingers, curling them deep, pumping while I gagged on Drew’s cock.

Shawn pulled his out. Slapped it gently on my lips.

I opened, took him in alongside Drew.

Their groans filled the room.

Eli guided his thick cock between my ass cheeks, pressing the head against my tight hole.

I tensed. Then exhaled.

“Yes,” I whispered.

He went slow.

Pain laced with pleasure as he slid in inch by inch.

“Oh fuck,” I whimpered, tears at the corners of my eyes. “More.”

He gave it. Hard. Brutal.

Drew was fucking my mouth, Eli was fucking my ass, and Miles had three fingers in my pussy.

I was shaking.

A toy. A cumdump. A birthday girl gone feral.

“Good girl,” Drew growled, thrusting deeper.

“Fucking born for this,” Miles muttered.

They shifted me.

Bent me over the armrest of the couch.

Miles pushed inside my pussy now. Long, slow strokes. One hand on my neck. The other on my clit.

“Don’t cum yet,” he warned. “You only cum when we say.”

I moaned.

Then Shawn filled my ass. Thicker. Rougher.

The two moved together.

Each thrust rocked my entire body. My nipples grazed the cushions. My moans were incoherent.

“Please please,” I begged.

“Not yet.”

Eli stood in front of me, stroking himself.

“Open,” he commanded.

I did. He slid into my mouth and groaned.

I choked, coughed, drooled but I didn’t stop.

My orgasms were controlled.

Three times they edged me.

Held me back until I was shaking, crying, begging.

Then finally

“Now.”

And I exploded.

Screaming.

My pussy convulsed around Miles’ cock while Shawn filled my ass. Eli came in my mouth, hot and thick, and I swallowed every drop.

They made me ride them next.

Straddling Miles while Drew spanked me hard.

Then bent over the coffee table while Eli fingered me open again and spread me for more.

When I finally collapsed, dripping, messy, my hair wild and body soaked with sweat and cum, I was panting.

Drew kissed my forehead.

“You filthy little dream girl,” he whispered.

“Still got more on that list?”

I nodded.

“Then you’re not done yet.”