Chapter 21: Confession No. 8– Her Pastor’s Secret
I should’ve known the storm would come.
But even in the low rumble of thunder, as I dusted hymnals on the chapel’s altar shelves, I stayed. Alone. Or so I thought.
Outside, clouds had swallowed Mount Kilimanjaro’s snowy peak, the forest winds howling like a warning.
Still, I continued to arrange the pew Bibles, trying to keep my thoughts clean.
But nothing was clean about the way I thought about Pastor Malachi.
Tall. Stern. Godly. And far too handsome for a man who preached restraint.
He always wore his collar crisp, voice calm, posture impeccable. A man who had memorized not just the scripture but the way to hold a room. Even when he looked at me, he didn’t really look. Not directly.
Until tonight.
The moment the power went out, I turned to find him standing at the back of the chapel, soaked from rain.
His eyes met mine, and this time, there was no holy distance in them.
Only heat.
The Gathering Storm
“Everyone’s gone,” he said. “The road flooded. You’ll have to stay until morning.”
My heart pounded.
I nodded, trying not to seem too eager.
“I didn’t think you’d still be working.”
“You said the Lord values diligence.”
He smiled faintly. “I did.”
We stood in silence for a moment. The only sound was the steady beat of the rain on the stained glass windows.
He stepped closer.
I didn’t move.
“I hope you’ve been praying,” he murmured.
I swallowed. “Every night.”
“Even with what you think about?”
My breath caught. “What do you mean?”
He tilted his head. “Don’t lie to your pastor, Nia. I see the way your thighs squeeze together when I speak.”
My face flushed.
He stepped closer again.
“You think I haven’t noticed how your breaths quicken when I call you forward for communion?”
I couldn’t answer.
Because it was true.
All of it.
The Confession
“I dreamed about you,” I whispered.
He raised a brow. “What did you dream?”
I looked down. “That I was kneeling. But not for prayer.”
A sharp inhale.
He turned away from me as if to pray himself.
Instead, he walked to the altar and lit a single candle.
“Come forward,” he said.
I obeyed.
“Nia, I am not a man given to sin easily.”
I nodded.
“But you tempt the spirit in me until I question what I serve.”
He reached behind the altar and retrieved something wrapped in velvet.
A leather bound paddle.
My heart slammed.
He saw the panic or was it arousal? in my eyes.
“You want forgiveness?”
I nodded.
“Then confess everything you want me to do to you.”
My voice trembled. “I want you to bend me over the pulpit. Spank me for every wicked thought. Make me cry. Make me beg. Then I want you to make me come so hard I forget every sermon I’ve ever heard.”
He let out a growl that didn’t belong in church.
“Turn around, Nia.”
The First Punishment
I turned, hands on the wooden pulpit.
I felt him behind me. His breath was hot on my ear.
He pulled up my skirt slowly, reverently. My lace panties soaked through.
He let out a low, pained groan.
“Fifteen. For the lust in your heart.”
The first smack echoed in the empty chapel.
Then another.
And another.
By the tenth, I was whimpering, but he didn’t stop.
“Say thank you, Nia.”
“Thank you, Pastor,” I sobbed.
He rubbed the sting with his palm. Then, he slipped his hand down between my thighs.
“So wet. Your body doesn’t know shame, does it?”
“No,” I gasped.
He sank two fingers inside me and bit back a moan.
Worship Between His Thighs
He pulled me up and turned me to face him.
“You wanted to kneel for me, didn’t you?”
I dropped to my knees without a word.
He unzipped his pants slowly.
I reached for him, eyes never leaving his.
He gripped my hair.
“No hands.”
I leaned forward and worshipped him with my mouth.
He guided me with soft curses and praises.
“Good girl. Take it all. Swallow your sin.”
I moaned against him, arousal dripping down my thighs.
When he finally pulled me up, he kissed me. Hard. Desperate. Like he wanted to consume me.
Sanctified Pleasure
He bent me over the altar.
Not the pulpit.
The altar.
He lifted my leg onto the velvet cloth.
And slid inside me.
I screamed.
Lightning flashed.
Thunder crashed.
And still, he moved.
Deep, slow, punishing strokes.
“Say my name, Nia.”
“Pastor Malachi.”
“Louder.”
“Malachi!”
He pounded harder.
Until I shattered.
Once. Twice. Then again.
After the Storm
He held me after.
The candle still burned beside us.
“Forgive me,” I whispered.
His voice was soft. “There’s nothing to forgive. You were made for this.”
I looked at him. “Will you still preach tomorrow?”
He smirked. “Only if you’re in the front pew, squirming in that same dress.”
I smiled.
Maybe salvation came in different forms.
Tonight, mine came with hands that punished and healed.
And a voice that turned my prayers into gasps.