Chapter 30: The power of your love
Theosophy, as it was seen in the 19th century, aimed at a scientific synthesis of religions but ultimately turned towards occultism and spiritualism. All this demonstrates, without a doubt, that in the midst of the positivist current, a spiritualist tsunami had risen, taking on different forms and sensitivities, but ultimately resisting a society that was becoming increasingly materialistic, utilitarian, and selfish. In Carloz Schwabe's poster for the Salon of the Rosicrucians (1892, Fig.16) - an exhibition of Rosicrucian paintings by the group led by Péladan (founder of the Catholic Rosicrucians) - there seems to be an invitation to communion between body and spirit. It is almost inevitable that the artists of the time, as well as painters and writers, were influenced by this irresistible current of spirituality.
These female characters, surrounded by nature, flowers, and plants, with a mesmerized gaze and in a kind of ecstasy, also represent a reaction against industrialization and positivism. They want to show that there is a world beyond everyday experience, that there is another knowledge that differs from that derived from scientific methods. They want to emphasize that human beings, especially women, hold a strong spiritual component. Therefore, there is also a return to religious spirituality from the Middle Ages, to the knowledge of Eastern philosophies, to ancient wisdom, myths, magic, and alchemy.
But in contrast to this group of mystical and dreamy behaviors, there is the terrifying devastating woman, the man-eater, who seems to represent Erich Neumann's complex of the Great Mother (a disciple of Jung). These incarnations of fatal women, on the contrary, seem to warn against the increasing power of the feminist movement and the irresistible rise of women in society. It is true that many jokes were made against suffragettes, that feminists were ridiculed and discredited. Hermann Paul adopts this humorous tone in the illustration of the magazine L'Album. He has a mischievous smile on his face, but her expression is that of a praying mantis about to devour its victim. Laughter hides fear. And that is what, truly, was behind all those decadent (Schanackenberg), morbid (Beardsley), libertine (Camps), or sensual (Bradley) figures. Feminists, in a somewhat Lombroso-like thinking, were therefore considered dissolute, perfidious, immoral, primitive beings driven by their base instincts.
The feminist movement had been developing practically since the French Revolution, with the Declaration of the Rights of Women and the Female Citizen (1791), although in its development it had shifted towards the demand for suffrage as a precursor to the improvement of women's political and legal situation. Born within industrial society, suffragism was, as we have noted, much more developed in those advanced countries like the United States or Great Britain, where there was also a liberal consciousness. Countries where trade and mass production were simultaneously developing advertising activities through the press and posters. In Spain, feminism did not emerge until the late 19th century, thanks to some intellectuals such as Emilia Pardo Bazán and Concepción Arenal. So, by the late 19th century and early 20th century, it was in full swing. It seems that, in some way, that fear of the new female power had to emerge (Fig.18). And even more than in treatises, in art, in didactic or scientific literature, that apprehension and distrust emerged in popular literature and illustration, where the collective imagination freely and spontaneously moves. And this without necessarily proposing to alarm the male population, while innocent advertisements for liquors, fair attractions, theatrical plays, and even children's books were also displayed. In Beardsley's poster (Fig.19), children's literature is advertised, the titles on display include La historia de una muñeca, La pequeña princesa, Cascanueces y el rey de los ratones, Un jardín encantado, etc. But the opulent and sensual character portrayed by the British artist has little to do with children. Only the presence of a book in hand reminds us that it is an advertisement for a publishing company.
Conclusions
We do not want, by any means, to convey the idea that these two types exhaust the archetypal representations of women in the period. After the initial impression, which leads to the easily deducible knowledge of a massive presence of female figures in advertisements and illustrations of the time, an attempt has been made to establish a cause-effect relationship between certain living conditions accompanied by a sensitivity that reacted both against the circumstances and against dominant thought, and the use of certain commonplaces in the representation of women. However, the scenario becomes much more complex when certain elements are introduced, such as the rise of suffragism, the scientific and philosophical ideas of the time about the female condition, and the commercial interests of advertisers or propagandists of established powers. There is no doubt that the image of a woman in unconventional attitudes, such as a reader, a regular customer at a café or billiards establishment (Fig.20), which were previously considered exclusively male spaces, drinking liquors, riding a bicycle, etc., helped to modify the position of women in the social imaginary.
The movies we are going to discuss here are David Fincher's "Perdida" and Carlos Vermut's "Magical Girl," both from 2014, and in them, as we literally say, there will be deaths; in these films, allow me the irony, no one lives or, rather, in these artistic film texts, there are more possibilities of death than of life. And so it is: the character of a central woman in the development of the action of the story is the trigger of all the tragedy, in two post-classical stories of this century. Both share a structure that is more like a parody of a children's story because, for a reason, the origin of the protagonists are two girls. In the case of "Perdida," she is the living incarnation of a famous and recognized literary character written by her mother... in the case of "Magical Girl," she is a girl suffering from leukemia who wants to emulate a mysterious girl from a popular Japanese animated manga called the same as the movie's title. The girls belong to a story, but life belongs to horror. Or rather, in this case, narrative fiction is not going to help them in their lives, but unfortunately it will contribute to their downfall. Because both movies seem to be more the story of a nightmare than that of a good dream encouraged by a good story. There are other movies to observe as samples in this study of the 2014 harvest, where the central protagonist character of the movies is a woman, such as "No corras, vuela" by Peruvian Claudia Llosa; "Ida" by Polish Pavel Pavlizovski; and Woody Allen's "la divina adivina" in "A la pálida luz de la luna," to name recent examples. In addition to the well-known works by recognized authors who have been thoroughly studied by Trama y Fondo colleagues, such as von Trier, Polanski, Almodóvar, among others...
Secondly:
Both women appear in the center of the story, triggering acts that cause tremendous consequences. Surely, in Fincher's "Perdida," in a deceitful and, if I may say, sloppy way, we almost know what is going to happen. The one who controls the threads of the plot and the others are mere passive spectators of the tragedy that looms over the actors of the drama, almost grotesquely.
In "Magical Girl," the girl's place is taken by a woman, a character in psychiatric treatment, who will also cause death and destruction. Bárbara, a sick woman who takes pills to sleep deeply, but whom no one gives a story, a promise (of love). A woman who enters doors where horror and pain reside. Lost girls in the domestic forest of darkness, who seem to wait, not for a savior, but for the inevitable and voracious arrival of monsters. They are given objects to calm them down, but paradoxically, that does not calm them.
Let's say it already: the critical point, the ignition, the boiling point that seems to hover over both stories, is the impediment or impossibility of these female characters to be mothers. And this leaves them lost. In the center of the story, there is only madness and desolation. Literally. And isn't being a mother or the birth of a life in a woman's body a magical event? Where do we all come from? Could that be the heart of the post-classical story? And also, that to be a mother there has to be a father, and here they are missing, passive, still, stood... no, it is not an attention order from a law enforcement agent, it is literally the husband of the character in "Perdida" who is still, unemployed, and spends his home hours between beers and televised sports, comfortably nestled in his paradise-like home.